@Monica, re: the question you referenced above, I think it's reasonable to ask what Jewish law and tradition say about something that pop culture treats as a rare but laudable accomplishment.
@Monica I'm also not sure why @double seems intent on drawing the OP into detailing exactly what activities he wants to know about. Double, are you trying to gain some clarity, or are you trying to get him to write something easily closable for modesty reasons?
@SethJ Didn't realize it was linked to in here. I was justifying closing it, and closed extremely downvoted questions self-delete.
The question was flawed in that if it ever became clear enough to answer it would be closable as immodest, but until then it was also closable. So: always closable.
Also, I'm hesitant to wield my superpowers unilaterally with immodest questions which are phrased precisely and formally, because I find the line hard to draw on my own.
So why not ask if other wives may be present during biah? There seems to be a lot of unnecessary details here. — Double AA8 hours ago
^^^ Sounds reasonable to me. That'd be defined clearly enough and could be presented without any unnecessary salacious language. It may not be exactly what OP originally wanted, but it seems that it'd probably get answered in the negative, which would, in fact, answer OP's original question (however defined).
@double, @Isaac, @Monica, then just close/delete it. He won't get the answer he wants in any case, and if the community is offended, this isn't the place for it.
Questions in Emunah tend to be about what Jews believe, or the halachos of Jewish Faith. In other religions that sort of thing falls under the topic of theology. Should the tags be made synonymous?
Questions in Emunah tend to be about what Jews believe, or the halachos of Jewish Faith. In other religions that sort of thing falls under the topic of theology. Should the tags be made synonymous?
