« first day (1467 days earlier)      last day (3470 days later) » 
00:00 - 23:0023:00 - 00:00

slm
11:01 PM
@Ramesh - I agree. That's ridiculous
 
11:11 PM
Coming into the party late, but I don't think it was as bad as everyone is making it out to be.
1) the user is obviously new, and probably didn't know you could embed images into the question so they can be viewed without clicking
2) the image itself was extremely critical to the answer as the asker stated he tried a valid command, which in any normal shell would have worked.

In fact, the only thing I can fault him for is not stating in the original question what he tried. That is an issue yes, but it's the only legitimate one that I would fault him for.
 
slm
@FaheemMitha I would be inclined to close the 2nd one as a dup of the one you wrote your A on. But i was thinking of migrating Kwiwy's A to that Q as well
 
@slm Ok. Do whatever you think is best.
 
@MohsenPahlevanzadeh DO NOT USE CODE MARKUP FOR THINGS THAT ARE NOT CODE. This is not the first time you've been told that. — Gilles 7 secs ago
can't he just go away, dammit?
 
slm
@Gilles - I'd be lying if I said that thought hadn't crossed my mind...a zillion times...
@Gilles - thoughts on whether it's worth merging these 2 Q's? I'm thinking of making this a dup of this. The 1st one is actually older but the 2nd Q from today is asked better IMO
 
I've edited the cp question to be more proper, and nominated it for re-opening.
 
11:17 PM
no need to merge, the answer on the dupe isn't that good
@Patrick link?
 
-6
Q: How can I copy a file from another directory to the current one?

user88022I have this problem as part of a school assignment: I tried doing: cp ../cambridge/security/parking ./parking2 ...but it doesn't work.

 
@Patrick crap question even after your edit. Let it die.
 
why? he tried a valid command, it didn't work. how is he supposed to know that ./ isn't needed?
 
“it doesn't work” → your question is invalid, tell us what happened (error messages, etc)
 
it's a homework program. I highly doubt it gave him a syntax error, or anything more meaningful than "wrong"
 
11:20 PM
is this ever going to be useful to someone else?
not in its present form, and I doubt the question can be edited to be useful to someone else.
 
if that's the criteria for a question here, then >90% of our questions should be closed
 
@Patrick what criteria? going to be useful to someone else?
 
they can't all be gems, but turds need to be flushed down the toilet
 
@FaheemMitha aye
 
hmm. i think we should at least be more on the lookout for dupes. the SE machinery doesn't help much with that.
 
11:22 PM
@Gilles So what was he supposed to have done? If he was stuck where he was, and kept getting told he had a wrong answer, asking for help is bad?
 
a feature which pops up possible dupes would be useful. i know it does for the person writing it, but perhaps as a review feature?
@Gilles that file copy thing?
 
@Patrick we aren't here to help everyone. If he needs that much handholding, he needs help from a high school teacher, or from a parent, not from us.
 
@Gilles That much hand holding? he had a completely valid command!
 
@Patrick I don't know, I haven't seen the text of his assignment
he didn't even post it, all he posted was an image
 
and the image was crucial. if he had pasted the command and said "this doesn't work", we would have jumped on him saying "you're lying", and some of us did
 
slm
11:27 PM
@Patrick - I edited it further
 
@slm Ty
 
slm
He's attending a university in Canada, and probably paying someone to teach him this material, right?
@Gilles - the image shows the problem in the text below the dir tree. I've copied the text into the Q.
 
If you're saying he should be asking the instructor. That might be a valid option yes. But instructors can be very hard to get a hold of. They have *lots* of students.
Study groups & peer help is very common in college. We just became his peer help. I don't think there's anything inherently wrong with that.
 
slm
Only that they're failing him, a bit,
 
@Patrick There a zillion clueless students out there. I've bet you've met some of them. Do you really want them all coming here?
 
11:34 PM
@slm school computer tests are notoriously horrible
@FaheemMitha I'm arguing that he wasn't clueless. He had a correct answer
 
slm
yeah these scripted testing systems I've had to endure as well and never really cared for them.
 
well, correct as in valid, but not what the program wanted
 
@Patrick I wasn't really following, but what was he asking about then?
Ok, don't feel you need to reply to that. It doesn't really matter.
 
@FaheemMitha His program asked him for the command to copy a file, he gave cp ../foo ./bar when the program wanted cp ../foo bar (no ./)
 
slm
I think Patrick's point is that this guy had roughly the correct A and was asking for help and he got basically -6, and told that his command was wrong and that he's typing it wrong.
 
11:36 PM
@slm i see. he just needed a minor course correction, you mean?
 
slm
yeah.
 
i agree we shouldn't be jerks to people who are trying and have legit questions. still copying files is a bit elementary even for this site.
we can't be nix tutors here.
 
We are nix tutors here. that's the whole purpose of this site
 
@Patrick seriously. you mean, anything at all?
 
slm
I need to think about this more. I'm not sure where I stand at the moment.
I get Patrick's point, but I've seen a lot of crap here too, and have spent hours helping A-holes too.
 
11:38 PM
@FaheemMitha depends on what you mean by "anything".
 
@Patrick sure. but a cp command is a bit, well, basic.
i guess the site guidelines don't say anything about basic.
 
Yes, but we also just tought someone about relative paths, and that ./ is implicit, and not required
 
@Patrick fair enough.
@Patrick what the program wanted? he was entering the answer into a machine?
If so, ugh.
 
@FaheemMitha Yes, testing program. I agree, shitty program.
 
@Patrick Poor fellow.
 
11:47 PM
@Patrick, I agree you have a valid point but the OP was told to put what he had in image as text in this comment which he chose to ignore. And yet, when he got an answer at roughly the same time, he chose to respond back.
 
@Ramesh That is a good point.
 
munin has a slab_cache field, a cache field and a swap_cache field. i guess swap is swap, but what is slab cache vs cache?
 
And whatever we have told the OP, it would have probably gone with the wind :)
 
slm
I've taken the dir struct from the image and made it an actual tree output now
 
hmm, there's a wp article on slab allocation.
 
00:00 - 23:0023:00 - 00:00

« first day (1467 days earlier)      last day (3470 days later) »