« first day (3210 days earlier)      last day (1746 days later) » 

12:01 AM
6
Q: Is it okay to retroactively change things when running a published adventure?

Keven MThis question came out of another post on here of mine, so there may be some similarities. An answerer/commenter on that question suggested splitting it off, so here goes: I'm a new DM, using Lost Mine of Phandelver to run a campaign. During the course of this adventure, I discovered what I deem...

 
 
@Carcer And then astropaths are literally soulbound to the emperor (by the sacrifice of their sight) so they're even safer.
@Ben From memory (I'd have to look at sources to be sure) a really powerful vox can communicate on interplanetary levels.
Anything beyond that you'd need an astropath. Or more likely an astropath choir, since astropaths capable of long distance communication by themselves are few and far between.
 
@Miniman There's an apostrophe joke in there somewhere.
 
Ben
12:18 AM
@rubiksmoose the cantrip question has been edited to add the 5e tag
 
@BESW I've never run across that before. Oh apostrophe, I'm sorry for my ignorance towards you all these years.
 
12:35 AM
Morning all.
How was/is everyone's weekend?
 
hey there @linksassin, how're things going?
 
@Shalvenay Not too bad for a monday morning.
 
Ben
@linksassin pretty good actually. Productive, relaxed.
 
@Ben Good to hear!
 
Ben
Did a bit of archery, cleaned and did the washing and ironing and all that, and I got volume 2 of my Power Ranger comics this week, so I've dived into that
I had them on back order, so I got volume 1, 3, 4 and 5. Haha
 
12:46 AM
@linksassin alright here
 
@Ben Nice. Wife and I finally finished out dice boxes we've had in the shed for weeks. Did a bunch of cooking.
And most importantly very narrowly avoided a TPK last night.
4 player party. Cleric, Druid, Paladin were all down. Good thing the rogue had a healing potion and the DM gave our cleric an OP AoE healing item.
 
Ben
@linksassin GASP. Talk about a close call!!
@linksassin Nice! Productivity is always an enjoyable thing :D
 
@Ben We were up against hobgoblins. They had two 7th level casters. 6 fireball/lightning bolts is hard to face. Hence why the rogue was the only one up.
 
Ben
@linksassin Oh wow. Yup. That high dex pays off! Haha
 
As the druid I got into and out of wild shape without getting an attack because I got hit so hard. I think I took over 100 points of damage in 3 rounds.
@Ben Evasion. Fireball directly on her, 0 damage.
 
Ben
12:56 AM
Oh, and on a sidenote, Jason David Frank is working on a new MMPR series, which follows on from the Boom Studios comic books (follows on/maybe diverts from)
@linksassin Ahhh yup.
What system you playing again?
 
@Ben That game is in 5e.
 
Ben
Ah ok
 
Also, not sure how many sports fans are in this room but what on earth happened in england last night? Wimbledon, Cricket World Cup, Silverstone F1 GP. All hectic crazy results.
 
Ben
We had the opposite problem in Pathfinder. The enemy had "blur" (25 or under on a percentile negates all damage). They consistently passed the roll, and tpk'd us because of that. Lol
@linksassin @BlackSpike might know haha
 
1:13 AM
@linksassin yikes
 
Um
Lol
Ok so that's the table you roll on
I do like how for at least one of them, ghosts show up and the Psyker is the only one who isn't scared
Because screw that they probably see worse ever Tuesday
XD
 
Ben
@trogdor "Oh hey Tom! Haven't seen you in a while"
 
Lol
 
Ben
Didn't realise it was 2 separate images
 
1:30 AM
Oh I was wondering why none of those seemed all that bad for an interdimensional intrusion of demonic psychic energies
Oh so they don't turn into demons
More like switch places with one
Which is still extremely horrible
Just to be clear
 
Ben
Haha. "Well this isn't so bad what are you talking abou--oh. Oh. Oh no."
 
Well like, I would take most of the things in the first list over most of the ones In the second one
It's not that they aren't bad things
 
Ben
Yeah, that's the idea
 
Ben
1:50 AM
The general reaction is "not 99... not 99... not 99..."
 
Well 99 and 100 are both pretty bad
 
And you can build your character such that you will basically never roll on the second table.
 
Ah
That seems like a good idea
 
Which will also minimize the effect of rolling on the first table.
 
XD
 
Ben
1:52 AM
Yes, Both end in character "death", but 100 is just [pop].
 
It's called not being a Psyker?
XP
 
@trogdor That's one way. Just...the worst way. One thing I really like is that if you're making a psyker, the game steers you towards making good choices that will lower the chances of something bad happening.
 
@Ben so it's sorta less horrible even if for you as the player it's hardly different in terms of losing your character
@Miniman fair enough
XD
 
Ben
99 is [pop]… Hello
@Miniman We kinda went for the Get. A. Psychic. Hood... PLEASE. approach
 
@Ben That's a 1e thing.
In 2e, the psychic rules are apparently vastly improved.
 
2:01 AM
@Ben true, for your buddies there is a huge difference XD
 
Ben
2:20 AM
@Miniman Yeah, I haven't had any experience with 2e. Our games were very brutal. Haha
Which I enjoyed, to an extent. The brutality made surviving the adventure that much more epic, but it was always tense since you were walking the razor's edge 90% of the time
 
@linksassin Halep had her A game on. Serena is still hitting it with that brutal pace. Some of her ground strokes just shot across the court. Heck of a nice job.
As to the men's final, reminds me of the days in the 60's when I was first watching tennis, and before the tie breaker was invented. Marathon tennis. (Also reminds me of a few Borg/McEnroe matches. Those two had a few epics)
As to England wining Cricket world cup .. I have a few friends who are no doubt "legless" at this point ...
 
@KorvinStarmast @BESW and @nitsua60 -- btw: if you all recall the piece by James Mendez-Hodes that BESW linked here a while ago re: decolonizing Orcs, I broke down and sent the author of that piece an email both complimenting him on it (as it's a very useful touchstone for me to communicate why I take umbrage at seeing "ORCS ARE EVIL." signs on the lawn) and describing some of my work on the Ambermoons to him, including a link to the transcript of my one-shot with Korv involving them
 
@Ben It's still brutal!
 
@Shalvenay That was fun. Malik will adventure more some day.
 
2:38 AM
@BESW I am familiar with many others who use such a process :P
@Shalvenay Nice!
 
@V2Blast lol
 
Ben
Haha awesome :D That said, though, it's very much "uhh, I lost a leg, can I get a new one?"
"Do you want rocket skates or jet jumpers?"
 
3:17 AM
@Ben It's not like that on 2e. Getting cybernetics is hard.
Actually, getting equipment in general is crazily difficult.
 
Ben
Hmm... may be a GM thing? My Techpriest started with an Omnissiah axe, just because it's like, a staple. Then he blew my leg off when I got jumped in an alley, and I woke up on the ship with a new leg. "Flesh is weak" style mantra
 
I mean, it's easier for techpriests, but yeah, your GM straight up giving you stuff is definitely circumventing the difficulty.
Our melee specialist didn't even bother taking the talent for power weapons because he knew how extremely unlikely he was to get one.
 
Ben
Fair
We actually had a player go the other way once.
One class starts with an Eviscerator, and he talked the GM down to letting him have only a Chainsword.
 
3:37 AM
Makes sense - the rules heavily favour one-handed weapons.
 
Ben
I was building up to getting three arms, so that I could use my Axe, and my integrated lasrifle in the same round. Lol
 
3:57 AM
You could just use a thingy for the las, right?
Mechadendrite, I mean.
 
Ben
@Miniman Nah it was integrated into my cybernetic arm. I did have a mechadendrite, which was its own weapon too. By then end of it I really was the tank cannon. I had the Mechadendrite, Power Armour, an Omnissiah Rod, and looking into a third arm, to allow for more attacks per round. Lol
It was a little unbalanced XD
 
4:41 AM
2
Q: What is the standard dungeon scale at the table?

munkI’m reading the Caverns of Thracia and I see the maps have a scale of 1” to 40’ for the most part - that seems to be about 4 squares. My understanding is that in AD&D if you have a movement rate of 12”, that means you move 120’ in “imaginary world scale”. Should I be using a scale of 1” = 10’...

 
5:18 AM
Good morning
Oh, I seem to have broken into 40k reputation over the weekend
 
Nice
 
Ben
@kviiri Welcome to the Imperium
 
It says here I unlocked a secret privilege that I can browse RPGSE at work and my boss can't get mad at me
 
Ben
Unless you're with Chaos. In which case get out of the Imperium. Heretic.
@kviiri Scoooooore
Wait...
We're not talking 40K like "Warhammer 40K" are we? Hahaha
 
@kviiri lol
 
6:03 AM
Joke's on him, I'm actually on vacation
 
6:23 AM
@kviiri Time to test it!
 
6:35 AM
@kviiri XD
 
0
Q: Whats the proper way to address possible copyright infringement in posts?

ZaibisI was wondering, because I see this happening especially often on this Stack site. Most recently I made the poster of this answer aware that by the License Blizzard is granting for their materials, you are not allowed to sublicense their material. And since posting something on the SE network th...

 
 
1 hour later…
7:40 AM
3
Q: How can I design a witch (or other enemy) that summons/controls lightning birds at sea to attack the party while hidden on a ship?

AntistrophyThe PCs (3 of them, at 3rd level) are on a disabled, abandoned pirate ship at sea in a storm. I want them to have hard encounters that become somewhat predictable and that they can put a stop to, so that they can concentrate on getting out of the situation. My idea is that there is a hidden pir...

 
 
3 hours later…
10:54 AM
Something odd is happening with the comments on this answer, the first three comments by AgentPaper are already in the associated chat so I flagged them for removal with a custom flag. All the flags were marked "helpful" but the comments are still there. No mods around right now I see but when one comes around could they take a look?
 
@Sdjz I've flagged them individually following this advice/plea. Flags are still active. My guess, your flag got marked before it was removed, someone got distracted and oops.
 
@Someone_Evil Hm perhaps, odd that they would become helpful, from what I heard of moderator tools, the helpful/unhelpful thing on comments is kinda automatic in regards to deleting the comment or leaving it there. I have flagged them all again anyway.
 
hey there @JohnP, how're things going?
 
@Sdjz If it's a custom flag there is probably no automation
 
OK. Just sitting in airport.
 
11:07 AM
@Someone_Evil Only 1 was custom though, which was explaining that comments were in chat and then the others were "no longer needed".
 
@JohnP ah, taking a trip, or waiting for someone?
 
@Sdjz Well, if the diamond who knows wants to chime in that's their prerogative, if not: no harm done.
 
@Someone_Evil Sure, it's no big deal, I just thought it was weird (or maybe a bug perhaps?) so it'd be nice to clarify.
 
11:30 AM
morning
 
 
1 hour later…
12:55 PM
@Shalvenay And what really gets me is that in the original D&D, orcs could be neutral or chaotic, while kobolds were only chaotic ... but I guess things morphed over time ...
And in Keep on the Border Lands, you'd do a lot better if you parleyed with a few of the monster groups than if you tried to just dungeon crawl your way from one end to the other.
 
1:10 PM
Kobolds? Rainbow kobolds?
(and yep, I know it says "goblins", but that is actually a translation error)
 
1:26 PM
@Derpy My kids looooooove that book. So much so they've each had me come in and read it to their grade-school class.
 
@Akixkisu The bulette encounter went awesome! Realized I didn't even need to consider advantage because it began with erupting out and jumping on them :)
 
Morning everyone. :)
 
@NautArch Fun for the whole party! :) (Did it eat any halflings?)
 
@KorvinStarmast It didn't, thankfully only one NPC went down during the encounter, but they healed him.
I also tried to, somewhat heavy handedly, suggest tht they should take a long rest "The guards with you are very uncertain about approaching the house they were heading towards. It's approaching night and they'd rather rest up before figuring out what's wrong"
But the party said "nah, let's just go in"
Had to scale back the encounter or it would have been a tpk.
 
@nitsua60 @Rubiksmoose Hello! This is purely out of curiosity at this point since the comments are now gone but do you perhaps have an explanation for what happened here?
 
1:37 PM
@Sdjz I just saw that comment and am looking through it now.
 
I'm all booked for our annual trip to the Garlic Festival.
 
@goodguy5 I didn't know you were coming over for dinner.
 
You'd better be prepared to feed the Garlic King (I won the garlic-eating competition last year)
 
@Rubiksmoose mornin!
@goodguy5 which one?
 
@NautArch Shawnee
 
1:43 PM
@goodguy5 Nice! We've gone to one up in VT, but it as...underwhelming. Mostly because I grew up near Gilroy, CA that had an incredible one.
 
@Sdjz from what I can tell, when the post was deleted it resolved the active comment flags on the post and marked the flags as helpful. When the post got undeleted, all the comments came back with it. Then they were reflagged and then actively purged by us.
 
@NautArch Doesn't Gilroy produce pretty much all of the domestic garlic in the US?
 
@Sdjz That was a weird progression of comments
 
Granted, most garlic in the US is imported, IIRC.
 
@Yuuki That's my memory. They are a HUGE garlic producer.
@goodguy5 I used to have indoor track meets back inhigh school at East Stroudsburg University.
 
1:45 PM
> The United States – ranked 10th in global production of garlic – grows less than 1% of China's production. Much of the garlic production in the United States is centered in Gilroy, California, which calls itself the "Garlic Capital of the World".
 
oh! nice
@NautArch Are you coming down to the festival, then?
Id love to beat you in Mortal Gombat
 
Huh. China grows more than 80% of the world's garlic.
 
@Yuuki well, they're really big
 
@Yuuki That's why they only have 20% of the world's vampires
 
@Rubiksmoose Oh that makes sense. So deleting causes flags to be marked helpful and removed from the comments without any other effects. That explains it, thank you for investigating
 
1:46 PM
hrm.... I feel like I recall something about chinese undead mythos.....

Like zombies, but with a scroll?
 
@MikeQ Pareto principle at work--good to see =)
@Rubiksmoose Nice sleuthing =)
 
A jiangshi, also known as a Chinese "hopping" zombie, is a type of reanimated corpse in Chinese legends and folklore. "Jiangshi" is read geung-si in Cantonese, Phi Dip Chin in Thai, cương thi in Vietnamese, gangshi in Korean, kyonshī in Japanese, and "hantu pocong" in Malay and Indonesia. It is typically depicted as a stiff corpse dressed in official garments from the Qing Dynasty, and it moves around by hopping, with its arms outstretched. It kills living creatures to absorb their qi, or "life force", usually at night, while in the day, it rests in a coffin or hides in dark places such as caves...
 
one of the most disturbing races ever happened there. The track goes underneath the seating at one point and my friend went in, but didn't come out. TUrns out, his quad muscle detached/tore from the bone.
 
@NautArch ow
 
@goodguy5 ha, no. We're further away now :)
 
1:48 PM
@Sdjz Yeah--if someone flags a comment and it is then deleted, the system auto-marks the flag as helpful. Deleting a post also deletes all comments, so the auto-helpful flows from that.
 
@NautArch WHY WOULD YOU TELL US THAT
 
@goodguy5 The US is equally big with arguably more arable land.
 
*shudder*
@NautArch aw, sad.I think it's about 90 minutes for us?
 
@Yuuki Yeah, he was in total shock.
 
maybe 2 hours, depending on traffic
 
1:50 PM
@Sdjz Yup! Specifically in this case deleting a post causes comments to be deleted. And comments being deleted seems to cause the flags on them the be marked as helpful (this is what would happen if the community got the comments deleted without mod intervention by reaching the flag threshold). And no problem :) Who doesn't like a good mystery on a Monday morning?
 
@goodguy5 Sharing the pain(ful memory)
incredibly,someone cast regenerate and he was able to recovery faster than the docs said and was able to row that spring season for crew (and his boat won nationals)
 
@NautArch Gah! That is horror movie material for a runner right there.
 
Bodies are so fragile
 
@Rubiksmoose It was very confusing for a bit. No one knew what happened.
 
@nitsua60 the first edition has become pretty rare. Aaaaand pricey.
 
1:58 PM
@Derpy Not going to lie, I like that book cover a lot.
 
@goodguy5 just sacks of blood and bones waiting to burst at the slightest provocation
 
@NautArch Nice! (and yay for stories with happy endings!)
 
@Rubiksmoose Cover? One of the main feature of that book is that every single page is a painting
 
@Carcer That's how I feel about Stirge
 
@Derpy Oh. Well then. That sounds quite awesome!
 
2:01 PM
@Rubiksmoose Or just a biped! Graaah!%$#&
 
@Derpy So what's you're saying is Every Frame (is) A Painting?
 
@Rubiksmoose Yeah, it was a near-miraculous recovery.
 
@Rubiksmoose Yeah, and they're very dense (in terms of detail) and vibrant and colorful paintings. The kids just fall into each double-page spread.
 
[makes a mental note of this book for future]
 
@NautArch That sounds like a Disney/Lifetime straight-to-DVD movie.
 
2:07 PM
@Yuuki Ha! Probably could have been!
He was literally told by his doc "You will not recover in time for the next sports season"
 
@Rubiksmoose I was looking if there is a preview of the book available somewhere (google books, amazon) but could find none. Best thing to give you an idea is this small screen from Google image search
 
oh.... I found something... Look here - seems this is his official web site. On this page you can see some artwork from his books
 
@Carcer hehehe
 
And if you go to the "movies" page and notice that oddly there are some design and pictures for characters in the Neverending Story movie... well... it is because he actually worked on the movie.
 
2:13 PM
@Derpy That's...incredible.
 
@NautArch Awesome, I'm not having much luck at testing Fast Friends (but a lot of fun!), so far the new NPC gang of low to medium level casters has successfully murdered six player parties.
So I'm probably not going to put it into a campaign any time soon.
 
@Akixkisu I still think it's not meant for combat.
I also scaled back the bulette's attack damage dice. That 4d12 is bonkers.
well, I probably didn't need to use ita gainst a level 4 party. but I did.
 
@NautArch yes, but it is scarily effective at combat and preparing combat. Since the gang is doing most of the ambushing (so far), they can achieve a lot before the combat proper starts. In combat proper, it affects the action economy as expected.
@NautArch yup and that +7 to hit makes it pretty consistent, how long did the combat last?
 
@Akixkisu about 3 rounds.
Jumped twice, attacked once. At the end, it tried to run, but it was cut down with opportunity attacks.
The next encounter I used one of the CHamberlains of Zuggmtoy and our fighter currently has the madness :D
 
2:30 PM
That sounds like a great session, I love those fungi.
 
@Akixkisu It was super fun - although (thankfully) I forgot they had piercing resistance.
 
@Carcer Happy Monday to you too! lol
 
@NautArch and bludgeoning on top of that which kind of balances the low hp and keeps them in the CR 2 range while their offensive abilities are very high on the CR 2 side, almost CR 3. Madness is pretty neat.
Most of the Out of Abyss stuff is great in general.
 
2:47 PM
@Akixkisu Yeah I hope it lasts a bit :) Did tell him it's RP only and not to come up in combat.
THe paladin also failed the save...but they're immune to disease.
 
@G.Moylan That's a sticky wicket. This may go under the purveyors of cheese.
 
@NautArch I'm just a simple man sheep, trying to make my way in the universe barnyard
 
@G.Moylan good question and a newbie gets some rep. win win
 
That answer was fast.
 
2:55 PM
@G.Moylan Wait, so the cultist casts Tongues on himself?
 
I've seen faster.
 
@Yuuki yes (he's foreign)
 
Ah, read that second clause more closely and now it makes more sense.
 
@goodguy5 I mean it is a new account that looks like it was created to answer that question, not someone who already had an account.
 
Wait, doesn't language proficiency fall under game statistics?
 
2:57 PM
@Someone_Evil See the related link in coomments
 
I have a related question in the wings about whether Tongues works with creatures that can't speak languages. Like Sheep.
 
How fluent are you if you're proficient in a language? Like, I know enough Mandarin to get by in everyday conversation but any chat that lasts longer than 10 minutes is going to be rough.
 
"Speak read and write"
I assume that to mean as proficient as I am in english
which isn't perfect, but good enough
 
@G.Moylan That's a simpler question. See the tongues requirement.
 
@NautArch rephrase: does a sheep speak Sheep?
 
3:04 PM
Sahuagin speak Sahuagin.
 
@G.Moylan speak with animals is a thing :)
 
Hook Horrors speak Hook Horror
 
@goodguy5 yeah but they're sea goblins. They have a society and culture
@Someone_Evil also explicitly explained in their MM entry
 
eh... a society sure, but culture.... unlikely
Though in my most recent run game, the players found a diary of one of the sahuagin. And there was a "reformed" Sahuagin that runs a casino in the shady party of town called "Toothy Joe"
 
@G.Moylan Storm King's Thunder says no
 
3:06 PM
@Sdjz oh by lack of language, got it
 
@goodguy5 Is that the name of the Sahuagin, the casino, or the part of town?
 
@Someone_Evil lol I was thinking that
 
ha!

The Sahuagin is called "Toothy Joe", with his location being "Toothy Joe's"

The part of town is ..... something "district"..... can't think of it atm
but it's understood as the shady part of town.
"Midnight District", maybe? I'd have to check my notes
 
ah yes the Shady District. Known for the beautiful trees and the viciously high crime rate
 
I generally prefer the Hammock District
 
3:10 PM
It's laid back?
 
not The Shades?
 
@goodguy5 The Toothy District?
Located in the Joe Suburbs?
 
Something I never understood: languages that I can't speak, read, or write.
 
wait..... is that pun?
 
@goodguy5 is it?
@G.Moylan raises eyebrows. Doofy grin
 
3:14 PM
"You don't understand languages that you can't speak, read, or write"
 
that video is weirder than I remembered
 
3:26 PM
Hmm, are werebears perceived as 'okay' amongst the general populace?
 
I'm not too worried about jealousy with the stat boost. We rolled stats and he was the only one not to get a 17 on his roll. So at best he's getting +1 Strength over what was base and at best he's even now.
 
@NautArch That's likely going to vary by setting.
 
@ConfusedDM THe damage resistance, though. That's a big deal.
 
@NautArch Huh, I think I disagree with Nitsua's answer pretty strongly there actually.
 
@Rubiksmoose submit a new one!
 
3:29 PM
@NautArch He's the only melee though, rest are ranged and a Cleric. That would actually help them keep him up a bit at least. Kinda akin to Barbarian's getting reduction while raging.
 
@NautArch it might be here somewhere, but there's a post about "Is spreading Werebear lycanthropy a good act?"
 
We've got a Fighter, Wizard, Ranger, Warlock and a Cleric.
 
@ConfusedDM Yes, but rage is a resource. This is always-on.
 
@NautArch Another answer already pretty much covers what I'd say.
 
It's totally up to you and your table - but we had someone who embraced their lycanthropy and as a DM it was really tough.
 
3:30 PM
Languages are pretty explicitly part of a creature's statistics (IMO)
 
1
Q: Is it a good act to change a bad guy to being a werebear?

RRRIs it a good act to change a bad guy into a werebear? Since the alignment of a werebear is always lawful good, this would convert the bad guys. But... is it a good act to ignore his intention to forcefully make it lawful good?

 
@Rubiksmoose That's what I had thought. But Nits' answer does seem 'raw'. Maybe not right, but 'raw.
 
@Rubiksmoose Don't underestimate the importance of BODY LANGUAGE, HA!
 
Werebear are Neutral Good in 5e. The guy they fought however resisted the curse and remained evil, so he was in a frenzy (it was during a full moon).
 
@NautArch I'm not sure about that actually. I would say my answer fits into the "likely too strict but RAW" mold and theirs fits into the "reasonable but not RAW" one.
From what I can tell, their argument relies on this:
> Thus, changing your ability scores, statistics, or skills have no effect on your languages. Because those changes haven't changed your experience, by which you acquired language. (Admittedly, those changes might impact your ability to hear, speak, read and/or write, however.)
 
3:33 PM
@ConfusedDM Shouldn't it be neutral good in beast form transformation, though?
 
@Rubiksmoose Which seems odd to me since many acquired features also are a result of experience (sometimes literally in the case of clas features gained by leveling with experience). But moreover I don't see any reason why things gained through experience don't count as statistics per RAW.
 
@ConfusedDM Basically, a lot of monsters deal nonmagical bludgeoning/piercing/slashing damage. Given free resistance is a HUGE boon, especially if you're giving any downsides.
 
does the shifters shift actually put them in full bestial form like wildshape or do they stay roughly humanoid\
 
3
Q: If a player tryes to persuade somebody what should that creature roll not to be persuaded?

AraIt's clear that we should roll insight versus deception (I guess) , but what should be rolled against persuasion or intimidation checks ? Is the answer to this question different for NPCs and PCs?

 
Shifting

As a bonus action, you can assume a more bestial appearance. This transformation lasts for 1 minute, until you die, or until you revert to your normal appearance as a bonus action. When you shift, you gain temporary hit points equal to your level + your Constitution modifier (minimum of 1 temporary hit point). You also gain additional benefits that depend on your shifter subrace, described below.

Once you shift, you can’t do so again until you finish a short or long rest.
 
3:41 PM
@MageintheBarrel You're just gaining an attribute
You aren't changing your whole form.
 
@MageintheBarrel "A more bestial appearance" suggests that you still look roughly the same as before, not as drastic as wild shape for sure
 
i was once told it's like a free wildshield
wildshape*
 
@MageintheBarrel you were once told incorrectly :)
 
go figure
 
Because that isn't mechanically or visually what's happening.
 
3:44 PM
okay then no wildshape race darn I thought that would be a rather cool racial
thanks
are there any bards that focus on singing over instuments in the core content
 
@MageintheBarrel None that I am aware of.
 
@MageintheBarrel Any bard can use their voice rather than an instrument. But if you need a focus, it's only instruments.
 
Though that aspect of the Bardiness is never really explicitly defined except that the instrument serves as the spellcasting focus. Otherwise a bard can specialize in whatever they want without any mechanical impact.
 
GcL
@MageintheBarrel I thought voice didn't count as a bard instrument, so it wasn't useful for casting spells.
 
If you don't want to use a instrument, use a component pouch instead of a focus
 
3:49 PM
16
Q: What counts as a spellcasting focus for bards?

JackInspired by this question: Can a multi-class spellcaster have one thing be two different focuses? The PHB, on p54 says: Spellcasting focus You can use a musical instrument (found in chapter 5) as a spellcasting focus for your bard spells. And yet on p53, the PHB in the introductory desc...

 
@MageintheBarrel There's a special subclass of Bard called "School of the Third (And A Half) Way".
(No, not in 5e but oratory and voice were "instruments" in 3.5e)
 
how does a component pouch differ from a focus? been awhile since I read that part and can't remember where it is
 
Unbounded this question can still be answered, but is it better to close it until OP tells us specific things that apply to them for a better answer?
@MageintheBarrel Mechanically, it doesn't.
 
@MageintheBarrel Spelling, mostly.
 
is that a pun cause it's a very bad one
 
3:51 PM
Maybe the DM would allow a homebrew "microphone" item, as a musical instrument that you play by singing into it
 
@NautArch it's fine as is, IMO, there isn't going to be that extensive a list of options
 
was trying to reflavor a bard to be an "idol" class
 
also what is there a way to be proficient in armour that doesn't allow you to cast spells in it?
 
@MageintheBarrel Microphone instrument.
 
i don't think electricity exists in most variants of 5e
 
3:52 PM
The salient part of having a musical instrument for a focus is that it has to be a physical thing.
 
@MageintheBarrel my instrument proficiencies are SCREAM and DANCE
 
@Carcer Yeah, I just wasn't sure. It's still limited, but it's even better to limit to what's relevant to OP.
 
Microphones can be powered by magic instead of electricity
 
A lot of the time it will actually be beneficial with a CP. Having a sword (or something else) in one hand and one free, with a CP in your belt, will allow you to cast any of your spells. Wereas sword+focus you (RAW) will need to drop something to cast S, non-M spells
 
@Carcer Tenser's Transformation :)
 
3:53 PM
@NautArch hah. Okay, you got me
 
Because back in 3.5e, everyone would use oratory or comedy or whatever as performance so they could keep doing Bard things in the "you're captured and lose your stuff temporarily" cliche.
 
Perform (Youtube Apology Video)
 
> Perform (IT'S JUST A PRANK, BRO)
> Requirement: Chaotic Evil
 
is there a dancer type bard in 5e?
 
@MageintheBarrel Since "Perform" can be any kind of performance, a bard could be a musician, dancer, orator, etc. Musical instruments are only relevant because bards can use them as spellcasting foci.
 
3:55 PM
@MageintheBarrel what do you mean?
 
@MageintheBarrel Do you want a character that does bard things or a Bard that does character things?
 
bard archetypes aren't based on any specific kinds of performance
 
i'm trying to make a bard that sings and dances for her performance and (possibly spellcasting) how would i build that
 
Castanets?
 
but you could check out the College of Glamour bard from Xanathar's, it literally has an ability that makes people idolise you
by "singing, reciting a poem, or dancing"
 
3:58 PM
@Yuuki I have no idea what that is
 
Note that when bards use instruments as spellcasting foci, they aren't (necessarily) playing the instrument. They can just hold or wear the instrument, and it works for the magic.
 
Castanets, also known as clackers or palillos, are a percussion instrument (idiophone), used in Spanish, Kalo, Moorish, Ottoman, Italian, Sephardic, Swiss, and Portuguese music. In ancient Greece and ancient Rome there was a similar instrument called crotalum. The instrument consists of a pair of concave shells joined on one edge by a string. They are held in the hand and used to produce clicks for rhythmic accents or a ripping or rattling sound consisting of a rapid series of clicks. They are traditionally made of hardwood (chestnut; Spanish: castaño), although fibreglass is becoming increasingly...
They're handheld percussion instruments typically used while dancing.
 
@Yuuki Maybe tap shoes would count as percussion instruments
 
@MikeQ Bardic lore is literally placebo magic.
 

« first day (3210 days earlier)      last day (1746 days later) »