I asked my chemistry faculty about the question. He says that your order is correct. Since carbocation stability is RDS..

@Safdar My sir was saying that we have to look at CH- acidity in this question

By the way, which coaching are you studying in?

FIITJEE

I am in Sri Chaitanya

@RobinSingh Did you ask why?

No, but today is my doubt class. I will inquire

chem.ucalgary.ca/courses/350/Carey5th/Ch05/ch5-5.html I don't think CH- even forms since the first step is protonation of alcohol.

@RobinSingh How is prep going on? Corona ko bhaga diya JEE mindset se?

Bhaga toh diya yar

Are u in 13th

12th prepping this year..

Same

Physics weak chal rahi hai abhi toh meri

But, how do you speak Hindi? You are from South, right?

@RobinSingh So? You can still learn hindi right?

Yes, but most people from the south that I have met seem to prefer English

My hindi is not very good though.. I can't talk for extended periods and my vocab is weaker. but I can understand if someone else speaks to me.

@RobinSingh Habit ho gayi abhi, It's fun to segue into hindi when speaking english.

I even placed bounty on that ques but still no answers

@RobinSingh The issue is there is not enough justification for both answers.. the time isn't over yet..

It says bounty expires tomorrow

You will have one more day to manually award.. so 2 more days.

Ohk

Did you upvote all my questions?

@RobinSingh Bounty ka effect ko remove kardhi. nothing much..

Kya?

I went through the question and wasn't sure whether I should upvote before.

@RobinSingh 50 rep deficit ko bhaga di.

Chalo bye. Doubt class start ho gyi

@RobinSingh Ask ok..

@Safdar He said that there was a mistake. If conc. H2SO4 and heat is given then my answer is correct but if only heat is given then his answer is correct. When I asked why he said aisa hi hota hai

Alright.. That was what I was saying.. The issue is that to disprove someone you need actual experimental data. So, it is hard to answer your question.

Can I answer with this? But there is no doubt now tho' is there?? :)

@RobinSingh

But what reason will you offer for the only heat casez?

@RobinSingh Then there would be no protonation taking place, so it should be E1CB

Ohk, I get it. Please write a formal answer

And that would be the opposite rate.

Yes

It will take some time.. I am currently writing an answer for a kinetics question..

Ill get it done by the end of the day..

ok as you wish

@RobinSingh You might wanna edit the question to signify that.

@Safdar What should I change?

Change it to say that your answer is correct for H2SO4 but if it is just heat the opposite order is correct. Ask why this is so..

No, then I'll have to change the title of the question also

You just answer the question saying that my answer is incorrect when only heat is given

@RobinSingh Ok fine :)