8:57 AM
@Oddthinking The recent veg-oil thing: have you read the fuct-chequer article on Insider that forms the basis of the answer? It really exemplifies most of what's wrong with what now counts as 'factchecking'. Zero research into the problem domain. Lots of eminence testimonials. One study as "the research". And that is behind a paywall, so the chances of those FCs not having read it itself increases quite a bit?
Further: the studies this 'research' bases its conclusions on do not support the claimed reach in that review!
That makes the answer here an oblique to the problem counterclaim based on a very superficial and unproductive 'fact-checking' article mixed up with barely connected ad hominem and some spicy opinionated commentary (which doesn't build a bridge out of a swamp but leads further into the woods). In short: echo chamber construction and amplifier for a poorly written article.
2 hours later…
10:45 AM
It is absolutely guaranteed that not a single listener to the advertised podcast can be convinced by what is written here on Echochamberofthemob:SE.
We read in effect: 'claimant is false because he says things 100% compatible with what those fuctcheckers also spat out?' And: 'claimant himself is wrong, because his heritage looks iffy' (not the claim).
You may now say that 'technically, this is a fine answer'. Coz. It has 'references, it's what skeptics crave'. Let's go Brawndo!
But perhaps you understand now that 'fact-checking' is by now a shot-down-in-flames & a burned-to-the-ground word and concept. Answers that rely on those are not needed on a site like this. If this site doesn't strive to be better —much better— than those evil 'fact-checkers', then it has zero purpose on its own, but is a metastasising malignincy. Same for: Testimonials & 'expert'- opinions. These are diametrically opposed to the site's stated mission.
« first day (4242 days earlier) ← previous day next day → last day (543 days later) »
Transcript for
Sep30
Oct '227
Oct11
Hub of Reason
General discussion about skeptics.stackexchange.com