@Imtiaz Wa alaykum salam :) and yes everything is good Alhamdulillah
@Imtiaz yeah me too, but this a fact, and there are many reasons, one is giving Da'wah to these sects and not Islam. Further more, it is as Allah said, each of these sects are happy with what they have
@AlUmmatمجاهد "Further more, it is as Allah said, each of these sects are happy with what they have" - I didn't quite understand that. Did Allah mention the sects anywhere?
@Imtiaz Alhamdulillah, your understanding is correct, if you wish, this is only suggestion, you can consult a book of tafseer to further ones understanding on the Ayah
I mean almost in all muslim world communism is banned, but capitalism is not.
Why such inequality?
Didn't Quran mention that the goal is to became a classless society where everybody is equal (advanced stages of communism) as mentioned in the work of Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels.
Personally ...
Marxism (and especially Leninism) were very much anti-religious; they consider religion to be nothing more than a tool used by those in power to control the populace.
so, for example, if you have a farm in a Marxist state, the government decides who gets all the grain (you don't own it yourself, even if you grow it).
a Capitalist state, you can do with your own grain as you please; keep it, sell it, give it away, it's your grain, not the government's.
I've always seen Islam as a free-market capitalist system; except for Zakat, we're pretty much expected to do with our goods as we wish.
actually, looking at the question, i think we can take a firm stand on "In the muslim world" questions
If the question is about why a particular muslim country does such-and-such, that could work (depending). But there isn't really any "muslim world" government that decides anything.
<closed> There are dozens of countries in the "muslim world", each with their own governments and their own decision-making processes; it's pretty much impossible to answer this question as phrased. — goldPseudo57 secs ago
the same in Egypt: Under the regimes of Presidents Anwar Sadat and Hosni Mubarak the new Communist Party faced state repression and was barred from running in elections.
@Derfder this was a comment by Umar Bin (which I accidentally deleted):
"Whoever is a Communist is not a Muslim. Communism involves different kinds of blatant kufr, such as denying the existence of Allaah (may He be glorified and exalted), denying the existence of the unseen worlds, making a mockery of the religion of Allaah and looking down on it, and flouting its laws and morals. How can the Muslim whose religion is Islam follow an ideology which states that religion is the opium of the people? -islamqa.info/en/ref/3321 "
@derfder there's not really any reason to expect that three different countries to have the same reason for forbidding three different communist parties.
to my eye, that's about as absurd as asking "Why is eating food forbidden in religion?"
I prefer to recite it while I'm walking, so I like to just delay it
for about20 minutes instead of doing it straight away after fajr
salah. Is this fine?
3 – Reciting “Qul huwa Allaahu ahad”, “Qul a’oodhu bi Rabb il-Falaq”
and “Qul a’oodhu bi Rabb il-Naas” [i.e., the last three soor...
@Derfder Personally? In Iran? Yes actually. And more that have left Iran over it. Of the regugees I know about half of them left for political issues, the other half religious. Being communist or being Christian are both strikes there. But in other Muslim countries, both are allowed. Your question is as much a political one as it is religious, and there is no definative answer because each country has their own reasons (which may or may not even relate to Islam).
as far as I know, currently Iran forbids any parties from running if they are against the Islamic system in place; whether or not they're Communist is irrelevant.
@Derfder Iran has an ever changing landscape of blocked sites, and some of the most interuptive methods for enacting it. However they are not alone, many countries in the Middle East and East bock political views they disagree with, including Turkey.
E.g. in Czech Republic it's OK. The only thing you cannot touch is Holocaust, they have passed a law that you cannot doubt or suggest that there were less dead people or that Holocaust never happend ;). But in some part of Europe you can do it on the internet without any problems.
Ok so you've lived in Europe, including an ex-Soviet block country. That doesn't qualify you to label Turkey as "basically European". It's nothing of the sort.
OK, so I assume you are a muslim. If not I am sorry. My question is. Do you feel that Turkey is heading more to the secular society or more to the religious society. How do you see it in the future. Will the atheist/agnostics take over in the future or will the religion remain as strong as it is now. I know that it's more secular than e.g. Iran which is islamic republic and Turjey is Turkey is a secular constitutional republic. Thanks in advance for your opinion.
@Derfder Secular and religious aren't as clearly separable as you seem to imply. And Turkey is becoming more of both actually. It's polarizing. And labeling it as "more secular than Iran" is to skip over the vast differences between different flavors of Islam and the imbalance of political representation in each location.
Hmm, why don't you think that Turkey is more secular than Iran? Iran is officialy islamic republic. Turkey is officialy democratic , secular constitutional republic.
Maybe you are frustrated from how it works in your country e.g. lack of jobs, corruprion etc. but the fact is Turkey is more secular country than Iran. The same analogy, but not using religion ;) could be made e.g. when comparing North Korea and China. Without beeing in North Korea you can right now say that in China you have more democracy than in North Korea.
@Derfder I didn't say that. But you've obviously not followed recent Turkish politics either, because the things that defined what "secular" means and how it is enforced here have changed.
@Derfder Democracy !== Secular.
@Derfder Turkey has more jobs than many places in Europe. Why would I be frustrated by that? And if I was, why would I blame that on the government not being secular? The party that has been bringing religion back into politics has also made huge progress economically.
You are right that democracy is not equal to secular society. Do you think that their religious belief has helped them to be more successful as their predecessor who was more secular?
I'm pretty sure turkey was religious even 200years ago. They were Muslim who took control of Israel. And I'm pretty they weren't secular in Israel. Lest you want to say a secular Muslim will pray in the al Aqsa or dome of rock masjid
When ill get home ill post a link to where "supposed" Palestinians are really Jews who were converts by force and they still did jewish rituals n prayers according to jewish law
How do you think "Palestinians" Happend? Countries took over and brought in settlers and some Jews who were forced to convert. That's what you hve as Palestinians not a separate nation. It's a mix of Arabs from arou drive Arab world with idigenius Jews
@DhoweedYaAgov 200 years ago was there even was a Turkey and certainly became it became officially a secular republic. That statement only confuses the issue.
And don't even try to mix the politics of the Ottoman Empire with modern day Turkish ones. Same audience maybe. Same venue maybe. Different actors, different script, different set.
The Stack Exchange model is one of community; the community asks questions that are of interest to itself, and they are answered by those of the community who can, ideally those who have encountered this similar issue and can speak from experience or knowledge (or both).
Unfortunately, the site ...
The Stack Exchange model is one of community; the community asks questions that are of interest to itself, and they are answered by those of the community who can, ideally those who have encountered this similar issue and can speak from experience or knowledge (or both).
Unfortunately, the site ...
I mean almost in all muslim world communism is banned, but capitalism is not.
Why such inequality?
Didn't Quran mention that the goal is to became a classless society where everybody is equal (advanced stages of communism) as mentioned in the work of Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels.
Personally ...
I prefer to recite it while I'm walking, so I like to just delay it
for about20 minutes instead of doing it straight away after fajr
salah. Is this fine?
3 – Reciting “Qul huwa Allaahu ahad”, “Qul a’oodhu bi Rabb il-Falaq”
and “Qul a’oodhu bi Rabb il-Naas” [i.e., the last three soor...
Jaami'at StackExchange al-Islamyya
Jaami'at StackExchange al-Islamyya