Oct 10, 2012 17:29
@JonEricson we say all questions must start from the text. Where that question is weak is that it starts from a text and a doctrine and gives them both equal weight. That's probably why it slipped under the radar - I think it should probably be closed. The spirit of our rule is that a question should start from the text only (or largely), isn't it?
I think this is a great example of where bh.se will succeed by side-stepping the kind of questions that just get us bogged down and keep it's focus on answerable questions
"Given those two facts as axiomatic" :-)
thats the deciding line in the Q for my money
