« first day (3392 days earlier)      last day (1562 days later) » 
00:00 - 14:0014:00 - 00:00

2:34 PM
Site appears to be down for me
oh, maybe not?
 
Was definitely down/slow for me too
 
@Someone_Evil So... last Thursday I charged headlong into a doorframe. Hit my forehead hard enough that I have a black eye. I don't recommend anyone else do it.
 
@nitsua60 Dang, way to ruin my weekend plans!
 
@nitsua60 What about archways, gateposts, or other portals?
 
@Someone_Evil Best way to enter a portal is to headbutt it
 
user15026
2:43 PM
@nitsua60 oh lovely. No concussion? (I ask only because this summer I tripped and hit my head on a chair post hard enough to give myself a minor concussion and had to take a week off work and still have weird light sensitivity issues)
 
2:56 PM
@Ash Oh, definitely a concussion. First I've had since I was a kid, I think.
(None of the falls/hits I took during college athletics compared to this, IIRC.)
@Someone_Evil I have no relevant experience. Extrapolate as you wish -)
 
3:08 PM
@nitsua60 woof, sorry man. I've definitely clocked myself on my shed doorframe a couple times.
 
3:22 PM
@nitsua60 Just saw this in the starred messages, thanks for sharing, it was pretty great
 
@trogdor sometimes; depends on if there is a chance for failure or not.
 
So a neighbor kid had gotten the Stranger Things starter set and we started playing it with a couple of his siblings and my son. Pretty sure I got 'em hooked.
Played saturday night and again Sunday night.
 
@jgn published adventures seem to lead to that if people try to emulate them ...
@jgn not even opinion. fact :-)
@MikeQ yes! I did a ton of those in AD&D era, and not as may in 5e but I still do some and it really depends on the players how well it goes.
@NautArch you are a great neighbor. :)
 
3:40 PM
@KorvinStarmast I definitely had as much fun as they did :)
Most of the kids were under 10, so it was a lot of teaching them how to play as we played.
And then me realizing the next day what stuff I forgot. Namely, I forgot to look at the Bard's sheet and tell them about bardic inspiration/cutting words.
 
@NautArch you didn't forget, you're introducing the mechanics incrementally :)
 
@MarkWells yeah, that's the ticket!
 
Now for the fun game of "Did I get the runtime error before or after my comment updated?"
 
@PierreCathé It's a pretty cool competition--I wish it'd been around when I was in high school. [checks website] Correction: I wish I'd become aware of it when I was in high school!
@NautArch My son's started running it. I really like the approach they took to teaching a kid of that age to run a simple adventure. (Still not quite as good as Mentzer redbox, IMO, but pretty darn good.)
 
@nitsua60 It's definitely above their pay grade to run it right now. It even seems like some more descriptions are necessary.
And it was odd that the wizard/bard have their full allotment of possible spells (wizard has less than they should, though), but the cleric has to pick their non-domain spells.
 
3:54 PM
So I saw a homebrew about adapting Pokemon into magical items and it got me interested.
> Sand Veil, Wondrous item. This wispy brown shawl prevents vision reduction due to sandstorms. When attuned, wearer can choose to create a sandstorm centered on self with a radius of 10 feet once per day. Entities inside the sandstorm are lightly obscured and the wearer gains the mirror image effect.
 
I know that Homebrew (unless there are multiple...)
 
@Medix2 There are probably multiple
 
Well, I was looking at this one:
The sand veil is something I came up with based on the Sand Veil ability.
 
Yeah I do happen to know that one
I see you've mixed in a bit of Sand Stream as well
 
Yeah I figured it was otherwise a very very situational item if you weren't able to generate a sandstorm.
 
4:02 PM
I assume the sandstorm lasts 1 minute?
 
Hmm... hadn't decided on a duration.
 
Clearly the answer is 2 days
 
40 days and 40 nights.
After which, the devil will come to tempt you.
With what? I dunno, a Klondike bar?
 
A whole box of Klondike bars
 
There was another magical item that interested me that centered around making the wearer resistant to time manipulation effects.
Both negative (slow) and beneficial (haste).
 
4:07 PM
time stop would be weird
(cue scenes from JoJo's)
 
> The hands on this pocketwatch appear to move erratically, springing forward and backwards at apparently random intervals, making it useless for normal timekeeping. But when the wearer is affected by a time manipulation effect, the hands swing to 12 and begin to tick like a normal clock.
 
I think I finally played a real session of D&D last night. We went to the docks and stole a boat so that we could have a boat. No other reason. Just wanted a boat, and 10,000gp was too much to spend on a boat.
 
@Xirema PCs doing PC stuff
 
The real solution is to invent the airplane/airship, not to use it, but to sell it for enough money to buy a boat
 
@Medix2 Airships are 20,000gp according to the DMG...
 
4:15 PM
@Xirema Did you get the boat only to realize no one could sail it?
 
Two boats!
 
@NautArch No, we didn't get to play out that trope. Myself and our Monk both have Water Vehicle Proficiency.
The guy we rescued in the previous session tried to bully my character into letting him captain the boat instead, and.... Well. He got to keep his life, I don't know why everyone is complaining about all the blood. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
 
@Xirema uhh... what kind of boat is half the price of an airship?
 
@Yuuki To be fair, the DMG only prices out the big boats, like the "transport an entire platoon" ships, not the "transport yourself and your companions down a river" ships.
 
Is it a bad idea to reopen this question? I'm just not seeing the duplicate in there
 
4:31 PM
@Medix2 it looks reopenable
 
I'm always nervous to use the gold badge privilege when a question very much feels duplicate or not duplicate to me and then I worry about if I'm just not seeing something
 
GcL
It can get unmarked as duplicate? correct?
 
Currently looking at this and this and I know where I stand but then there's that nervousness
 
GcL
@Xirema Isn't that approximately a longboat?
@Xirema Looks like it's listed as a keelboat in the players handbook. "A keelboat is a riverine cargo-capable working boat, or a small- to mid-sized recreational sailing yacht"
Probably could do a couple of canoes... which are approximately rowboats.
 
@GcL Hmm, maybe.
 
4:49 PM
Leafy Sombrero, Wondrous item. This blue-colored sombrero is festooned with leaves and foliage. Its wide brim and tall curved edges allow it to hold a sizable amount of water. When attuned, the wearer can choose to consume a charge to gain 1d8 healing. Consuming a charge lowers the water level of the sombrero. At max capacity of 1 gallon, the sombrero contains 4 charges.
 
@Yuuki I see your rain dish, correctly inspired by the Lotad line
 
5:01 PM
@Medix2 "What would you do for a Klondike bar?" "Get thee behind me, Satan."
 
@Medix2 If you consume 4 charges of the sombrero in one encounter, a bushy mustache springs into existence under your nose.
 
Should this question be split into multiple scenarios?
 
5:18 PM
@NautArch I would say so just because they all seem pretty different to me. One is a specific spell, the other is a spell, uh, making a spell. And the other is summoned creatures.
@NautArch I think it should be split because there are currently 8 possible answers, an each would need to justify three separate claims
 
Just voted to close and left a comment
 
5:35 PM
@nitsua60 Precisely
 
6:01 PM
Anybody know why refreshing the page that results when I search "deleted:1" changes the ordering of the results? There seems to be two it keeps going back-and-forth between, oh nope, got a third now
 
6:28 PM
@Medix2 Which sort mode?
 
6:41 PM
@Someone_Evil Apparently it defaults to "Relevance"
 
@Medix2 So it is sorted by relevance to an empty string, it doesn't surprise me that it is acting chaotically
 
Yeah, that makes sense to me now, didn't realize it had changed to relevance-sort
 
GcL
@NautArch Yeah. Let the OP ask separate questions perhaps?
 
6:58 PM
@GcL oh definitely!
 
7:09 PM
The key to any successful plant now harvest later game is doing a ton of drudge work in the beginning.
 
@JohnP And surviving the first Winter (or equivalent)
 
 
1 hour later…
8:23 PM
6
Q: Do flying creatures count as anchor points for the Web spell?

aaron9eeeSeveral size Large flying creatures are attacking my party. I'd like to cast Web to prevent their escape and limit their ranged advantage. Relevant parts of the Web spell description say: The webs fill a 20-foot cube from that point for the duration. [...] If the webs aren't anchored be...

 
GcL
8:33 PM
What do you think about the following in regards to this question: spells that essentially constitute magical traps are those that can be cast on something other than the victim and require the victim to trigger them.
 
I'm very ready for an "Ask your GM", because what counts as damage from a creature is kinda nebulous
 
@Medix2 Any creature that can cast magic is da mage.
 
@GcL I think @Medix2 has it right that this unfortunately falls within the DM ruling. It's really not clear.
 
GcL
@Medix2 Everything is that answer. i like answers that provide at least a reasonable decision someone could read and run with.
How to make an attack? Rules say this, but DM caveat always applies so ask your DM.
 
I also don't understand the source of 'magical trap'.
It's a spell, cast by a creature, with effects.
 
GcL
8:41 PM
Traps don't count as damage from a creature. There exist magical traps that don't count as damage from a creature... they're usually encountered as features of a dungeon or something like that. So, could it be reasonable to interpret spells like symbol as a magical trap?
@NautArch A trap is a device set by a character with effects.
 
@GcL Yeah, i'm just not sure about treating spells like traps.
I mean, would you say the 'snare' spell would qualify as such?
 
GcL
@NautArch ooo... this is interesting find traps detects glyph of warding.
@NautArch snare is xgte?
 
@GcL yeah
 
GcL
@NautArch Snare is a good find. That one literally says it becomes a magical trap
 
I'm still not sure i'm on board with some spells not being directly tied to the caster of it.
But I could end up there :)
But given that snare specifically states it becomes a trap. If another spell doesn't state that, i'm not sure i'd consider it as such.
 
GcL
8:54 PM
On the other hand.. how many psychic damage dealing magical traps are there? I think glyph of warding is the only way you can get there.
 
IMHO, if you cast a spell that ultimately does direct damage to someone, unless it specifically imbued some other actor with the power to do that damage, you are the source of that damage
 
GcL
@NautArch Having it explicitly spelled out is nice, but it looks like, quacks like, and moves like a duck... it's a duck
 
@GcL Why does the damage type matter?
 
GcL
@Medix2 The question was in regards to reflecting psychic damage" " whenever a creature deals psychic damage to you, that creature takes the same amount of damage that you do."
 
Oh for the feature that happens to be in question here. Though note there may be other features that apply to other damage types
I think the real question here is "When does damage count as having been dealt by a creature" and that's uh....
 
8:58 PM
@GcL That's not a terrible methodology, but given the other weirdness around rules, the opposite case remains true, too (if it doesn't say it, it isn't it.)
 
Heck does catapult count as the creature doing the damage? Does even firebolt? I at least don't think there's a reason to consider how far abstracted away from the original caster some instance of damage is because that forces you to draw a line somewhere
 
@Carcer That's kinda where i'm sitting right now. But @GcL is starting to put together a good argument.
 
GcL
@Medix2 That's the point. Where to draw the line.
And by what criteria
 
@GcL THe line may be if the spell specifically states something (like snare is a trap), but even then...it may be that there is no line.
 
GcL
That's a reasonably conservative approach.
 
9:01 PM
while this whole discussion smacks of "overthinking this one" I think it would be cool for the situation the question asks about, glyph of warding, to trigger the GOO ability and wherever the glyph maker is they suffer the psychic damage.
It also talles the glyph maker 'huh, someone with a psychic/psionic ability just triggerd my glyph!"
 
GcL
@KorvinStarmast Also a reasonable approach. Which for a PvP situation essentially rules out a lot of magic traps.
@KorvinStarmast Do they get to know the source? or just "you take 14 points of psychic damage" and the caster ends up blaming it on the poorly cooked carrot cake they were consuming at the time.
Or worse, someone around them... "I don't recall inviting an ithillid to the dinner party..."
 
9:13 PM
"An Illithid at Dinner" sounds like a book out of The Elder Scrolls
 
9:28 PM
Or some kind of children's eldritch horror book.
Where like if you look closer at the situation, it's incredibly messed up but it's couched in fun language and the main character doesn't seem to suffer any adverse conditions as a result of the frankly psychopathic levels of child abuse he's undergone.
Because magic.
 
9:43 PM
@GcL Maybe to a raw INT check to recall if they recall setting the glyph ...
 
GcL
@KorvinStarmast What's the check to know about other classes features and how they operate? Arcana?
 
Kate Hepburn's "Guess Who's Coming to Dinner" gets more interesting if the guest is an illithid (no slam on Sidney Poitier)
@GcL That would be my guess if it's a caster
So the Ilithid is coming to dinner, and you just realize that the appetizer the caterer offered is calimari. AWKWARD!
 
@KorvinStarmast That's the thing I couldn't remember the name of!
 
I fell in love with calimari when we lived in Italy.
 
@Yuuki Pretending this isn't obviously just referencing Harry Potter. 🤣
 
9:47 PM
But the best calimari I ever had was in Crete.
 
9:58 PM
@Xirema i'm just saying, if a kid in real life was relegated to a cupboard under the stairs for 10 years of his life while spiders dangled above his head constantly, his first thought might not be "let's prevent the evil dude from killing all the people".
 
@Yuuki don't forget he has no friends!
 
lol
 
10:34 PM
7
Q: How can I replace a lost Horn?

user61347So I play a tiefling phoenix sorcerer (lvl 9) and we had an encounter with two half-dragons in a forest. At first there was only one and me being a sorcerer I stayed back and used ranged attacks but the other one sneaked up on me and because of his action surge he absolutely massacred me. I was o...

5
Q: Does a Cure Wounds living spell exist in RAW?

RorpWhen I heard about Eberron and its living spells, I almost immediately thought about a living Cure Wounds spell (or any "friendly" spell) that may become the pet of one of my players' characters. I never had the possibility to put them in a situation where they may encounter such spell... Until n...

 
10:49 PM
Robert Angus of Lark Brigade has collected every single-player physical game and every two-player physical game on itch.io.
 
11:35 PM
7
Q: Does cure wounds damage undead?

PadMarI'm brand new to 5e and want to play a cleric. When I last played over 30 years ago, cure wounds could heal a PC or damage undead. Is that still the case?

 
00:00 - 14:0014:00 - 00:00

« first day (3392 days earlier)      last day (1562 days later) »