needs downvote and deletion

seeking personal advice math.stackexchange.com/q/4138290/29335

math.stackexchange.com/questions/4138359/… should I answer this?

never mind, found a dupe

@ParclyTaxel Closed by community, just about a minute after I voted to close.

math.stackexchange.com/q/4130259/357390 needs one more duplicate vote

@ParclyTaxel Hmm where does your edit's contents come from? Is it your words or the asker's words?

@vitamind Moreover, it is a PSQ

D1, D2, D3.

D4, D5, D6.

D7, D8, D9.

D10, D11, D12.

C1, C2, C3.

C4, C5, C6.

C7, C8, C9.

C10, C11, C12.

@vitamind Now up for deletion.

@TeresaLisbon That unimproved question about finding a witch can be deleted.

@user21820 Thanks, the witch is gone!

PSQ Attempt focuses on definition, so can be borderline, discussion is welcome.

PSQ

Delete

Downvote and delete

For the sake of curiousity : What was the question with the hightest score that was eventually deleted ?

PSQ with link in comments partially compensating for context.

PSQ

@TeresaLisbon Gone

@amWhy Thanks

!

@TeresaLisbon Open for deletion.

@amWhy Thanks, one more delete vote to go.

PSQ

Can someone debate this answer on meta?

@TeresaLisbon It seems as if the answerer is making accusations, or so I thought. "Often questions are closed by some upstanding member of the community who read it for half a second, read some other question that seemed vaguely similar for another half-second, and decided to close it without doing due diligence."

@soupless That, and : " Good questions get downvoted and closed all the time". Not sure.

Or "good" means different things for different people then.

I think I'll comment to that answer.

@soupless Up to you. I wanted to , but I don't know what to say honestly at this point!

@amWhy I just think it's an outspoken user, but what is also true is that the views aired are very biased at the starting. The last paragraph is decent as is the second last IMO, but the rest are pretty bad.

I think the user doesn't regard the SE rules with any respect because they are set up for gamification. While that's a point, it's certainly not an excuse to then ask everybody to not play by it.

I think this question should be closed: The goal is to prove that |𝑧+6+8𝑖|≤13, but OP tries to prove |𝑧+16+8𝑖|≤13 instead. What would be a suitable closing reason?

@MartinR Also see the answer!

I think I'll see the source (it's good it was given) and I'll clarify with you if the question is correct or not.

I don't think the question should be closed, @MartinR , at least until I verify the source.

CONFIRMED : It is |z + 6 + 8i| <= 13.

So indeed, the attempt is off.

@MartinR If OP cares about the question, I think He/She should definitely answer you. If Op doesn't make any comments, I agree with you.

→ 1 message moved to ­Trash

@amWhy The meta answer has been deleted.

These needs to be deleted

^^^ "This needs ... *

@amWhy It's gone.

@JoséCarlosSantos Thanks!

Help close this PSQ with three answers