@ratchetfreak The main differences is that yeah, you need ash too to make the Porcelain Clay, and the strings of the sieve worn out after some uses(but can be changed to last forever like 1.7.10 Ex Nihilo)
Well, but there's still the early depressive game of getting enough dirt to make a few cobblestones to get your first bucket of lava for your cobble generator
I'd almost say the the extra trees from the ash should help once the starter chest of bonemeal runs out, but then again that requires 8 cobble to start with
which actually makes the initial cobblegen even more annoying to get...