« first day (149 days earlier)      last day (4892 days later) » 

12:09 AM
0
Q: Handle Marine (often + Bunker) Rush as a Zerg

YgamAs a bronze leaguer, I got a taste of Diamond League Terrans and I have got to say their gameplay was superb. 3 games against diamond all ended up in one crushing defeat: via Marine or Marine + Bunker Rush. The maps were Xelnaga Caverns and Steppes of War.They either harassed me with two or 5 ma...

 
12:21 AM
This speech is fascinating and more than worth the 15 minutes it'll take to watch:
@badp This is my freehand interpretation of your drawing, which was a drawing of tzenes's drawing
 
They have just implemented badges on the Parent Site for Meta performance
 
I saw that
seems odd. I guess it's to encourage people to check out meta?
 
@sjohnston Always a good thing, in my opinion.
And, bonus points, it's a badge that Jon Skeet can never get on Stack Overflow!
 
why?
 
Stack Overflow has no associated Meta site.
 
12:36 AM
wait...meta.stackoverflow is not associated with stackoverflow? In what world does that make sense?
 
@sjohnston Meta Stack Overflow is the capital, it came before the per-site-meta business, and it runs its own reputation scheme.
It's used for general Stack Exchange business in addition to Stack Overflow stuff.
 
hmm
I also noticed that the tags list in your user profile now shows the total score you have for that tag, which I like a lot
 
kind of like how DC is the capital of the US, but not Maryland
 
I would not have guessed that my highest value tag is Starcraft 2. Although I think that shows how big starcraft 2 is, rather than me having any level of expertise
 
If I can post 8 more awesome posts on Meta discussions, I can get Meta Gaming's first silver tag badge.
@tzenes That would be an adequate analogy
...wait a minute...
I bet I can blame @Mana for this.
 
12:42 AM
?
 
If there was a badge for "Post the same message to chat on three occasions, and have each one starred", then @badp would win it. The only logical conclusion is that Mana is at fault. Either directly, indirectly, or by happenstance.
 
you think mana stars things too much?
 
No, Mana wasn't even around for any of the incidents
 
I believe he's just the new Gaming scapegoat
 
Wait, no, he was around for the latest one. But he wasn't active around the first two.
And so because he wasn't active when those were starred, one can only conclude that Mana is at fault.
 
12:46 AM
badp wasn't around or mana wasn't around?
 
@tzenes Mana wasn't around. badp was around because badp posted all 3 instances, and would be the badge recipient
 
Shouldn't you people be playing games or something?
 
@CRoss Multi-tasking~
 
what what what
my name's being mentioned at least 10x more than usual. Something's up
 
@Mana You have a very common term in gaming for a name. It should not be a surprise to hear it often. There's nothing suspicious going on. ♪
 
12:58 AM
we were just talking about how pretty you look today
 
oh, that's cool
 
1:11 AM
maaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaan, that One Chance game was pretty dark
good thing I got it right on the first try apparently
 
One Chance?
 
spoiler alert: you only have One Chance unless you cheat and clear your cache
in which case you have as many chances as you like
kind of ruins it I guess
 
1:24 AM
for all you jinro fans: tackfilm2.se/?id=1292005131236ID764
 
That is a pretty dark game
 
what did I just watch @tzenes
 
@Mana I hadn't actually played that yet...I think everyone but my daughter and I died, hm.
 
@Tim same ending as me then
 
I guess that's...good...heh.
Though the other events were rather unfortunate :/
 
1:37 AM
Yes.
Say a younger sibling asks you for a mediocre new Tomb Raider game for Christmas. Is it lame to buy them the original Tomb Raider trilogy instead?
 
G'day all. :)
 
Hullo hullo!
How's it going?
 
Entirely too warm.
Oh, hey @Jin
 
Jin
howdy
 
Heeeeeeeeey Jin.
 
1:47 AM
Wow, that game was pretty dark.
 
Mainly stopping by at @CRoss's suggestion to see if anyone's interesting in taking a seat at our chat-based D&D game. We're looking for 2 more players :)
 
oh man, that sounds cool, although I haven't played D&D before
How much do I need to stress over stats?
 
That ... isn't a problem
 
Jin
has anyone played Resonance of Fate?
 
not at all. As this is the middle of a scenario, you'll be grabbing a pregen
Hardly used :)
and I'll be happy to go over the mechanics.
 
Jin
1:48 AM
I saw a trailer for it, apparently it came out a while back. looks interesting to me: youtube.com/watch?v=d326pL1MM-s
 
oh, and we'll be using wave, so what browser do you use?
 
oh, hey, Wave!
 
@mana, drop by The Back Room if you're interested. :)
 
Chrome, though I also have Firefox
 
yeah
cool. The map plugin fails in firefox for some reason. Very odd
I use chrome and everything's happy :)
 
1:50 AM
Heh.
 
So yeah, you're welcome to join.
 
Which Back Room chat is this?
I'm in one right now but nobody's there
 

 The Back Room: Live Tabletop Games

A space for online tabletop gaming.
Ah, that's probably the in-character room.
 
No, turns out it was the right room
 
 
1 hour later…
3:02 AM
@Jin Resonance of Fate? I was actually looking into it. Haven't played it, but was interested
 
Jin
@GraceNote it looks really good... see gameplay: youtube.com/watch?v=0qwGntLfdao
i'm a sucker for gunkata
 
@Jin Well! If I wasn't already sold by the concept and by the style of dress, that demonstration certainly did it! Now I regret not grabbing it at the store four months ago!
 
Jin
@GraceNote well, on the bright side, the game is a lot cheaper now.
 
@Jin That is true.
 
STILL ALIVE is the most optimistic battle victory message ever.
 
Jin
3:10 AM
@mana maybe we need to implement more optimistic badges to SE/SO....
[STILL HAVE MORE REPS THAN 3000 OTHER USERS] badge anyone?
2
 
!!!SUPER USER!!! -- Hit the 50 rep mark.
 
Hm... standard price: $59.99
Amazon price: $19.99. Save $40, or 67%.
 
Jin
@GraceNote still???
 
I'm hard pressed to see why I should not jump on this offer, considering this is the price for a new copy.
 
Jin
@Mana i'd still like to see a [C-C-C-C-COMBO BREAKER!] badge.. need to work it in somehow
 
3:14 AM
I almost asked "Should I get it for 360 or PS3?" before I remembered that if I want to actually understand what's being said it's going to be PS3.
 
Jin
i doubt i'll never get a ps3
i thought about getting it at one point for Meta Gear Solid 4
I barely play my xbox360 as it is
 
@Jin I avoided it for a long time, but then Trinity Universe came out.
Measured up with enough exclusives or other reasons, it ended up being purchased.
Crepes, Amazon's having like a super-sale on video games right now, or summat.
 
Jin
is FF13 any good?
i'm making a list of games to play over Xmas break.
 
@Jin Not tried it. I've heard very mixed reviews.
 
Jin
I think j-rpg era is over.
 
3:19 AM
It still lives in various ways, but more interactive combat is... honestly many times more exciting than menu navigation.
I still love it, like in Etrian Odyssey 3.
 
Jin
i'm a "tweaker" when it comes to rpgs. I love spend hours just in the menu tweaking my characters. i'm kind of out of loop with recent j-rpg games
the last time i was excited about was Front Mission, but it turned out wasn't a rpg form
 
@Jin Oh, that hasn't gone anywhere but even more complex and even more numbercrunchy.
In a good way, I mean
 
Jin
@GraceNote is it out?
 
Between finally escaping the limits of 99 levels to all kinds of experimentation in class systems and stat systems and meteorite rings...
@Jin Front Mission? The last Front Mission I played was the original, so I'm more than a bit behind on that.
I was talking about tweaking of characters between either optimization or just tweaking them to your style.
...d'oh, BlazBlue is not on sale.
 
BlazBlue~~~!!!
man, that game's plot is all kinds of crazy awesome
and also one of the few games where I really really like the English voice acting
especially for Jin
geez they chose Jin's VA well
 
3:29 AM
@Jin no, it is not
 
@Mana All of the English voice acting is good. And aye, Jin is excellent.
I own the original, I'm looking into Continuum Shift, though, for naught but the obvious reason of more content.
 
I want to find out what happens to Hazama :(
 
We should both buy it. Then, we can add more BlazBlue questions to the site.
 
haha, yeah
I'm not very good at it in a competitive context though since I mainly play it for the plot
 
Jin
I concur, Jin is great...
6
 
3:32 AM
Haha
 
0
Q: "Disconnected from server" more often?

BeemerGuyI've noticed this very recently and I don't recall reading something about in any of the recent patch notes. I hop on a flying route and, as any normal human being, get bored of watching the bird flapping its wings all the way until I reach my destination 5 minutes later, so I alt-tab to go br...

 
4:18 AM
mastbrotherschocolate.com so fucking good.
 
0
Q: kinect go hard in the paint

zmoneydo have to have internet on your xbox360 to activate the kinect

 
@Feeds Can anyone explain the title of this one to me?
 
4:41 AM
...
scratches head
 
4:57 AM
0
Q: How to kill the Last Hunter?

HarshHow do I kill the last hunter in prototype?

 
5:16 AM
hi all
 
'Ello
 
5:30 AM
Blegh, having a hard time staying logged into chat on dialup. Whenever it times out, it makes me log in again.
 
@FallenAngelEyes Hm, there are some ongoing problems with chat.SE too, so if not your connection that might be to blame.
 
5:51 AM
I'm not sure if anyone noticed but look at the first link in this post: gaming.stackexchange.com/questions/12488/…
 
ha
@Feeds did anyone understand what paint had to do with internet connectivity?
Ugh, just started playing my first shooter in a while. I had forgotten how much I suck at them.
 
6:08 AM
That didn't really clarify for me
 
what shooter @sjohnston?
 
Borderlands
 
ah
 
aaaghhhhhhh. Finals. :(
 
7:37 AM
Why youtube has to work so hard to prevent people on slow connections from watching (= downloading) their videos.
 
7:55 AM
↑ "no" in Japanese.
I guess it's a language that encourages you to be positive, if a negation takes seconds to write
 
Woo... our internet speed is going to be doubled ASAP
 
0
Q: How do you deal with Reapers

tzenesI'm on the second run in with Ophilia's army and I'm having a bit of trouble dealing with her Reapers. In addition to killing me when I get with in 30 feet, they also seem to be just as effective against my other troops. How do I manage that situation?

 
@ArdaXi Yeah, it was definitely too slow.
 
@badp I only got like 4.5 MB/s (36 mbit) or something.
 
@ArdaXi Poor boy, I feel your pain.
 
8:01 AM
So now we're upgraded to 120 mbit
 
8:20 AM
@Feeds I was confused by this question title/asker combo until I saw the Brutal-Legend tag
 
Tzenes? Asking questions?
 
SHOCKER
 
@LessPop_MoreFizz Obvious typo. goes change to "rapers"
 
@ArdaXi not just asking questions
but about REAPERS
I forgot for a second that more than one game has reapers.
also, holy shit are some of the new raid bosses in Cataclysm fun
We are fighting a blind dragon atm
if you get hit by his sonar shit he starts spamming breath attacks in your direction and such
 
5 messages moved to Die2Nite
 
 
1 hour later…
10:00 AM
0
Q: What to use to identify keys without looking?

Brian OjedaAll to often I hit one of the hot keys that surounds the moment keys. This a big problem in World of Warcraft when flying high on mount and hitting any action key that causes the toon to unmount. So, what is a good things to use to help identify keys with out looking down at the keys? I want to...

 
10:27 AM
@Feeds I want to move this to programmers.
 
@badp We can only move to gaming meta, or?
 
@Fabian Currently, yes.
 
The question is not really gaming-specific, you could ask it without even mentioning any game
 
11:03 AM
0
Q: Lich King raids are still available or disabled?

BeemerGuyI absolutely missed all the Icecrown quests and most of all the quest to kill the Lich King. Are these quests still available after Cataclysm release? Or would they disable them since it makes no sense chronologically? If they are still there, are they 5-man or 10-man raids? Do people still pl...

 
11:15 AM
0
Q: Help me identify late 80's-early 90's arcade game please! Going crazy!!!

Erik ClarkMy memory is so hazy on it. i just have a few vague recollections of being at the cabinet playing, i never got to play it more than a few times. It was a vertical and sometimes side scrolling shooter i think, but you were a character not a ship or anything like that. mabye you use physical attack...

 
12:00 PM
Whoops, didn't notice that ITG had no ITG tag.
 
12:21 PM
bad Mana!
is having a bad case of DVORAK
 
12:39 PM
damn it, what's with sequels these days and returning back to the original titles :(
 
"SQUARE ENIX is proud to announce the world-wide reveal of..." "OH MAN HYPE HYPE HYPE" "...TOMB RAIDER" "...o_O???"
 
even faster
5 mins now
 
they improved on that time?!
geez.
 
> The Lakitu Skip went through many iterations before we got this result. There was the first one (frame 1812) which tied the previous run. Then we managed 1810 with the forward jump kick trick. Shortly after uploading our WIP, Moltov had a brilliant idea to use the slope in the manner you see in our current run. That achieved 1807 the first time through. Days later, we tried a bit more and figured out long jumping into the slope would be slightly faster. Thus came 1805.
> Then the final version came about days before the run finalization. Somehow we managed to get more speed off of the slope and recover a frame sooner giving us 1803 (a total of 9 frames over the previous run).
 
12:48 PM
0
Q: Cyborg F.L.Y 5 VS X

wordWhat's different? Which is better?

 
@LessPop_MoreFizz that's a train wreck ...
 
1:04 PM
For the above question...better part is subjective?
Also one of the sentences there in the author comments demonstrates why I love French
> Au debut du secteur 7, la tension est proche de son paroxysme, d'autant que ce secteur est precede par une scene < cinematique > qu'on ne peut abreger. Les battements de c?ur deviennent ostensibles, tandis que la vision se brouille l'espace d'un instant... mais je divague, pardonnez-moi.
English could never capture so beautifully in prose the tension one feels during sector 7 of Jumper Redux!!!!
or at least during the intro.
 
1:27 PM
@LessPop_MoreFizz I was expecting some hot Kinect action there... "shake boobs horizontally == vertical scrolling"
 
0
Q: Update old answers according to patch notes for unreleased patch

FabianThe announced Civilization 5 December patch will change quite a lot of gameplay elements and it will invalidate some old answers on this site. The changes will render some answers factually incorrect, an example is the question about buying courthouses or the question about research overflow. S...

 
1:51 PM
-1
Q: What is the password for Assassins Creed Broherhood full game.rar ????

ahmadmustafa007Hi guys!!! live in Middle Asia, there is no store to buy the game from, so I downloaded the game which is 2.25 GB from the net. I try to extract it but it asks for a password,,, I really wnt to play the game. CAN SOMEONE HELP ME??? IT WOULD BE SO KIND OF YOU TNX IN ADVANCE TANKS ALOT

 
To quote the immortal words of Sweet Bro and Hella Jeff:
> ahahahahahahaha just HOW high do you even have to BE just to DO something like that..........
 
@Feeds Burn it with fire
 
2:08 PM
hope it will work @CRoss ;)
 
What games have you been playing recently, @Ivo?
 
 
well I play SC2 nearly daily @GraceNote (together with @TomWij)
 
Google Directions, now with Superman routing. It needs some work though.
 
and I just bought Kinect with Dance Central and Your Shape
 
2:12 PM
Ah, I see
 
I recently became self-employed and though my boss is awesome, I do feel guilty if I play too much ;)
 
I have the best boss of all time. The boss is me. I am the boss.
 
Heh. Have you setup a work schedule or do you do something more of a flex-time-as-long-as-I-clock-X-hours-a-week thing?
 
I try to work regular hours
but my girl friends a nurse, so she has the worst schedule ever
 
@Mana You should be nearing finals for your courses this semester, neh?
 
2:15 PM
plus I'm on Stack Exchange all the time
 
@Grace Oh ya. First final is on the 16th.
 
so I have to make longer hours, to actually get some productive hours in a day :P
 
@IvoFlipse Why is it that a hefty fraction of my friends have girlfriends in the medical profession
@Mana Are you prepared for it?
 
hehe you consider me a friend eh? ;-)
 
I consider everyone here a friend. I like this community.
 
2:16 PM
hehe, well played :D
 
@Grace yup! It's first-year comp sci, so it's just studying up on different sorts of ADTs + sorting algorithms
 
well the fact that I'm here speaks for itself doesn't it
 
Heh
 
Yeah, everyone here's really cool. I don't really visit the site anymore for rep so much as I do for the community.
 
will you still be my friend if I go after your mod spot? ;)
 
2:18 PM
@IvoFlipse If you plan on running, please do so.
 
well I just miss my mod tools on any site I visit
hate having to use mod flags myself :P
 
Speaking of mods...where has Juan been these days?
 
@Mana This just reminds me of when one of my professors forced us to use a sorting algorithm to arrange the papers when we handed our tests in
 
I never see him on chat D:
 
some people have a life @Mana ;)
 
2:19 PM
@IvoFlipse I feel the same on some of the other sites I poke around in
@Mana Juan is married with kids. He has a very busy life, but he's still active.
 
ahhhhh
woooow
What a cool guy.
 
I think the reasoning behind inhibiting it is kind of flawed, we all were chosen because we understand how the system works. We wouldn't even consider abusing our powers on sites where we don't know the community well enough
 
@IvoFlipse Then you have sites like Maths that groan when Jeff does moderatory stuff
 
I wouldn't even dare moderating on Math, hence the problem solves itself
 
Do you know communities well enough to judge whether or not they would consider any use of your power "abuse"?
 
2:22 PM
though if I see a spam post, I would delete it anywhere
I would often only use it for cleaning up @badp
though I feel like I know Gaming and Android well enough to pitch in when I spot something else
and I know how to leave comments, so my actions can be tracked by community members
and the SE-folks are quick enough with raising pitch forks, that's for sure
 
Nice pitch, but my vote is still for @GraceNote (although her littering Meta with chat replies is kind of annoying).
 
@badp I clean it up, you know
 
I know you do, and it breaks the conversation you are replying to.
 
I think it's awesome
 
Not really. Every message I've had to delete has either been reposted on Chat or was not replied to
 
2:25 PM
well @badp, I actually believe they should re-evaluate their SE-network moderating scheme
because I surely don't want to replace and of the pro-tempore mods
2
 
I would email instead of using commenting, but for the same reasons that I don't log into chat at work, I don't log into my non-work email.
 
so...@Grace, will you be self-nominating?
 
@Mana Most likely. I expect a lot of flak once I do, but I figure I should still be in the running.
 
wait what a lot of flak? Why?
Personally I think you've done an excellent job as mod so far so I really can't see anyone complaining about it.
 
Don't interpret this as being melodramatic or anything: I'm fine because I stand by every decision I make. But I'm without a doubt the least popular of the 3 pro tems, by virtue of actually doing things people will complain about.
 
2:30 PM
Huh.
 
@GraceNote That only means you do the most
 
@badp The most visibly aggravating stuff. Oak actually outdoes me, you have no idea how much junk and spam he is responsible for deleting nearly every day.
 
The meta commenting was not really a complaint, merely a comment
 
I don't know which meta comment you're referring to
 
8 mins ago, by badp
Nice pitch, but my vote is still for @GraceNote (although her littering Meta with chat replies is kind of annoying).
 
2:32 PM
Oh, I didn't take that as a complaint. I imagine you were being playful
 
It was merely a comment, I know you'd do the right thing if you could.
bbl
 
It's mostly closings. It's not actually a big amount of anything, but I'm only the least popular in comparison to Juan and Oak, consider it that way. It's not saying that I'm "unpopular".
But comments on the nominations phase is the perfect opportunity for people to air out any concerns they had about any of the controversial or questionable actions that the pro tems may have done during their terms.
 
@Grace I'd be hard pressed to find a single thing I think you did wrong. There were a number of times where I disagreed with you, but never once where I disagreed with an action you took
4
 
In honesty, I'm more worried about what I'm going to even write on my nomination form than about any of the complaints I'm likely to receive.
Maths had it lucky - they have a very professional atmosphere and they conduct themselves on a daily basis in a very professional manner
 
Your long posts on meta regarding important issues on the site should be your strongest focus, in my opinion.
I would nominate you simply based on this alone
 
2:42 PM
0
Q: What happens to ranged promotions when the unit becomes melee?

OakSome upgrade paths transform a unit from a ranged one to a melee one - for example, a crossbowman normally upgrades to a rifleman. However, ranged units get different damage-increasing promotions from melee units. What happens to those ranged-damage promotions in that case? Do they still apply, ...

 
Thank you, @tzenes. And thank you, @Mana.
 
If I end up self-nominating I'm going to have a hell of a hard time figuring out what to write for myself though. My participation on meta has been virtually non-existent.
The only thing I think I do that makes me feel like I might be an okay mod is that I'm quick to edit/flag problematic questions/answers.
 
You are very quick at that.
 
But really, that's not enough. I need to participate more in helping the site grow.
 
regarding the spam would be a reason why I want to be a mod here too @GraceNote
 
3:01 PM
@GraceNote You are awesome. Get over it.
 
@badp But how would I transcribe that awesomeness?
 
If you don't have words of your own, use ours.
 
@Grace " I'm the best mod on this site. DEAL. "
That's it. Nothing else.
 
Haha
Technically, it's more of an issue that I have too many words. Thankfully, I still have a week to figure it all out.
 
"Hi, I am Grace Note blah blah blah the diamond with the musical notes blah blah blah you know you aren't going to read this blah blah blah never gonna let you up, never gonna get you down."
 
3:04 PM
Hi, @kalle43!
 
Oh hullo!
 
you don't need to transcribe it, you'll get testimonies @GraceNote ;)
 
@IvoFlipse And for a sudden moment, the only thing that popped in my head was "mod-rec"
3
 
lol
 
3:19 PM
I forget, if someone puts Thanks at the end of their question, do we remove it?
I just feel like a bit of a jerk every time I do that.
 
@Mana Usually, only if you have other things to edit.
 
Oh, ya.
 
Signatures are disallowed, but simple salutations don't need to be cropped out on sight
 
Makes sense.
 
6
Q: Moderator nominations

Ivo FlipseRobert Cartaino recently announced the following on Meta Stack Overflow: The nominations for moderator elections will start about 30 days after a site graduates from beta. Moderator nominations will not be conducted as a meta thread, as they were done with the original sites. We are in t...

Your nightmare is my command.
 
3:23 PM
I wonder where we came up with the thought that there'd only be one moderator. Especially with time zones
 
3:33 PM
0
Q: C&C4 says I need more command posts

Mark RobinsonPlaying C&C4. When I try to build beyond my unit cap (50) there is a female voice that says, "We need more command posts." How can I capture more? How can I get the unit cap beyond 50?

 
4:07 PM
Wow, the guys at tasvideo uploaded a shitton of stuff in the last 3 days
 
0
Q: What actions earn XP in The Guild 2?

C. RossWhat actions earn XP in the Guild 2? What action generates the most XP?

 
4:48 PM
0
Q: Chance of being discovered by zombies as a scout?

FabianIf playing a Scout in Die2Nite, how likely is it to be discovered by zombies and therefore being unable to leave the square? Does the chance depend on the number of zombies? And are there any other factors determining it?

 
 
2 hours later…
6:43 PM
There's nothing more depressing than shoveling the driveway and walkways and coming back to the house, only to discover that there's more snow in the driveway than there was when you started.
 
@sjohnston If you can't fight it, join it!
 
join...the snow?
 
Fall with the snow! Stay with the snow! Be the snow!
 
1
Q: Can I play Call of Duty on the Xbox with someone on the PC?

VaccanoCan I play Call of Duty Black Ops with someone on the PC if I am playing on an XBox? Or do they keep them separate? I could see why they would. A Keyboard and Mouse seems to give more control (at least to me). That may be considered an unfair advantage.

 
7:32 PM
Does anyone know if Blizzard does a Holiday sale around Christmas time like Steam does?
 
If they do I will end my life since I bought SC2 last week
okay that was a bit of an overreaction
I will be disappoint.
 
8:05 PM
@RavenDreamer Historically they haven't. But they have spent this year significantly improving their online storefront.
 
wonders why @CRoss accepted my answer over Powerlord's...
 
I thought it was clearer
I upvoted his too, but yours was formatted better, etc
 
I remember that that particular question (and my answer) was a cause of some upset.
 
Odd that I didn't notice that
it being my question
why were people upset?
 
I'm not terribly sure anymore, @GraceNote obliterated most of the comments.
It had something to do with Powerlord claiming I stole content from his answer or something.
 
8:22 PM
Which question's that?
 
9
Q: Team Fortress 2 - What are the vintage items?

C. RossIn playing Team Fortress 2 after the most recent update I've noticed a lot of "Vintage" items. What's different about these items? How can I acquire more?

aww, chat ruins referral links :(
 
Arda...
Your answer...
is really good!
 
Mana...
 
Quick question: Can moderators transform an answer to a comment on a specific answer?
 
No...
it isn't.
 
8:31 PM
@Fabian Nope :(
 
Would be useful, users without enough rep to comment often write answer that really should be comments
 
I still don't get why commenting requires more rep than answering.
 
Because if you can't post an answer when you're starting out at a Q&A site, something about the fundamental logic of it all causes the universe to implode.
@LessPopMoreFizz Target's got a sale on the WoW battlechest (Classic + BC) for $20. I'm debating throwing down for it. I missed the black friday sale where I coulda gotten Classic through Wrath for $25. :(
 
9:00 PM
0
Q: In Team Fortress 2, which melee weapons have the longest attack range? shortest?

Mark RogersWhile it's easy to find damage data for melee weapons in TF2 (this question for example), it's difficult to find the range of melee weapons. The eyelander is described as being longer than the demoman's other weapons, but what is the actual range of various weapons. Does anyone know the reach o...

 
9:29 PM
@ArdaXi That was Oak, not me
 
Oh.
You have obliterated comments before, right?
 
Or possible Juan. But I was pretty sure it was Oak
Yes, and I've tracked which ones I have. The only one I recall you being in is the FRAPS debacle
 
Well... that's what I was confused with. shifts eyes
 
@ArdaXi Focus of the website is getting answers. We don't want people just willy-nilly running around just posting comments, because they're secondary for existence. For every comment that we get which is useful for clarification or solution, we get 3+ that are just off-hand remarks or otherwise unnecessary content.
That's why comments require reputation. If you want to shoot the breeze, show that you want to be part of the community by contributing real content first.
 
I remember when SO didn't have comments.
(Okay, no, I don't, but there were such times IIRC.)
 
9:32 PM
@GraceNote So you mean the ratio of good : bad is higher with answers than with comments?
 
@ArdaXi Extended comment discussions throw that ratio off, but otherwise on average I would deign to say yes.
The other point of interest is that we can track answers easily.
Junk answers bump things to the front page, we have like a half dozen utilities in the 10k tools for detecting junk answers, and it's easy to flag and find junk answers for deletion
 
the idea of a Q&A site is that if you're not writing a question and you're not writing an answer then it's not really important
 
Comparatively, comments do not bump, possess no methods of tracking, and are easy to overlook due to their miniscule nature.
 
if you make a Q&A site where questions, answers and comments are on the same level, you've just made a phpbb clone :P
(or a hackernews clone or a reddit clone or whatever it is kool kids use today.)
 
2
A: Lower commenting threshold to 1 rep

Jeff AtwoodWe funnel users to the answer input box for a reason -- because the focus is on getting answers to questions, not meta-commentary. Commenting is a privilege that should be earned by providing useful answers. And 50 rep isn't much. It's highly unlikely a random drive-by user will understand our...

This is what happened in the most recent attempt to lower comment reputation threshold.
 
9:39 PM
0
Q: Black Ops: How to determine if someons is 'hacking'?

RobbI've played games with some friends and they claimed that so-and-so was hacking. I honestly just thought that he was a really good player. What are some indications that someone is actually cheating?

 
 
1 hour later…
10:42 PM
0
Q: WOW casual player - is a couple of hours a week do able realistically

JonHi, I used to play EverQuest and loved it but it took up a lot of my time. I now have a family of three. a 1hr 40 min commute each way to work and life seems to be rather busy these days. So my question is, is it possible to play WoW for a few hours a week and actually get something out of it...

 
11:10 PM
@Feeds oh god is that one begging for a close vote
 
11:39 PM
0
Q: What use is the shotgun for the heavy?

Thomas McDonaldTypically my loadout for the heavy is: Minigun Sandvich Gloves of Running Urgently However, some of the players I play with (a 32-player server, but I have a reasonably close knit group of people I play Highlander with) have been moaning rather loudly about the amount of time I spend eating m...

 

« first day (149 days earlier)      last day (4892 days later) »