« first day (185 days earlier)      last day (4694 days later) » 

12:59 PM
no-one in?
 
 
1 hour later…
2:00 PM
This one looks S&A to me, but suddenly it seems that's not a close option anymore?
0
Q: Is DRM effective?

MrHenNote: I was forwarded here from Skeptics.SE by AviD. I simply copied the entire body of the question but acknowledge that it may need some tweaking to fit properly with this site. Any edits or comments to that effect are welcome. Reddit is all abuzz about DRM, piracy and all related topics. I ...

 
@Iszi "not constructive" is the synonym you're looking for.
[n.b. I generally consider the whole field of anti-piracy and content rights management to be nothing to do with information security, so may not be the best person to evaluate that question. That said, it does show that it's a subjective question if @AviD thinks it's on topic here]
 
2:45 PM
@avid Would it be appropriate to actually delete lance's rant? Totally out-of-place here on several fronts. And can we/how do we help him get on board with useful questions? ....
So people can pay to prevent questions from being closed?
1
Q: Tips for a secure iptables config to defend from attacks. (client side!)

LanceBaynesOwn examples: ############### # KERNEL PARAMETER CONFIGURATION # PREVENT YOU SYSTEM FROM ANSWERING ICMP ECHO REQUESTS echo 1 > /proc/sys/net/ipv4/icmp_echo_ignore_all # DROP ICMP ECHO-REQUEST MESSAGES SENT TO BROADCAST OR MULTICAST ADDRESSES echo 1 > /proc/sys/net/ipv4/icmp_echo_ignore_b...

"open bounty => can't be closed"
 
 
2 hours later…
5:18 PM
Well, I'm off dancing till Saturday and will be mostly out-of-contact - please hold down the fort while I'm gone :)
 
 
1 hour later…
6:48 PM
Avid, I cleaned up this question and like to answer it:
0
Q: Is it a security issue that Thunderbird only logically deletes emails?

LanceBaynesI have several e-mail accounts configured in Thunderbird. I just wanted to move an e-mail from one of my e-mail accounts [A] Trash folder to another accounts [B] Inbox folder. Because the moved e-mail has been lost, Thunderbird doesn't shows it, but here's the catch: Another email appeared in the...

 
@HendrikBrummermann done. FTR, I still think it's a barely passable question - but passable IMO, nonetheless. Great job on cleaning it up....
@nealmcb @HendrikBrummermann cleaned that one up for us real nice. Still not a great question, but watyagonnado...
@nealmcb yes, I agree - I'd already linked him to How to Ask, but the questions did not seem to improve... That bounty thing is a neat trick, though.
I wonder if a mod can still close it? Though I dont think there is a consensus for it, and its not my area of expertise to be sure that its not acceptable. (It seems closeworthy, but I'm not sure I know enough to make that call on my own.)
@nealmcb oo enjoy it, twinkletoes!
 
thank you.
 
@GrahamLee @Iszi I do think it is ontopic (but I agree the wording is not great - @nealmcb did a good job rewriting it). I think the given answers show why it is ontopic - DRM is ostensibly a security mechanism, it is put to us (the security site) to prove our disprove.
@ScottPack everything sounds perverse to you! ;)
 
7:20 PM
At least the bounty has the side effect that his reputation number is more appropriate now.
I just had a look at the history of that user.
Seems like most of the reputation points he got was from questions that have been heavily improved by others.
I thought there was some kind of magic to prevent people from posting questions which such a bad history.
 
@HendrikBrummermann said magic is subverted when we create good questions in place of the old.
watching this one?
0
Q: Why are people saying that X-windows is not secure?

LanceBaynesWhy are people saying that X is not secure? With X I mean: https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/X_Window_System p.s.: The OpenBSD team succeeded with priviledge separation in 2003, WHY DIDN't the "Linux developers" do this? http://openbsd.monkey.org/source-changes/200302/msg00511.html

 
8:05 PM
@ScottPack I think I missed a lot of chat log. How did you come to that conclusion?
@AviD Don't think I ever said it wasn't on-topic. Just S&A.
 
 
2 hours later…
10:31 PM
Is there a way to see on which question a given user has put up bounties?
I mean bounty actions older than 7 days.
 
 
1 hour later…
11:44 PM
@AviD Not everything.
Oo....new close method. "Not Constructive". I like the implied tone way better than S&M.
 

« first day (185 days earlier)      last day (4694 days later) »