Conversation started Feb 23, 2018 at 6:04.
user131753
Feb 23, 2018 06:04
"I would be glad to know a partial list (at least of ten posts) which has been undeleted or reopened by the CRUDE users and also has been mentioned in the room. No need to respond to me here (if at all) I also visit the CRUDE room sometimes and so you can respond there also (if at all)."
Martin Sleziak
Martin Sleziak
As you suggested, I have added link to this discussion in comments under the meta post - although I am not sure whether it really is that useful. (It is definitely not list of at least ten posts as you requested - just a suggestion how one might find such discussions.)
user21820
user21820
@user170039 I see. So the two links I gave are considered instances you are looking for, right? In any case, I hope you're aware that the junk to gem ratio among the deleted posts is like 1000:1, so it would of course be unreasonable to expect as many undeletions mentioned in CRUDE as deletions. (I'm not saying you do, but certainly there will be many users who wrongly see this disparity as unfairness, which is a logical fallacy.)
user131753
@user21820 It may also give substantial (quantitative?) insight into the main focus of this room.
user131753
Which may hopefully help to evaluate eventually whether such deletions (and, probably, closure too) is indeed coordinated by folks in the CRUDE room, as @Jack claims.
user21820
user21820
Feb 23, 2018 06:23
@user170039 Whether it is coordinated is a red herring to the real issue of whether it is beneficial for the site. Like I said in my Meta post and in many other comments there and here, you don't criticize cleaners from cooperating in cleaning up after people leave their dirt lying around, right?
 
Conversation ended Feb 23, 2018 at 6:23.