« first day (1294 days earlier)      last day (1238 days later) » 

12:46 AM
0
Q: Film about a man who becomes a murderer after receiving an artificial heart

FuzzyBootsI read about this in a book about classic horror films in elementary school, around 1987 to 1991, in Ashland, KY. The main character is a scientist who is developing an artificial heart. To prove his invention, he implants the heart in himself. Later, he becomes a murderer (I think with all impli...

 
 
2 hours later…
2:25 AM
0
Q: 1950s Children's TV Sci-Fi Where the Villain is an Arrangement of Crystals That Achieved Consciousness

homeboyI am trying to locate the name of a serialized children's sci-fi program. My most vivid memory is the ending. The bad guy turned out to be a half dozen crystals whose positions relative to each other allowed it to achieve consciousness. The hero "killed" the villain by just moving one of the crys...

 
 
2 hours later…
4:05 AM
0
Q: I am looking for two different manwha's that I cannot figure out the name for

xlovinglyThe first one starts with a guy who is in a game type world and he runs past this boss fight to mine some rocks and I think gets a really rare drop or something. The second is the main character is on a quest in another game type world and he gets an S class item right as he dies. It has a simila...

 
4:54 AM
0
Q: I am looking for a fantasy manwha that isnt really an isekai

xlovinglybasically the main character is on a quest in a game type world and he gets an S class item right as he dies. It has a similar world I believe to hardcore leveling warrior where the top players are super famous and one notable famous one is this girl he runs into. On top of that I know he crashes...

 
5:25 AM
0
Q: Why was this Star Trek and slavery question locked?

Giacomo1968Why was this question locked? The moderation banner at the top of the page on that question states: “Locked for 7 days. There are disputes about this question’s content being resolved at this time. It is not currently accepting new answers or interactions.” I am sure some people will say it is ...

 
 
4 hours later…
9:28 AM
0
Q: Did Doctor Who ever tackle slavery in one of its story cycles?

Mozibur UllahThe original remit for Doctor Who was that it was to be a children's entertainment programme and that it had to be educational. Given that Britain was involved in the transatlantic slave trade, although, given - as far as I know - no slaves on British soil: Did a story cycle in Doctor Who tackle ...

 
10:17 AM
-1
Q: Were there any other monsters in Doctor Who which were a play on words?

Mozibur UllahThe Daleks were originally the Kaleds. Notably, Dalek is Kaled spelt backwards. This is just a simple play on words. Were there any other monsters in the long running Doctor Who series that were a play on words, and not necessarily of this kind?

 
11:07 AM
-1
Q: Is Mr. Sin in the Talons of Weng-Chiang a deliberate play on words?

Mozibur UllahThe Talons of Weng Chiang is a story cycle of the fourth doctor. In it there is a homonculus called Mr. Sin, was this a deliberate play on words by the story writer - Robert Holmes?

-1
Q: Why is Weng-Chiang called the 'Butcher of Brisbane'?

Mozibur UllahThe Talons of Weng-Chiang is one the story cycles of the fourth doctors which found critical acclaim. In this story, Magnus Greel, runs away from the 51st Century to pose as a Chinese magician in Victorian Britain. In the 51st C, he was a minister of justice for the Supreme Alliance and responsib...

0
Q: Was there an actual masque in the Masque of Mandragora?

Mozibur UllahThe Masque of Mandagora was a story cycle of the fourth doctor and set in fictional city of San Martino in 15th C Italy. In it, Heironymous, an astrologer, attempts to call up the Mandagora Helix to rule the earth. It's sounds rather like Goethe's Faust. A masque, is not a mask that one puts over...

 
11:26 AM
[ SmokeDetector | MS ] Link at beginning of answer (34): Why are AI systems almost always feminine? by ouicertes on scifi.SE
 
0
Q: Does Rand al'Thor succumb to Ba'alzamon?

Mozibur UllahIn the chapter "The Dark Waits" in the Eye of the World, Rand dreams of the Four Kings, a village that he has just been through; and in this dream, he meets Ba'alzamon and there is the following exchange: Rand turned and discovered he could be afraid ... They are jealous of what you will be, onc...

 
@Marvin Well, @Randal'Thor?
 
If he has succumbed can he answer?
 
11:57 AM
0
Q: How does this conversation in Shadows of the Empire make sense?

DamarI actually liked Steve Perry's Star Wars novel Shadows of the Empire from 1996, but there are a couple of things that keep my head spinning. Above everything else, I don't understand the following conversation, which takes place in chapter 37 when Luke, Lando, Chewie and Dash run into Leia in the...

0
Q: Why does Le Guin say that Superman's mother was a 'funny book'?

Mozibur UllahIn an academic study of SF, Ursula le Guin, who herself is a pioneering SF author is quoted as saying: Superman is a submyth. His father was Nietzsche and his mother a funnybook. Why the 'funny book' genre? I don't recall the Superman strips particularly humourous. In fact, I'd say the opposite...

 
12:13 PM
@Mithical That's ... a weird question.
Why ask a question about what happens later in the series when you're in the middle of the first book?
 
Eight questions in a couple hours...
 
I don't think the amount of questions is the biggest problem
 
I may have left out a word.
 
Just leave a few comments and the situation will resolve itself.
 
0
Q: How is Beskar Forged?

pankajdohareySince Beskar is an extremely heat tolerant metal and even survives lightsaber and blaster attacks, how do the Mandalorian metalsmiths even forge such a metal? The only thing that could vaporise the metal seems to be Arc pulse generator.

0
Q: Was Mona 'the vampire' delusional or just day-dreaming?

AncientSwordRageI remember having a strong negative reaction to how the primary character's day dreams are portrayed in the TV Series. The series follows the adventures of Mona Parker, who refers to herself as "Mona the Vampire", as well as her two best friends, Lily Duncan ("Princess Giant") and Charley Bones ("...

 
1:02 PM
posted on November 27, 2020 by tech

Click here to go see the bonus panel!Hovertext: Come to the object at this distance from the following pulsars FOR A HOT TIME. Today's News:

 
@Marvin @TheLethalCarrot @OrangeDog I think the OP here has tagged this because they read the book, not watched the TV series
 
> I've tagged it a 'children's-novel' as many of the Doctor who story cycles were novelised. And I happened to discover Dr. Who first through its novelisations.
It appears to be because they found it through the novelisations and it may be novelised but the tag still doesn't make sense even then unless they only want answers based on the books which I doubt
2
 
> I picked it up first in a school trip to our local library
@TheLethalCarrot agreed
it seems like a bad edge case
 
Nah unless they want only book answers the tag is completely unneeded
 
@TheLethalCarrot yes
> Use this tag when the question specifically relates to a novel targeted at children or young people. Written for those with basic levels of reading comprehension and vocabulary. It should not be used solely because an original work was novelised, unless you are referencing elements only in the novelisation.
new tag info
thats far isn't it?
 
1:11 PM
I like it.
 
Sounds about right, even then though it should be used alongisde the main work tag
 
@TheLethalCarrot do you mind working that in?
 
Good point.
 
Added a bit on the end
 
Thanks
@DavidW We've been discussing that question and how to treat similar ones in the future
We've sort of agreed that we don't want this become Sci-Fi and Fantasy franchise stackexchange, where only thing specific to books/tv/movies etc are on topic
but it's definitely hard to get good answers to good subjective questions.
 
1:26 PM
It's hard to get good concise Q/As on topics that are franchise agnostic cos if only 2 franchises treat something different you end up with messy noise where both answers are correct but completely differenty
And that kind of misses the point to SE
 
@TheLethalCarrot true, which is why it needs to be a narrow answer but also use broad strokes
You can still phrase it as "Generally there're three types of dragon, but there are obvious exceptions..."
 
0
Q: Is it known why Tolkien made Sam be Frodo's servant rather than very close and trusty friend "on equal terms"?

S KIf I have to find one "flaw" about The Lord of the Rings, it may be the fact that Sam is more or less the slave of Frodo, albeit a willing servant. This fundamentally bothers me, for some reason. Perhaps because I'm essentially Sam in terms of social status, if even that. Although he ends up bein...

 
Oh yeah, that question is bit more acceptable, in my opinion... it's when you get to the "What defines a vampire/zombie/werewolf/[insert here] where things start becoming more complicated... sure they have common themes across almost all interpretations but there's a lot of different characteristics
 
@TheLethalCarrot yes, it's not cut and dry/ black and white then
which is where @Randal'Thor and I agreed it may need more soft moderation so the community is on the same page when it comes to what is good subjective
 
Aye, it's quite a broad grey area
 
1:30 PM
SFF is mighty keen to upvote shiny questions/answer at times
 
Subjective isn't the problem to me in these cases, it's trying to scope them properly so they don't end up being too broad or a list
 
but that still links into subjectivity
One person might have a very narrow experience, and claim only XYZ are dragons
thats very subjective
someone taking a range of views into account, and is aware of that subjectivty is going to scope the answer better
I'm going off my experience on RPG stack exchange and how they treat similar subjects
 
Aye true, I was thinking of subjective and too broad/list as separate things in terms of close reasons
 
1:59 PM
@Randal'Thor I don't understand those kinds of questions either. I've recall there were a few such about LotR.
@TheLethalCarrot Yeah, witches and werewolves and zombies are way too popular and have lots of different versions. Dragons and time travel too.
Are they undead or living? Depends on what book you read.
 
@b_jonas at least dragons are broadly similar. You can happily lump the Dragons from Reign of Fire and smaug together I would hope
 
@AncientSwordRage That sounds fair to me too, but I agree it may be a hard line to draw sometimes. (Which doesn't at all mean we shouldn't try.)
@AncientSwordRage I would argue that "good" subjective means showing a certain amount of work on the part of the asker; if nothing else, that will help narrow the question.
 
@DavidW thatsa good criteria
 
For example, our hypothetical question about dragons, if their question's background shows that their view of dragons is largely from Dragonlance and other D&D-influenced material, that would suggest answering in that vein instead of trying to drag in oriental dragons or wyrms of Norse lore, etc.
 
@DavidW yup, and they put in the tags information missing from the question body, which could trip people up
 
2:26 PM
1
Q: Fantasy book with a female protagonist in a wizard oppressed world that Comes into magic through a stone she picks

JonLooking for an online novel I read a while back. I believe it was set in a wizard oppressed medieval era. The main Protagonist is a girl who finds a Stone and is somehow able to use magic. On this being discovered , her family is forced to let her be taken away as an apprentice, however the warlo...

 
@AncientSwordRage Nah, there are at least two very different brands of dragons too.
And even the western style has enormous variation. Sometimes they're huge but slow and dumb beasts that use their raw power; sometimes they're still large and strong but also fast intelligent and have hands and can speak and can even cast spells.
Lem even describes a dragon without a head.
And I already mentioned that there are worms, wurms, and wyrms, the last one of which are related to dragons.
 
2:47 PM
 
1
Q: Was Arthur Weasley's car truly invisible?

J. MiniOutside of invisibility cloaks, the only mention of invisibility that I can recall in the series is Arthur Weasley's Ford Angila. I find it suspect that he was able to make a car turn invisible, but, as far as I know, the series has no invisibility spell. This raises the question: Was his car tru...

 
3:14 PM
@b_jonas there're definitely exceptions, but also general patterns
 
 
1 hour later…
4:25 PM
0
Q: Does Beskar armor resist lightsabers?

Yu ZhangIn S2, E5, when Din Djarin (the Mandalorian of the title) fights against a Jedi, his Beskar armor is able to fully protect him from slashes from a lightsaber. Is this a new concept introduced by Disney's The Mandalorian or has it been this way from the original Lucas's Star Wars universe? I was u...

 
 
2 hours later…
6:35 PM
0
Q: How did driods entered Gungan shield?

Ari AroganaHere is the battle between droids and Gungan army, where droids entered the shield generated by Gungan army: How did driods entered Gungan shield?

 
7:25 PM
0
Q: Can I read Rhythm of War, before the rest of The Stormlight Archive or will I be lost

TheFLASHAZAMI want to know if I can listen to the Rhythm of War Audiobook, because it's up on Brandon Sanderson's youtube, before I read the rest of The Stormlight Archive. I know there's alot of books in the Cosmere, and I want to get into it, but I don't know if I have to read it in order to understand it ...

 
7:40 PM
[ SmokeDetector | MS ] No whitespace in answer (96): Why aren't the Valar considered gods? ✏️ by alfodel on scifi.SE
 
0
Q: Why didn't the Clyons just build a new resurrection hub?

userIn the reimagined Battlestar Galactica season 4, a plan to destroy the Cylon resurrection hub is hatched. The humans seem to think that this will prevent all Cylons resurrecting forever. Why would they assume that and why would it be true? Couldn't the Cylons just build a new one? Didn't they bui...

0
Q: Why in a society with ubiquitously advanced tech; many people live like Medevial villagers?

MaxSPOILERS FOR MANDALORIAN CHAPTER 13 The Mandalorian goes to the forest world of Corvu and goes to a village that Ahsoka is protecting. The walls protecting the village are basic metal. The village itself looks like something out of Game of Thrones. People are dressed like medieval peasants. Their...

 
8:15 PM
0
Q: Why can't Trekkers use their transporter buffers to keep back-up copies of people transported?

Robbie GoodwinIn TNG S6 Ep22, Crusher wants an autopsy to help determine whether someone was murdered, but the dead guy’s family has cultural objections. In the story she goes ahead anyway, jeopardising her career - and that’s not the point. To me, it seems obvious that some simple combination of replicator an...

 
8:40 PM
2
Q: Alien killing people by shooting his fingernails

Dixie CRI've been looking for this movie for several years and found nothing, I guess it wasn't popular. So the action takes place on another planet. I don't remember much of the storyline, just that there was a cute little alien. And one of the crew memebers fed it with a chocolate bar. And another memb...

 
9:05 PM
-1
Q: Do the writers of Star Wars agree on what is Lightspeed and what is FTL?

MaxSPOILERS FOR DOCTOR APHRA 6 I always thought hyperspace was established to be Faster than light and lightspeed is just slang. It approaches lightspeed when jumping but then breaks the barrier. Yet now in Doctor Aphra 6, they introduce a new engine called the Path engine that is said to have incr...

0
Q: Teen fantasy book series about a world where people who showed creativity could learn magic, and were killed for it

DjbomberThe first book starts where the main character shows creativity, and is sent presumably to his death. He then ends up in a secluded area run by a caretaker where they learn to use their creativity and art as magic. The two sides go to war, one led by the main character and the other by his twin o...

 
 
1 hour later…
10:28 PM
@Marvin That's Kraid from Super Metroid, isn't it?
Hmm no, that doesn't match the body, only the title.
> there was a cute little alien. And one of the crew memebers fed it with a chocolate bar. And another member was being cruel to it and it killed the human by shooting him with his poisonous fingernail. Alien had three fingers.
The cute alien and Kraid who kills people with fingernails are different aliens, and I don't recall a chocolate bar.
 
10:44 PM
@Marvin "magical sentient whiteboards" hmm. Toy Story has a magical sentient etch-a-sketch I think
 
0
Q: that one novel i remember every thing but the name

Kitotikatatari RaskijThe novel is about a guy who is reincarnated to another world of magic and swords maybe a game. He was born to a noble family or rich . This guys know this world the hero, and he tries to make a plot keep going the right way from the shadow. He become a merchant do mission and get strong (he look...

 
@Marvin "remember every thing"? please write them down in your question then
@Marvin Jesus this question only has generic details with no specific enough thing to even put in the question title. It's like those "anime where young guy with black spikey hair goes to fight monsters and he becomes more powerful and summons monsters using cards/rings to fight with him and is on a mission to defeat a big bad and save the girl the big bad kidnapped" ones.
I don't even understand what the "making his his family don,t know he is strong or a merchant" part means
The only specific details are the two other works that it's similar to.
 
11:23 PM
@DavidW No, "good subjective" doesn't depend on the amount of research done in the question - it's more about the type of answers the question invites. The term was defined by SE many years ago and it's still in the help centre on every site.
3
Basically Good Subjective means subjective stuff that can be backed up by objective arguments. Not just "I think X" but "a case can be made for X based on the following pieces of evidence".
An example of Good Subjective at work on SFF is . A good answer in that tag won't be just "I read/watched them in this order, it's cool" but "this order makes sense because it's in-universe chronological / what the author intended / best avoids spoilers / whatever other objective reason".
In the case of non-franchise-specific questions, ASR found a nice comment of DVK which shows how such Q&A could really work well and provide some genuine genre expertise:
@Valorum - that's the point. You don't enumerate BOOKS, you enumerate approaches. 1. Vampires that die from garlic (ex1, ex2). 2. Vampires that are in severe pain from garlic (ex1, ex2). 3. Vampires that are irritated by garlic (ex1, ex2). 4. Vampires that aren't affected by garlic anymore than humans (ex1). 5. Vampires that only drink garlic infused blood as it's a delicacy (ex3). 7. Vampires made of garlic (ex)DVK-on-Ahch-To Jun 6 '16 at 20:36
That's the sort of in-depth study of fantasy fiction that I'd really love to see, and would expect to see, on a site of fantasy experts.
A question like "does garlic harm vampires in Twilight?" or "does garlic harm vampires in Vampirates?" is completely objectively answerable, pretty boring to anyone except a fan of that specific franchise, and doesn't require any expertise except knowing how/where to search all the canon of that franchise.
3
A question like "what are the effects of garlic on vampires in vampire fiction?" is much broader but also much more interesting, to someone who's interested in sci-fi and fantasy as a genre rather than just being interested in Twilight or interested in The Vampire Diaries or whatever. And it COULD be answered without listing all the million different pieces of vampire fiction over the decades and their approaches. It just couldn't be answered by pure search-fu in canon databases.
2
 

« first day (1294 days earlier)      last day (1238 days later) »