last day (15 days later) » 

3:58 PM
-2
Q: What is the mapping relationship in this odd form?

xmh0511Generally, according to the definition in wikipedia, given f(x) = x, x∈[-1,5], we say f is the mapping: X → Y. Where X is the domain, namely [-1,5] However, consider this odd form, given function g(x+1) = x, x∈[-1,5], its domain X is still [-1,5] but its form is different from the first function,...

 
It is not clear what you mean by "we say f is the mapping: x -> Y".
 
@AnneBauval It's the definition of a function in the linked article.
 
No it is not. "the mapping: X -> Y" makes no sense. Can you please clarify your question? A cleaner formatting might help, but won't suffice.
 
Note that the function is a map from the domain into the range. The domain isn't a variable $x$. You're likely wanting to say $ f: [ -1, 5] \rightarrow Y$?
 
@CalvinLin Have updated the question.
 
3:58 PM
Your notation is all over the place. Distinguish between capital and lower case, please.
$f(x+1)=x$ is an equation with respect to $x$. You would be asking which $x$ in the domain of $f$ satisfy said equality.
 
How do you know that "the domain X is still [-1, 5]"? Can you explain your reasoning? EG What is $f(-1)$ equal to, and how did you obtain that from the condition?
 
@CalvinLin I have updated the question, and given a distinguishable notation to avoid the ambiguous.
 
Can you clarify what is the set "X+1"? EG What is the set "$[-2, 2] +1$"? $\quad$ Also, please answer my previous question where I asked you to explain the reasoning (You stated "its form is different from the first function", which isn't an explanation for "why that is the domain")
 
@CalvinLin Sorry, that's the wrong expression. I don't know how to express the mapping relationship for the function g(x+1) = x.
 
When its domain is $X$ and its codomain is $Y,$ $f$ is a (not the) "mapping $X\to Y$". Now, again (as AlvinL already asked you) when $f$ is defined by "$f(x+1) = x, x\in[-1,5]$", what is the domain of $f?$ i.e. what is the set of elements $t$ such that $f(t)$ is defined?
 
3:58 PM
@AnneBauval Now, when 𝑓 is defined by "𝑓(𝑥+1)=𝑥,𝑥∈[−1,5], what is the domain of 𝑓? Isn't the [-1,5] is the domain of this f?
 
No. Please think it over.what are the $t$'s for which $f(t)$ is defined, i.e. the $t$'s for which $t=x+1$ for some $x\in[-1,5]$?
 
@xmh0511 As far as i understand from the discussion above in the comments, all you want to know is what is the domain of $g$ where $g(x+1)=x \hspace{0.1cm} \forall x \in [-1,5]$. See how $g(x)=x-1$ and this holds for every $x$ in $[0,6]$ and hence your domain of $g$ would be $[0,6]$.
 
@OmJoglekar Isn't [-1,5] is the domain of g(x+1)?
 
@CalvinLin How do you know that "the domain X is still [-1, 5]"? because x∈[-1,5] in g(x+1) = x, where the range of x is the domain of g? Maybe, my understanding of the domain of a function is wrong. Please feel free to point out my wrong.
 
3:58 PM
If the domain is $[-1, 5]$ like you said, then what is the value of $g(-1)$? How did you figure that out?
 
@CalvinLin if you passed -1 as the argument, that means, x+1 = -1, which makes the x outside its range, so you cannot pass -1 as the argument.
 
Great! So how can we figure out the actual domain?
 
@CalvinLin the actual domain is x∈[-1,5] and the passed argument t should be t ∈[0,6] for f(x+1).
 
Great! More accurately, $g(t) = t-1$ for $ t \in [0, 6]$. The domain is $[0, 6]$.
 

last day (15 days later) »