@Hamlet I have no desire to enter the discussion because everything I'd want to say has been said, but I think you did the right thing by posting a meta answer. Even if people disagree, or maybe even in those few cases where you absolutely screwed up (I'm not saying this was one), the best thing to do is to always explain your actions. I can't count how many times that transparency has turned out well for me as a mod and the site as a whole.
2