@JoshDM I am going to write the Question "What is the best kind of dog to give as a Christmas gift?" To me this seems most likely to be found when that person is searching the web. We can see how it develops, and decide if there should be a separate question for cats, or if the question should be made more generic and just ask about the best kind of "pet".

@JamesJenkins - Are you looking to reword or rollback the edit to that question?

I'll clear out the comments shortly, but I'll leave your comment describing the purpose for a bit.

@JohnCavan, I reworded it a bit. Trying to image how to optimize for searchs.

Cool, I cleaned up the comment discussion too.

You might consider waiting a couple of days and running a google search on some of those common questions to see what arises.

If your question hits high in the results, that would be good.

All - Please do not hesitate to down vote the question pets.stackexchange.com/questions/1520/…

Just don't vote to close, the answer needs to be here

Hmm... I wouldn't (I upvoted), I would much prefer that people ask that question before buying a pet as a gift than just buying the pet... :)

I will ask the Easter Bunny question after the winter holiday. That holiday is specific to that pet, will probably included baby chicks in that question as well.

I do it every year.

@TimPost - hahaha awesome. :D

I may have to mark my calendar for talk like a pirate day...