Math Mods' Office - 2017-09-17

« first day (971 days earlier) ← previous day next day → last day (2427 days later) »

user308168

9:20 AM

I want to talk to a moderator as soon as possible.

user308168

10:47 AM

Moderators! Please unsuspend me. At lease please tell me the main reason of my suspension. So far I have been suspended for more than 10 days while I do not really know its reason. Can other users help me?

user308168

The first time I was suspended (for one week), though I disagreed with it, I knew its reason, so I accepted it and had not any complaint. But I do not really know the main reason of 30-days suspension. Not knowing it is more annoying to me than this suspension. You can suspend me forever, but please tell me the reason.

user308168

The following is the message which has been sent to me by some moderators (or a moderator):
Hello,

I'm writing in reference to your Mathematics Stack Exchange account:

https://math.stackexchange.com/users/87128/mathematicsaminphysics

We've noticed that you've asked many questions, a large number of which were not well received by other members of our community, particularly on the meta site.

Specifically, many of your questions were downvoted and closed because they seemed to be hastily written, or of the type that we'd prefer users refrain from asking. This is a troubling pattern; we'd…

user308168

I can not understand what they meant by "asking many questions". After the one-week suspension, I have only posted one question on the Meta, My posts are off-topic, but similar posts are not, which is not a bad question, as you know well. I also have edited my bad posts on the Meta (You can check it).

user308168

On the main site, do you know that I was one of the top 0.06% of the MSE users in the week before the recent suspension (Please see my reputation graph)?

user308168

Something has been puzzled me very much. About 15 hours before the recent suspension, I had asked a moderator (arjafi) whether I could post a criticizing question on the Meta or not, then he/she had answered me that "constructive criticism should be fine".

user308168

10:53 AM

About 15 hours after this conversation in Math Mods' Office, My account has been suspended and the room was deleted. When this room has been undeleted, I have found that my conversation with arjafi has been removed (It was not offensive, as some moderators know).

user308168

Please tell me the main reason even if it lies outside the SE (like because of my ...); I will not be disturbed. I want to correct my faults.

El'endia Starman

1:18 PM

@WDNWBM FYI, evading a suspension by using an alternate accounts is itself grounds for a suspension. Both of the alt account and possibly lengthening the original suspension. Please reply directly to the mod message you received on Math.SE.

Martin Sleziak

@El'endiaStarman I'll just point out that this user only has Physics.SE account. I suppose that creating math.SE account would count as trying to bypass suspensions.

user308168

@El'endiaStarman I have talked to one of them, but I have not heard the main reason for my suspension.

Martin Sleziak

I assume that this account was created probably mainly due to (somewhat unfortunate) fact that suspension on the site which is parent user for chat account leads to inability to talk in chat: Why can't a user talk in a math.SE chatroom if he/she is banned (suspended) on another SE site?

El'endia Starman

@MartinSleziak Hmm. I'm not sure if having a Physics.SE account counts as bypassing the suspension, but I'm fairly sure that using it to ask about the Math.SE suspension probably does.

Martin Sleziak

A few days ago WDNWBM talked with mixedmath in a private room.

in Mathematics, yesterday, by mixedmath

Very well. Join me in here: https://chat.stackexchange.com/rooms/65652/temp-chat-with-mixedmath

I do not know what was said in that room. (I assume only mods and WDNWBM have access there.)

user308168

1:33 PM

That was not a private room.

Martin Sleziak

But I am pretty sure that math.SE moderator would directly tell them if they had problem with creation of new physics.SE account.

@WDNWBM It certainly is now. (At least I do not have the access there.)

El'endia Starman

@MartinSleziak Yeah. I personally think that's by-design since chat is secondary to the main Q&A sites. If your behavior on a main site is bad enough that you get suspended, why should you keep the privilege of chatting? (That's what I see as their perspective; whether it should be that way is a topic for another time.)

Martin Sleziak

But that's not my point. All I am saying that at least one of the math.SE mods (mixedmath) is aware of your new account.

user308168

No. It was deleted.

El'endia Starman

Even I can't see that private room, and I can see frozen and deleted rooms just fine otherwise. mixedmath intentionally made it private so only you and Math.SE mods could see it.

user308168

1:38 PM

I say again: It was not a private room.

El'endia Starman

It certainly is now.

user308168

I can not see it.

Martin Sleziak

@El'endiaStarman I certainly do not plan to start a lengthy discussion on this. (There are already several threads on meta.SE about this, such as Should a user suspended on the main site be allowed to chat on associated chat-rooms? and Don't extend suspensions from the parent site to chat.)

I've only added what I considered as relevant to the ongoing discussion. I probably should leave this alone - it does not really concerned me. But since I was in a conversation with this user relatively recently, I added the information I knew about this.

El'endia Starman

@MartinSleziak I appreciate your input.

user308168

I hope one day all users know that I have not any problem with them.