« first day (2191 days earlier)      last day (2730 days later) » 

12:00 PM
@JohnRennie you got me there
but our +50 years old landlord came with us
 
Jim
12:13 PM
@JohnRennie We are students our entire lives. Though I guess you could say, we are as children as well
 
@Jim I have made it my life's work to preserve a childlike approach to life :-)
 
Jim
@JohnRennie so when things don't go your way, you take your ball and go home?
 
user116211
There are 750 people with an age of 100. — gunr2171 Apr 17 '15 at 16:22
 
@Jim Immaturity is a sadly underappreciated quality :-)
 
Jim
@JohnRennie Nuh uh!
 
12:18 PM
If you disagree I can only say YAH BOO SUCKS TO YOU!
:: John crosses his fingers that doesn't get flagged ::
 
user116211
@JohnRennie Don't worry 0celot can't.
 
I am comfortable with both cophenhagan and Bohm
 
@MAFIA36790 Sir Cumference has been suspended twice for saying fduck. I think the flag reviewers are sometimes excessively enthusiastic.
 
Jim
@Secret have you asked them if they're comfortable with you?
 
well they cannot because they have died
 
user116211
12:21 PM
@JohnRennie Well, he insulted a cute bird; so the flag was just.
 
@Secret In one of the MWI universes the Copenhagen interpretation is correct.
 
user116211
@Secret Bohm is a commie; so he speaks wrong.
 
My current intepretation is best described as follows:
$$\frac{1}{\textrm{normalisation}}\psi\textrm{-ontic}(\lvert \textrm{Copenhagen}\rangle+\lvert \textrm{Bohm de brogile}\rangle)$$
 
Jim
@MAFIA36790 that's a bit prejudiced. Why do you fear commies?
 
The key is $\psi$-ontic, and in a to be arrived paper from professors in my uni, they said they have proved the wavefunction is real
 
user116211
12:26 PM
@Jim I don't fear....
 
user116211
I hate commies.
 
@MAFIA36790 don't be silly. Commies is one of those catch all terms that doesn't describe individual human beings.
There will be people living in, e.g. China or Russia, who are as warm and loving human beings as you could hope for.
 
user116211
Hmm.
 
And there are people living in the (capitalist) UK who are total shirtheads.
 
Jim
@MAFIA36790 Commies simply have a different philosophy from yours. One which they don't try to imposed on your life. Hating them is a product of fearing them. If you were truly unafraid of them, you'd see no issue with their existence and no reason to hate them simply for having a different philosophy. Fearing them triggers the fight or flight response about them. There is no way to run from their existence, so the only way to fight it is to hate them and act biased against them.
Hating people for simply not living the way you do (especially when they don't directly impact your life in any way) is a product of fear. Denying that means you let the fear control you. This indicates hatred as a form of cowardice
 
12:31 PM
@Jim while I agree with the sentiment this is another example of using the word commies as if it meant anything useful - which it doesn't. The term is typically just used to mean people I hate.
 
Jim
@JohnRennie says the person who was just giving examples of people in communist countries
 
user116211
Oh man; I was just kidding about Bohm. It is really funny to read Lumo's blog on this topic.
 
user116211
> Bohm who made the picture popular, largely because he was a fashionable, media-savvy commie (he's almost certainly the recipient of Wolfgang Pauli's famous criticism "not even wrong" that was ironically hijacked by aggressive Shmoitian crackpots in the recent decade). ...
 
Jim
link?
 
user116211
> Prince Louis de Broglie liked the new life that apparently returned to the veins of his old sick theory so he didn't even care too much that his theory was going to be attributed to someone else and that the someone else was a Marxist rather than an aristocrat.
 
user116211
 
Hmm, either I'm too stupid to follow the arXiv subscription instructions, or the arXiv has a problem with non-ASCII characters in the mail :/
 
Jim
@ACuriousMind can't it be both?
 
@Jim Well, that's a possibility too
Either way, I don't get the "regular daily listings" promised! ::shakes fist::
 
Jim
Yeah, I recently started receiving twice daily listing from them. This is more than I signed up for. I'm not sure I can handle two email blasts a day from arxiv
 
currently tried to focus on reading Iwasana decomposition but whenever the thought that there is a more than 10 pages of finite groups need to be read after that, I felt demotivated
 
12:39 PM
Ahaaaa
Yes, it was the non-ASCII characters
 
rob
@Jim just forward the extra one to @ACuriousMind
 
Heh
Not sure I want astro-ph or whatever Jim's subscribed to, though :P
 
Jim
gr-qc
everyone wants what I subscribe to. Anyone who doesn't like what I like is wrong
 
rob
@ACuriousMind You should file a bug report. There's no excuse for choking on non-ASCII characters in this century.
Well, this decade, at least.
arXiv is old enough that the first version was probably some hacked-together 7-bit email script.
 
@rob Yeah. The subscription page doesn't say anything about it either, it's as if they didn't even think of the possibility that people might have non-ASCII in their names
 
rob
12:46 PM
@ACuriousMind Falsehood #9
 
Jim
@rob nice list. I have a student with no given name. Just a surname. Had to enter them into the system with a period under "first name"
She and her sister have no first name. Their brother has a first name, but their parents didn't give them first names
 
morning
 
rob
@Jim I have a friend, Nur, with only a single name. He shows up in databases as "Mr. Nur" or "Nur Nur" or even in one semi-official place as "Nfn Nur", which I guess was some idiot data entry clerk's way of representing "no first name"
 
@Secret The section on this in Jost's geom anal book was good
 
Jim
@rob Not going to lie, I really like the name "Nur" and I can't figure out why
@0celo7 perhaps using the full word "analysis" would have been a good idea
 
12:58 PM
@Jim Maybe
 
But in my high school, the analytic geometry class was abbreviated "anal geom" on the syllabi
 
Jim
not well thought out, that one
 
@Secret the newer edition would be better
 
rob
Also "Nur" is the first of about five syllables, but that's how he encourages US colleagues to address him.
 
12:59 PM
I own the 6th, I think
lemme check
yeah
great book
 
Jim
@rob Sounds like a fantasy book. "The Secrets of Nur"
 
the knights of Nur
 
Jim
^ love it
 
rob
@Jim This particular Nur is basically the most non-fantasy-oriented person on Earth :-)
 
testing $\prod_{i\in A}$
 
Jim
1:01 PM
The Facts of Nur
 
@Secret use $\prod$, not times
 
rob
But in a tender scene in his story, a clueless seductress whispers, "Tell me about you, Nfn"
 
No fucking name?
 
hello
 
1:06 PM
Oh, first name
@rob honestly anything is better than Gerard 't' Hooft'
@heather why are the boys crazy in your grade?
 
@Jim nur means "only, just" in German, so that just sounds weird to me
 
rob
@0celo7 Is there a final apostrophe as well? I haven't noticed that before.
 
@0celo7, have you met 12-14 year old boys?
 
@rob The correct way is Gerardus 't Hooft.
I think 0celo7 was just throwing apostrophes everywhere to be sure :D
@heather Worse, he's been one once :P
 
@ACuriousMind, yeah =P
but honestly, I think it is just teenager hormones specific only to boys =P
 
rob
1:11 PM
@ACuriousMind Does the "'t" in Dutch play the role of a "von" or a "de" in other languages? Or am I revealing my ignorance?
 
@rob I think so, but I'm not sure what it exactly means, since the analogue to the German "von" or the English "of/o'" would be "van" in Dutch
 
It means head
Or is that hooft
@heather I haven't met one that wasn't well behaved and courteous.
Always makes me wonder why people complain about middle school.
 
According to Wiki, the 't means "the" (abbreviated "het") and so he's named "Gerard the head"
 
More like Gerard doesn't know string theory the head
@ACuriousMind I was well behaved and courteous.
So what is so bad about teenagers?
Maybe it's an American thing.
I had to memorize bible verses when I screwed up, so I didn't.
 
user228700
@JohnRennie U mean thoughtful immaturity :-)
 
user116211
1:27 PM
@0celo7 Proof?
 
user228700
@0celo7 You have had a good life then, if u haven't experienced "middle-school misery" :-P
 
@Kaumudi Don't take life too seriously. You'll never get out of it alive anyway!
 
@JohnRennie Not with that attitude, yeah
(To make one of @Jim's favourite replies :P)
 
user228700
@JohnRennie I agree that thoughtful silliness is absolutely wonderful, but sometimes, I feel that it does one good to take our lives seriously.
 
Caption: This is what a group looks like to me based on my feelings alone:
 
user228700
1:34 PM
We are going to die, but if we don't take this flicker of consciousness allotted to us seriously, then we might end up wasting a lot of precious moments...
 
A many layered thing with a lot of a lot of orbits
 
user116211
@Secret I thought you were going to provide a Cayley Table.
 
user228700
I've sort of been witness to the lives of many people not having taken their lives seriously.
 
user228700
This diagram puts a lot of things into perspective:
 
user116211
No death talks, please.
 
1:35 PM
Partial rationale: quotient groups and subgroups are important tools in understanding groups, so are normal subgroups, conjugates etc.
 
No women, no relationships, no death
@MAFIA36790 what the hell can we talk about?
 
user116211
@0celo7 Maths.
 
no physics, good
 
user228700
 
user116211
@0celo7 yes.
 
user228700
1:37 PM
@0celo7 Yeah :/ Why no "death talks"?
 
user116211
@Kaumudi I wonder if it were a Cayley table.
 
so in a sense, a group does look like an abstract onion with a dynamic surface...
 
Mew
wtf there is not enough squares in that grid
 
@Kaumudi what?
 
user228700
^That's all we've got. Vsauce actually did a great video about how the Earth moves. At the end, he speaks about how much we traverse through space in like, 80 years.
 
user228700
1:39 PM
How's it's literally the "ride of our lives" and all :-D
 
@Kaumudi if you're determined to take me seriously (probably a mistake) I'd say some thing matter, but the cardinality of that set is smaller than teenagers believe.
Anyway, I have to go out and buy lunch, and that really matters :-)
 
user116211
@JohnRennie Good. That's a good way to talk.
 
user228700
@0celo7 What?
 
@Kaumudi So what does that put in perspective? Some people enjoy their weeks filled with silliness, others want them to be filled with adrenaline and excitement, and yet others want them to be dedicated to a higher purpose, some people want all three, and some neither.
 
user228700
@JohnRennie :-) Perhaps; you should know better, I guess. Have a good lunch!
 
1:41 PM
Maybe their finite amount makes each week "precious", but what "precious" means is entirely subjective
 
user228700
@ACuriousMind Did I define what "precious" is supposed to be for all human beings?
 
Therefore I argue that group theory is kinda visual
 
Mew
@ACuriousMind, it doesn't matter, as long as each individual is maximizing their own measure of "preciousness"
 
user228700
I was only making the point that it does one good to take life seriously sometimes.
 
@Kaumudi No, but you kinda sounded as if you were suggesting that being silly is not the right use of preciousness
 
user228700
1:43 PM
@ACuriousMind What? I actually made the case for as much silliness as possible. Perhaps u misread my message...
 
Mew
@Kaumudi, yes the graph makes me seriously want to have more fun
and sillyness
 
user228700
@Mew :-D Ikr?
 
@Kaumudi Eh, then I have no idea what this conversation is about. Ignore me :)
 
user228700
@ACuriousMind: JR said that we musn't always take life so seriously (I'm sure he didn't think I'd take this particular message so seriously, lol :-P) and I was making the case that it's good to take it seriously, that's all. That diagram "puts things into perspective" in that it helps me to realize that I have only so many days.
 
user228700
And "precious" is entirely subjective, yeah-I didn't mean to sound all teenagery but I guess I sort of did :-P
 
Mew
1:47 PM
@Kaumudi, and ACuriousMind's argument is that having "so many days" can be used to argue for either (a) taking life more seriously and also for (b) not taking life seriously
 
user228700
@Mew Ah, OK. It depends on what u mean by "taking it seriously", then :-)
 
I think we have a fundamental miscommunication about what "taking life seriously" means but I'm not sure it will benefit anyone if we hash this out...
 
user228700
@ACuriousMind Yes, yes we do :-) It doesn't matter. Let's all move on from this :-P @MAFIA36790: Sorry for introducing death into this conversation? :-P
 
Mew
@Kaumudi, should we colour in one of those blocks in the graph and allocate it to hashing out this question lol
i think not
 
user228700
I dunno if I should apologize for being so teenagery but hey, what can I do? :-P
 
Mew
1:51 PM
na mate don't apologize
difference offers everyone a refreshing viewpoint
 
user228700
@Mew This is basically what I meant, sort of. OK, anyway! :-P
 
user228700
@Mew :-) Yes, but sometimes, when teenagers get all profound and all, "adults" often dismiss a lot of it...I hope that doesn't happen if some person reads the transcript later on :-P
 
@ACuriousMind : The planet or Bruno? :)
 
@ACuriousMind yikes
 
@Qmechanic Haha, actually I hadn't seen that one yet
 
2:07 PM
0
Q: How to ask a practice book question and apology

PhysicsapprovalI wanted to know how to ask the question from my practice book I add the homework tag and obviously I myself want to know only the concept part and I also give information about what I did and how I approached the problem But still my Question was put Off-topic if I went wrong in the way of ask...

 
Jim
@ACuriousMind I'm glad someone is finally getting the concept
 
2:25 PM
Jesus, that Indian uses question and doubt in the same though
*thought
 
3:03 PM
16 messages moved to Trash
 
What's this obsession with sanitizing the chat lately
What the hell?
 
user116211
@0celo7 Mod power ;))
 
rob
@MAFIA36790 Disagree.
 
More like unnecessary use of it.
 
user116211
Room owner maybe.
 
user116211
3:05 PM
@rob Kidding; just ignore.
 
@0celo7 It's not nice to talk about people in a place where they can't reply.
 
rob
@ACuriousMind Yes, this. Furthermore, discussion about who can or can't or is or isn't participating in the discussion is distracting and boring.
 
Stop removing my messages.
 
rob
No, let's talk about something else instead.
 
user116211
Stop talking about him.
 
rob
3:13 PM
Here's a physical model of a quadrupole magnet focusing system:
 
Can we talk about music? I'm going to see the Hawklords in four hours!!
 
@rob Does that rotation actually turn the unstable equilibrium into a stable one?
 
rob
@ACuriousMind At the right frequency, yes.
 
And I shall drink beer, and the atmosphere may get a bit, erm, fragrant with smoke :-)
 
@rob Is that right frequency a threshhold, or a "sweet spot" you must?
 
rob
3:17 PM
@ACuriousMind Sweet spot. The video shows the ball getting ejected for too-low and too-high frequencies.
Real accelerators have to use feedback systems to stay on-resonance.
 
user116211
@JohnRennie What smoke? Bonfire?
 
user116211
Fireworks?
 
Herbs
 
user116211
I like the gunpowder smell.
 
user116211
@JohnRennie ...
 
user116211
3:18 PM
@JohnRennie Burning herbs?
 
That's what happens when you go to a gig with several hundred other aging hippies!
 
user218912
does latexing stuff help you learn it better?
 
rob
@obe Yes, if "it" == "\LaTeX"
 
@JohnRennie How many years have you been a fan now?
 
user116211
@JohnRennie WTh ;/
 
3:19 PM
:: counts on fingers :: 41!
 
rob
@JohnRennie Wow, you have a lot of fingers
 
not 41 factorial
 
user116211
O.o
 
user218912
@rob no I already am pretty good with latex, I wrote a 50 page document in it before.
 
user218912
I mean learning class material
 
rob
3:20 PM
@JohnRennie Still a lot of fingers
 
user218912
does latexing it help
 
@obe Well, I find that writing down stuff helps me learn it. Whether you do that by hand or by LateX is probably irrelevant, though the LaTeX tends to distract me because I go off for hours playing with the formatting :P
 
user218912
@ACuriousMind okay thanks I'll try it out for a while and see
 
user218912
I remember @Danu latexed his notes right?
 
user116211
@JohnRennie, Beware, it may cause cancer.
 
3:22 PM
@JohnRennie You're impressively loyal, then ;)
 
@ACuriousMind or stupidly stubborn :-)
 
There's a difference?
 
:-)
So tomorrow morning I'll be tired, hung over and deaf. An ideal state to go through the review queues.
 
user218912
@ACuriousMind I missed a few days of class cause I was sick and I'm having trouble doing cross sections and perturbation theory stuff with feynman diagrams.
 
user218912
what do I do
 
3:26 PM
You...read up on it and ask someone who was there to help you with it?
@JohnRennie I'm completely undecided whether the second sentence is serious or not
 
user218912
hmmm
 
user218912
well nobody is offering help because I'm a loner there.
 
user218912
and the worst part is
 
user218912
I don't even know which part I don't understand so I can't ask questions here :O
 
user218912
should probably read up on it from a different book first.
 
user218912
3:29 PM
@ACuriousMind is this scattering stuff generally the hardest part of a first course in QFT?
 
@obe You shouldn't expect people to offer help. You need to ask for it, but that shouldn't be your only interaction with the other students. I know that just talking about the lectures with others has helped me understand a lot much better.
 
Are there notes for the class you could copy?
 
user218912
@JohnRennie yes but normally they work better when accompanied with the lecture.
 
user218912
because there are no examples as far as I know.
 
user218912
I'll have to look at different books
 
3:32 PM
@obe Eh, I found it more annoying than hard, but our lecturer was a theorist who didn't particularly like scattering calculations himself, so I suspect we did less of them than is usual.
 
user218912
@ACuriousMind my lecturer does those for a living. xD
 
user218912
I think it's about 35% of the course or more.
 
user218912
oh well I'll live with it, apparently it's important in condensed matter?
 
@obe Stop changing your pic!
Just pick a name and pic and stop confusing everyone
 
3:46 PM
@SirCumference I'm not sure anyone but you is confused about this :P
 
@ACuriousMind It bugs me when y'all change your pictures
 
@SirCumference: have you made your peace with degenerate gases?
 
@JohnRennie Almost entirely
 
I like changing my picture. It's much easier than operations in real life and has the same effect on people when they see me afterwards
 
All that's left is to start analyzing the Schrödinger equation
 
3:49 PM
See, the physics chat is a good place to learn how to deal with degenerates :-)
 
Are any of the properties of degenerate gases related to the Heisenberg uncertainty principle?
 
The HUP is a result of the way systems are described in quantum mechnics
You hear people say such and such happens because of the HUP but that isn't a good way to view what is going on.
 
user218912
@SirCumference what's that?
 
The HUP isn't the reason the systems behave as they do. It's a consequence of the way they behave.
3
 
user218912
:p
 
3:53 PM
@JohnRennie This. So much this.
 
I have to walk into town to go the Hawklords gig, and it's started raining. Do I wear my sensible coat or my aging but much loved German police coat with POLIZEI written on it in reflective tape?
 
@vzn It won't be a good demonstration of QM unless they can demonstrate entanglement along with Bell violations
 
@JohnRennie How did you obtain a German police coat?
And is it legal for you to wear it in the UK? In Germany you'll get into trouble if you wear something that could reasonably be mistaken for a law enforcement uniform
 
Can't remember. I've owned it for decades. It came froma surplus shop I think, though why they had stock of ex German traffic cop coats escapes me.
 
user218912
what's the point of doing anything if we're all gonna die anyway?
 
3:56 PM
@obe Nihilist
 
user218912
no, just asking.
 
@ACuriousMind I've never been picked up on it. I think polizei is sufficiently different not to be confused for police in the UK. And it's olive green not blue, like UK police uniforms.
 
@obe That's for philosphy SE
 
user218912
hmm
 
But really, just spend time enjoying life
And helping others enjoy it
There's nothing inherently wrong with that ideology
 
3:57 PM
I am only a nihilistic when I am emotionally frustrated. When I am peaceful, I do nothing
 
@obe What would be the point of doing anything if we were immortal?
 
Even if we'll all die, there's nothing wrong with enjoying life as much as you can
 
user116211
Nihilist? Didn't you get a less extreme word?
 
By another aging hippie group.
 
That's not to say you should do something stupid, but don't think death makes life meaningless
 
user218912
3:59 PM
@ACuriousMind well if you were immortal, and assuming the universe will also never end then everything you do matters.
 
user218912
since it's there forever
 
You've got an opportunity to see a whole Universe now
 
@MAFIA36790 "Nihilism" is not an extreme word, it's a philosophical viewpoint.
 

« first day (2191 days earlier)      last day (2730 days later) »