5:58 AM
So I remember @James complaining about 150 messsages on chat.. he should try to be coming early in the morning in Europe... ;-)
so to the questions, I can do some HTML(5), CSS(3) (but I am lousy for design), or reasonable JS/jQuery, PHP, I have some theory, but not much practice... SQL, I can copy-paste commands :D
I think it was perfectly well summarised, the web-thing is easier for users, and desktop easier for us. My vote would be desktop.
As I wrote, I wanted to put up something together to explain what I had in mind when suggesting the whole thing, but you were already discussing that yesterday... :-) So in short words...
My idea was to start the SW, and get a blue map, possibly a blue sphere (3D...?). Without considering ux for the moment, the user could click a "make a map" button, where the shpere would be divided in plates with some assign as oceanic, others continental. And we would implement some tectonic model to make some land appear. Maybe the methods described in the thesis of
that answer.
Biomes could be added, mountains, rivers, etc. refined.
Then politics kicks in, and the SW could help the user to define the different countries and place some cities.
Et voilà, you have your map.
the outputs could be a PNG, a GIS, etc. But it offers also the possibility to view the map around within the SW.
Intended users: everyone who's interested in worldbuilding. So WB SE users, but also, who knows, others. GM, Authors, Curious, etc. Not necessarily technically minded people.
The main idea was that there are those very nice questions, and yes, of course one could follow the manual instructions to build one's map. But if one wants to, e.g., implement fratals, one needs a program for it.
Tectonic calculations, fractals refinement, etc. might require some computing resources. Probably nothing a reasonably modern laptop would not be able to handle of course, but it nevertheless makes more sense to have a desktop app.
In any case, it prevents to have calculations on the server-side.
Do tell me what you think of that description. If you think that's about right, we should copy-paste it into a google or so doc