« first day (2070 days earlier)      last day (2584 days later) » 

12:19 AM
> "Baron," he said and grasped Pampa around his broad waist, "it seems to me you have forgotten an important fact. This famous sword was used by your ancestors only to do battle, for it is written: Do not draw your sword in taverns!"
> [...] "Although the Golden Horseshoe is actually not a tavern, it's just a little corner bistro ..."
> "Some also say," remarked Rumata, "that it is written: Do not draw your sword in the corner bistro!"
There, now I'm halfway through HtBaG. Haven't had time for it for a few days until now.
 
 
2 hours later…
2:13 AM
0
Q: Is calling Queequeg a "cannibal" meant to imply he literally consumed human flesh?

GGMGIshmael and other characters repeated refer to Queequeg as a cannibal, which in modern parlance means that he consumes human flesh. However, the novel doesn't ever say that outright, rather, Ishmael just seems to use the word to indicate that Queequeg was just non-native from a distant land that ...

 
2:37 AM
@Bookworm oohh. I was thinking that last time I read that O_o
 
0
Q: Where did the name Nimitseahpah come from?

MithrandirIn the January 2004 issue of The Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction, they ran a story called "Nimitseahpah", by Nancy Etchemendy. 'Nimitseahpah' is the name of the Paiute statue that's part of the story: "It has a powerful name. Nimitseahpah. The Paiutes never say it aloud. They only whi...

 
2:57 AM
ah yes, the curse of the mithrandir. every question he touches stays unanswered and at 0 score /s
 
3:12 AM
@Riker *facepalm*
Well, I asked the one on top, so I can't vote for it.
The other two I don't know if they're good questions without the book.
@Riker bad news for SFF. I'm the 5th editor for all time there :P
So, back from vacation?
 
 
2 hours later…
5:35 AM
0
Q: Are keteks based on some form of real-life poetry?

muruIn Brandon Sanderson's Stormlight Archive novels, the chapters are grouped into parts, the titles of the parts combining to form a ketek. For example, in the first book, The Way of Kings: Above Silence The Illuminating Storms Dying Storm's Illumination The Silence Above Combined: Above si...

 
@Riker is back!
 
@Gallifreyan yes. Das good.
 
 
3 hours later…
8:42 AM
Hmm. Still no Shakespeare expert came forward to answer literature.stackexchange.com/q/2224/139 "Was the sealed letter ordering Hamlet's death a Biblical reference?"
 
@b_jonas I still think that @Hamlet should answer that one ;)
2
 
 
4 hours later…
12:33 PM
@Mithrandir yep!
@Gallifreyan yep!
 
@Riker o/
 
o/
 
Where did that come from?
 
 
1 hour later…
2:06 PM
mornin
 
morning
@Mithrandir what come from?
the 'o/'?
idk I've almost always used that as a hello sign
 
2:22 PM
@Riker Yeah.
@DForck42 afternoon
 
ah
@Randal'Thor your profile needs updating
that's from the puzzling one fwiw
 
Now I'm off for a day or so. Adieu!
 
see ya!
@Mithrandir ¡adios, mi conocido!
 
@Mithrandir how goes it?
 
 
2 hours later…
4:30 PM
0
Q: YA Adventure/Survival Novel, Written Late 1940's Through Late 1970's

Doug R.I'm trying to find a YA novel that I read sometime between 1977 and 1980 from our public library (after I started reading "big books" in second grade, but before we moved from that town). Two notes: We lived in a small town in Iowa (USA) with an underfunded library that had a lot of older book...

 
 
1 hour later…
5:38 PM
@Riker I know, I know :-/
It's on my to-do list.
Wow! Interesting that the idea of going to sea in a sieve has such a long history. It just goes to show that what may seem a silly and pointless question can nonetheless have an interesting and informative answer. — Rand al'Thor 4 mins ago
 
5:53 PM
@Randal'Thor tempted to ask a question about this cover:
 
That's a ... slightly disturbing cover.
 
@Randal'Thor Exactly! What does it have to do with the book?
 
Well, I haven't finished it yet, so can't comment ;-)
 
By the way, "deciRand" is actually me nodding in the direction of Hard to be a God:
> The Institute should introduce a course dealing specifically with feudal intrigue. And proficiency should be measured in rebas. Better yet, in decirebas.
 
Ha! :-D
Nice. That was a reference I didn't get.
 
6:26 PM
how's everyone?
 
6:38 PM
@DForck42 Evening! Buried in homeworks, as usual. You?
 
@Gallifreyan not too bad. had lunch with the fiancée and her coworker
 
@DForck42 I went out with an old [female] school friend on Tuesday. Some people from 11th grade saw us and immediately thought we were dating. I wonder what kind of rumours they're spreading now :D
 
@Gallifreyan lol
 
6:55 PM
0
Q: Why does Night say Desire and Dream are alike?

GallifreyanIn The Sandman: Overture #5, Dream speaks with Night while paying a "social visit". There, Night claims Dream and Desire are very much alike: I tend to agree with Morpheus on this one. It is true that he acted dumbly by dooming Nada to Hell; he has other quirks as well, like always demanding t...

 
@Bookworm Wow. Less than a minute!
 
@Gallifreyan lol
 
7:16 PM
@Gallifreyan I like your new profile picture! :)
...there's a panel in Doll's House (Part I or II) that's relevant to my question about the witches' names. I'll try to link to it in a comment, at least, if I can find it again.
(I'm partway through Doll's House at the moment)
 
@Shokhet Cheers! His big dark eyes look a lot like mine right now, due to a particularly tiring semester.
 
@Gallifreyan Ha.
The benefit of attending a Jewish college is that I get a break for about 2 weeks for Passover -- both for the break, and the fact that I don't have to miss class for the holiday.
 
8:01 PM
@Shokhet Do you mean this panel?
 
 
1 hour later…
9:07 PM
@Gallifreyan Yes.
I see you're on top of your game :)
...I have a couple of Doll's House questions, but I think those should wait until I'm finished with the book
Maybe I could ask the one about the prologue, but I don't have time today
 
@Shokhet I hope those are not analysis question. I's hell analysing The Sandman
 
@Gallifreyan I'm not sure. I'll give you basic outlines:
1) what the prologue and part IV add to the general storyline (of Dream recovering nightmares) 2) whether the type of story (or particular story) of Nada in the prologue reflect real African myths (more research required to ask that one, but Gaiman really knows his mythology, apparently) 3) what are nightmares for?
...There were more, but those are the ones I remember off the top of my head right now
 
@Shokhet Like that last one. I think it has an answer on the pages of Doll's House though.
 
...so I guess 1 and 2 are sort of analysis (but not quite like your answer for the Ruby question), and 3 isn't really (and I'm not sure whether I'll ask it here or on SFF)
@Gallifreyan Okay, good to know. Like I said, I'll finish reading it before asking
 
@Shokhet I think I even have a lead for that last one. I'm starting to like it :)
 
9:20 PM
@Gallifreyan You get a head start. I'll be offline for the next 2 days :)
 
@Shokhet I'll be busy with my assignments and the physics exam.
 
@Gallifreyan Good luck!
 
@Shokhet Thanks! You too!
 
@Gallifreyan Thank you :)
 
 
1 hour later…
10:43 PM
Oh God. This is exactly the sort of thing I wasn't looking for: nominations for highly-voted stuff which doesn't really deserve all the love it's had. We need to show people our best stuff, not the pap that's happened to hit HNQs. -1 for the entire first section, another -1 for starting with the highest-voted question and answer, another -1 for the Bradbury and Hobbes answers which are mainly based on authorial intent, another -1 for Harry Potter. (Well, I can only downvote once, but you know what I mean.) But thanks for the Humpty Dumpty and haiku posts, which I agree are pretty good. — Rand al'Thor 24 mins ago
Ugh. I was afraid this might happen, but I'm really quite disappointed that @Hamlet of all people upvoted it.
 
user15026
11:20 PM
@Randal'Thor How do you know that? I don't see any clear indication of that
 
Other than that, while most of the content here personally wouldn't be my choice for my nominations for best questions and answers (other than Emrakul's haiku answer, which I added to my list), it's good to get different perspectives, so I gave this answer an upvote. — Hamlet ♦ 4 hours ago
 
user15026
@Randal'Thor ....Okay, I am tired-er than I thought
 
user15026
I somehow completely missed that
 
user15026
I'd agree with you, though - while its great stuff hit HNQ and got votes, I see these posts as ways to highlight the unsung heroes, who didn't get the nice rep bumps.
 
My experience of HNQs is that they tend to be biased towards short, low-effort posts which are correct but also easy to make and easy to understand.
Often trivial questions to which everyone knows the answer. Which makes sense, because lots of people see the question, think "I can answer that", click through, upvote whoever got there first with the answer, and all those upvotes drag the post to HNQ.
This is my go-to example of a god-awful question which got lots of votes from HNQ.
 
user15026
11:32 PM
@Randal'Thor I don't think it's completely God awful. Easily Googled, sure, but not inherently terrible.
 
@Randal'Thor Maybe Himarm wanted some isnight from known Brits here?
 
@Gallifreyan Maybe Himarm wanted some easy rep and badges.
2
</cynical>
 
@Randal'Thor That too. Who's there to blame though? The system, or its products? [attribution needed]
 
user15026
@Randal'Thor I think you are being a little too judgemental
 
@Ash I rely on the fact that I answered that question to soften my criticism of it :-P
 
user15026
11:35 PM
@Randal'Thor your statements here don't really make that cleaer
 
user15026
And verge on disparaging the user themselves rather than the question
 
in Mos Eisley, Sep 18 '16 at 21:30, by Himarm
@NapoleonWilson better start asking stupid harry potter questions for some free rep :P
in Mos Eisley, Mar 25 at 21:46, by Himarm
i just copy paste harry potter quotes for rep
 
user15026
Yes but the fact that you need to bring in all this outside stuff beyond the question to prove it is a bad question or asked on bad faith doesn't automatically make the question bad. Asked with poor motives, perhaps, but you're not really proving a strong point about HNQ
2
 
user15026
Or rather, about this particular question being a poor one and a bad example of HNQ
 
user15026
I can see a world where someone might honestly have this question and think to ask it on SFF
 
11:39 PM
How to earn the Popular Question badge: 1) post a HP question; 2) profit! — Gallifreyan Jan 25 at 18:00
 
@Ash OK then, take one of my top answers on SFF.
Trivial answer - literally a single quote - to something that anyone who's read the books should know.
 
user15026
Well, read to book 5
 
user15026
I haven't. So I wouldn't know.
 
The OP actually self-deleted their question after I'd answered it, because they were getting so much flak in comments for it being a poorly researched question, and we had to undelete it for them.
 
user15026
The assumption that to ask about something you have to have read every part of its body of work is kinda frustrating
 
11:41 PM
Or my very first HNQ answer - again, pretty much just a single quote.
 
user15026
I don't think we are going to see eye to eye using the examples you are providing. I don't disagree with your core point, just how you're currently presenting it. The fact that you rail against stuff you have profited from in terms of rep gain is also somewhat odd
 
user15026
Because if you have such a problem with them, you shouldn't engage, otherwise you perpetuate them, no?
 
@Ash I'm not saying these questions are invalid (poorly researched maybe, but still valid questions). But the answers are low-effort and yet get scores of upvotes.
 
user15026
So how can the questions be more valid? Is the problem then not with your answers?
 
@Ash No. I answered those questions because I knew the answer, not because I wanted to get 100+ score answers out of them.
Some questions can only be answered with single, simple quotes.
Others need loads of research and effort to answer properly.
My problem is with the HNQ system (which tends to reward the former rather than the latter), not with the answers themselves.
 
user15026
11:45 PM
Sorry, typing on my phone.
 
user15026
I'm not sure then what your actual argument is, in terms of your original point about poor quality stuff hitting HNQ
 
True that. Single Google search for that; 2 hours of some sleuthing through 50 megabyte PDFs for this one; reading through 12+ volumes of a series for this one. Guess which one has the most upvotes?
It's like Martin Eden and his literary struggles.
 
@Ash While quick low-effort answers and super well-researched ones can both be valid in different contexts, HNQ rewards the former rather than the latter, even though I think we'd all agree that the latter is more worthy of reward.
2
That's it in a nutshell, basically.
 

« first day (2070 days earlier)      last day (2584 days later) »