« first day (1315 days earlier)      last day (3265 days later) » 

 
1 hour later…
10:01 PM
As I reflect on it, I'm puzzled why the word "Exegetical...." begins this close-reason. I feel like it would be preferable simply to have "Questions that start...". Maybe I'm just a miserable pedant, though. :) — Davïd 49 secs ago
^^^^ @Dan @JackDouglas @Susan @JonEricson
@Davïd To the exclusion of questions about hermeneutical approaches (which don’t require a specific text), I believe. — Susan ♦ 1 min ago
Right, well that makes sense. :) My sense lingers that there's a quirk in the close-reason still.
 
10:17 PM
@Davïd Because the very ones we’re closing aren’t really exegetical?
 
@Susan Pretty much. I've been pondering alternate wordings, but not coming up with much by way of improvement (or that I'm happy with either).
 
10:34 PM
0
A: Please can we have a custom close reason "...doesn't start from the text..."?

DavïdYet another option: Questions which fail to focus on the biblical text or hermeneutical approaches to it are off topic. I think we all agree pretty much on what we want to "prohibit", but I'm not sure we've nailed the best way to signal it in the reasons offered: the "...regarding systema...

^^^ My best shot through bleary eyes and flakey wifi. Will see how many holes have been shot through it ... some time soon. ;)
 

« first day (1315 days earlier)      last day (3265 days later) »