« first day (1572 days earlier)      last day (2066 days later) » 

Nicolas Chabanovsky
Nicolas Chabanovsky
2:38 AM
Hi @aki! Thank you for the compilation of the slogans. Yes, we can direct user to a question.
The only really hard restriction is the length of the title. It should be short to be placed on the banner.
You kindly mentioned the banner which says "If you have a question about moderation ask it on meta". This banner is a bit from another campaign which I really want to have on SOja soon. The campaign is about tips how to use the site. We just finished it on SOes!
aki
aki
3:16 AM
Hi @NicolasChabanovsky hope you are feeling better today 🍎🍏
Nicolas Chabanovsky
Nicolas Chabanovsky
@aki Thank you!
aki
aki
3:34 AM
@NicolasChabanovsky wrote back to you 📧📲 to have more action buttons of "let's ask" make sense
Nicolas Chabanovsky
Nicolas Chabanovsky
Thanks! Will look at the email in a few :)
aki
aki
and what should the action button say for the most voted question titles (nekketsuuu and yohjp's)?
Nicolas Chabanovsky
Nicolas Chabanovsky
Hm. Interesting question. What do you think about "Look at a good question" or something like that?
aki
aki
3:53 AM
hm, 良い質問をみてみよう
良い質問を読んでみよう
may i ping those 2?
since they are their actual questions..
will they direct here? ja.stackoverflow.com/questions?sort=votes
i could see both of their questions @NicolasChabanovsky
Nicolas Chabanovsky
Nicolas Chabanovsky
4:38 AM
@aki Let me clarify the idea. I thought that if we use the title of a good question the banner should direct users to the question. Could you please tell me if I understand your idea right?
It would be a bit strange to me if I click on a banner with a question but the banner sends me somewhere else. What do you think?
 
3 hours later…
aki
aki
7:19 AM
firstly, the bright side of directing to the most voted page is that we could encourage users to go through all these great (top 1 percent) questions and somehow that may lead to their "actions" of either answering, voting, or ultimately asking new question (as great as these fab. questions) i thought

secondly, i must say that “to have most voted question’s title as a banner” was originally yuki’s idea (not mine🙏!!!) and I still think it is brilliant

lastly, i agree with your point that we click on a banner with a question and the banner sends us somewhere else is in fact not friendly
Nicolas Chabanovsky
Nicolas Chabanovsky
Could you please tell me what target page should we use according the initial idea?
aki
aki
in yuki's email (which i was only cced), he said (i think) here ja.stackoverflow.com/questions?sort=votes
Nicolas Chabanovsky
Nicolas Chabanovsky
Let's then pick some title that will describe the target page? What do you think?
aki
aki
but it is true that if you read 「Python のプログラムを実行可能バイナリにコンパイルするには？」and then click on it, then you would expect to go to the actual page which is ja.stackoverflow.com/questions/42597/…
hmm
@nekketsuuu sos sos
@NicolasChabanovsky if you click on this ja.stackoverflow.com/questions?sort=votes can you see nekketsuuu's question?
if it is 15/page, then none of those banner titles show up (previously it was 50/page on my screen)
 
3 hours later…
nekketsuuu
nekketsuuu
10:11 AM
@aki If you want to show only my Q&As, this URL will help: ja.stackoverflow.com/search?tab=votes&q=user%3a19110
aki
aki
@nekketsuuu do you have any preference for the landing page?
ちょっと日本語で⤴︎
プラス票の多い@nekketsuuu さんと@yohjp さんのバナーですが
現在ランディングページとアクションボタンの文言を検討中です
他の6つは「質問しよう」（let's ask）
https://ja.stackoverflow.com/questions/ask
にしようと思うのですが
それではお二人のバナーにはあいません。
ランディングページが実際のご質問のページであれば（ニックさんはこっちの方がよいと思われているような）
https://ja.stackoverflow.com/q/42597/14055
https://ja.stackoverflow.com/q/22446/14055
「この質問の答えは？」 (what is the answer to this question?)
「質問をみてみよう」（let's see the question)
などいかがなものかと考えてました。
ランディングページが得票数最多ページであれば
https://ja.stackoverflow.com/questions?sort=votes
「気になる質問を探してみよう」 (let's take a look and find some interesting questions)
あたりでも良いのかな、と。
nekketsuuu:
https://ja.stackoverflow.com/search?tab=votes&q=user%3a19110


yohjp
https://ja.stackoverflow.com/search?tab=votes&q=user%3a49


you are right! these may work, too
 
3 hours later…
Nicolas Chabanovsky
Nicolas Chabanovsky
12:56 PM
@nekketsuuu Hello! Thank you for the slogans. I think if we use the title of a particular question then the banner with that title should direct to the question instead of some sorting. What do you think?
If we want to direct to most upvoted questions we probably need to have an appropriate title so when a user clicks on a banner thy know what they will see.
nekketsuuu
nekketsuuu
1:35 PM
@NicolasChabanovsky Hello :) I agree with Nic; it's better that a banner with a particular question links to that question.
Nicolas Chabanovsky
Nicolas Chabanovsky
Could you please tell me what would you like/do you think will work best (1) a banner with a title that leads to the question or (2) a banner that leads to most voted questions?
I think both options are fine!
nekketsuuu
nekketsuuu
Hmm... Is the question title short enough for a banner?
If so, I prefer (1).
Nicolas Chabanovsky
Nicolas Chabanovsky
Nice! Thank you!
nekketsuuu
nekketsuuu
@aki How about 「質問を見る」 (see the question) for a message of an action button?
 
9 hours later…
aki
aki
10:59 PM
「質問を見る」 (see the question) sounds great, thank you so much @nekketsuuu !
@NicolasChabanovsky final version will be sent to you via email. 「質問を見る」 (See the question) for nekketsuuu and yohjp's top questions, and 「質問をする」 (Ask a question) for payaneco, nekketsuuu, and Phroneris's slogans as their action buttons. Let me know what you think 🙏

« first day (1572 days earlier)      last day (2066 days later) »