« first day (2648 days earlier)      last day (782 days later) » 

Martin Sleziak
Martin Sleziak
7:13 AM
3
Q: Favoriting / bookmarking a question while working the Close Queue?

JonathanZ supports MonicaCIs there a way to favorite / bookmark when you encounter it in the Close Queue? I didn't see the little bookmark icon under the vote count widget (but then I frequently miss elements in the math.se interface). I was using the mobile site on Firefox for Android, if that makes a difference. Also, m...

bug review closing bookmarks
My guess is that the bookmark icon was removed when the review queues were revamped last year. The mockup of the new design in Visual design changes to the review queues does not show the bookmark icon. In that post it is also mentioned, "All review queues will be adopting a new user interface that focuses on providing reviewers with context to make deliberate, thoughtful decisions on review tasks." — The Amplitwist 13 hours ago
My searches on Meta Stack Exchange did not turn up any related posts. It may be worth posting a feature request there :) (And, perhaps the support tag is more appropriate here?) — The Amplitwist 13 hours ago
Although the bookmark button is missing, you could follow the post. Screenshot here; see also Meta.SE post The Follow Questions and Answers feature is now live across the Network — Calvin Khor 2 hours ago
@TheAmplitwist Since you've mentioned Meta Stack Exchange, I'll add a link to this feature request: Can't favorite a question under beta review system. However, that one is from 2012 and it did not get much attention (no comments, a few votes, two edits), less than 50 views. — Martin Sleziak 1 hour ago
@MartinSleziak Ah, I see my mistake was to restrict my search to relatively recent posts. Instead, just looking for posts tagged [review]+[bookmarks] would have brought that up. Thanks! Odd that it hasn’t gathered more attention… — The Amplitwist 22 mins ago
@TheAmplitwist I hope it's ok if I respond here - so that we do not make the comment thread too long.
Even though there is an older feature request, maybe posting a new one might be more reasonable...? (Considering that many things now working rather differently, compared to 2012.)
And it is possible that it might be noticed on this site. (AFAICT the SE staff monitors also per-site-metas for bugs. And the mods sometimes add status-review to make them notice some things.)
Still, it seems not very likely that a network-wide change would be made based on a report from per-site-meta. (Maybe if the change is minor one.)
This isn't something that would matter to me personally too much. But if a few people around here (i.e., on Mathematics Meta) think that this is relevant, I would be willing to add a bounty on Meta Stack Exchange post to draw attention. (Of course, I am fully aware that bounty does not increase the chances that much. But at least it might help getting some attention.)
Hi Martin, I received your ping in your chatroom, thank you for that :) however, I’m on a break from SE chat, and can’t reply there, terribly sorry. (Hope it was alright to ping you under this answer here.) Since my initial guess was way off — the bookmark icon seems to have never been there — perhaps I can remove my comments there? — The Amplitwist 5 mins ago
Despite the fact that we found an older feature request similar to the issue, I think it still might be reasonable to make a new post on Meta Stack Exchange - as @TheAmplitwist suggested. (The site changed a lot since 2012 - so probably the feature request which was posted such a long time ago isn't really relevant now.) — Martin Sleziak 14 secs ago
 

« first day (2648 days earlier)      last day (782 days later) »