« first day (3303 days earlier)      last day (1338 days later) » 

12:24 AM
0
Q: What is the radical feminist take on Harry Potter?

DukeZhouRowling recently came out as a radical feminist, but the book series she is famous for seems to have some problems from that perspective. For instance, the main character is a male, anointed as the chosen one. (He even bears a stigmata, a tiny scar, but nothing extreme like Sparrowhawk's horrific...

 
 
1 hour later…
1:41 AM
@Bookworm Whoa no way. I was just mouthing off about this today!
Though I am not sure I agree with the premise
 
 
1 hour later…
2:54 AM
0
Q: Why do Albanians "take life whenever they get the opportunity"?

TomDot ComIn Reginald on Tariffs, Saki writes: [Reginald]: I’m not going to discuss the Fiscal Question (said Reginald); I wish to be original. At the same time, I think one suffers more than one realises from the system of free imports. I should like, for instance, a really prohibitive duty put upon th...

0
Q: What is the influence of Louis Quinze and Wilhelm II on furniture styling?

TomDot ComIn Reginald in Russia, Saki writes: Reginald sat in a corner of the Princess’s salon and tried to forgive the furniture, which started out with an obvious intention of being Louis Quinze, but relapsed at frequent intervals into Wilhelm II. How are mentioning the figures Louis Quinze and Wilhelm...

 
3:19 AM
0
Q: What is the Ruff of Don Tarquinio?

TomDot ComIn The Reticence of Lady Anne, Saki writes: Don Tarquinio lay astretch on the Persian rug, basking in the firelight with superb indifference to the possible ill-humour of Lady Anne. His pedigree was as flawlessly Persian as the rug, and his ruff was coming into the glory of its second winter. T...

 
3:44 AM
0
Q: What is the hidden meaning of "Bad News" known to Egbert and Lady Anne?

TomDot ComIn The Reticence of Lady Anne, Saki writes: Both Egbert and Lady Anne would have preferred something from The Yeomen of the Guard, which was their favourite opera. In matters artistic they had a similarity of taste. They leaned towards the honest and explicit in art, a picture, for instance, tha...

0
Q: What is the significance of a raised black flag?

TomDot ComIn The Lost Sanjak, Saki Writes: ! and, in the midst of a string of questions on indifferent topics, the examining counsel asked me with a diabolical suddenness if I could tell the Court the whereabouts of Novibazar. I felt the question to be a crucial one; something told me that the answer was ...

 
4:09 AM
0
Q: Why does Groholsky head toward the water barrel?

TomDot ComIn A Living Chattel, Anton Chekhov writes: [Impersonal Witness] I pressed Groholsky's hand, and got into the train. He bowed towards the carriage, and went to the water-barrel—I suppose he was thirsty! What is implied when Groholsky is seen heading toward the water barrel? That he is intending ...

 
4:34 AM
0
Q: Why is the Lady "a suffering soul in some page of Dostoyevsky"?

TomDot ComIn An Enigmatic Nature, Anton Chekhov writes: "I am a suffering soul in some page of Dostoevsky. Reveal my soul to the world, Voldemar." and "Happiness comes tapping at my window, I had only to let it in - but -" And later concludes the story with the following passage: "But what—what stands...

 
5:25 AM
0
Q: How old was Murasaki Shikibu when she married her second cousin? And why did she marry him?

Eddie KalFrom Wikipedia: Aristocratic Heian women lived restricted and secluded lives, allowed to speak to men only when they were close relatives or household members. Murasaki's autobiographical poetry shows that she socialized with women but had limited contact with men other than her father and broth...

0
Q: Who was Murasaki Shikibu's first love? And what was the skinny?

Eddie KalA line from Donald Keene's introductory text about The Tale of Genji piqued my curiosity: We know little else about Murasaki’s early years, though her poems suggest that she fell in love at least once. Keene goes on to talk about Murasaki Shikibu's marriage. It is clear that Murasaki Shikibu di...

 
 
2 hours later…
7:18 AM
How to Read a Poem: free online course on FutureLearn. It runs for 4 weeks and started last week but you can still join this week.
 
8:21 AM
@Bookworm HNQ. Which explains the upvotes by Swedish royals disguised as Stack Exchange users.
 
9:10 AM
@Randal'Thor If that question about Maugham is off topic, in spite of the relevance to his novel Of Human Bondage, shouldn't we also close Was Shakespeare a member of the lower classes? as off topic?
 
Apparently people deleted it already anyway.
 
@NapoleonWilson People deleted what exactly?
 
The question in question.
 
I know.
 
9:41 AM
0
Q: Guidelines for migration from Science Fiction & Fantasy

TheLethalCarrotI'm putting together an effort on Science Fiction & Fantasy to give users guidance for when they should migrate1 a question from SFF to a different site on the network. Literature has a decent amount of overlap with SFF which means there is potential for a lot of migration of off topic content on...

 
10:13 AM
@Librarian Do we need to discuss anything beyond what we have in the Help Centre?
 
10:45 AM
We haven't used the Twitter control room since March. Do we have anything worth tweeting?
Dr. Dara Downey on Twitter: "I went to a Derrida conference once and it degenerated into a shouting match. Then we all fed cake to ducks. It was very confusing. I think he would have liked it."
 
0
Q: Where did Derrida say that Jonathon Culler's On Deconstruction is a good introduction to his work?

TsundokuThe works of the French philosopher Jacques Derrida (1930 – 2004) had a significant impact on literary theory, leading to the development of a method of analysis known as deconstruction. (Derrida said deconstruction in his own writings did not refer to a method, but that is a different minefield....

 
11:03 AM
@Tsundoku does it even still work
 
@Mithical Oh, is there any reason why it wouldn't work any longer?
 
I just have no idea if the program set up to monitor the starred posts is still running.
I'm not even sure who set it up. Either Shokhet or Hamlet, I think.
 
Hmm, we'll need to identify a really good question to test that with.
Or just point to our ongoing reading challenges.
 
12:03 PM
That's a very thoroughly researched answer by a new user.
So now I have a proposed tween tweet in the Twitter Control Room.
 
Are tweens old enough to propose?
 
Are there cultures that reserve reasonable responsibilities for 30 or older?
 
The Representation of the People Act 1918 (UK) allowed some women over 30 to vote.
 
(Other than hobbits and a general lack of universal rights.)
 
12:20 PM
There is an EpicShahnameh account on Twitter.
@Mithical Three Very Short Introductions to Literary Criticism recommends Culler's Literary Theory: A Very Short Introduction, Eaglestone's Contemporary Fiction: A Very Short Introduction and Hutchinson's Comparative Literature: A Very Short Introduction.
 
12:56 PM
0
Q: What does "Hoo's fully resolved t' sew up meawth an' eend" mean in this context?

Pasta AddictI would like to know what "Hoo's fully resolved t' sew up meawth an' eend" means in the following stanzas: VII. Eawr Marget declares had hoo cloo'as to put on, Hoo'd goo up to Lunnon an' talk to th' greet mon; An' if things were na awtered when there hoo had been, Hoo's fully resolved t' sew up ...

 
1:21 PM
0
Q: Looking for a short story about an executioner

abbeI remember reading this English (could be a translation) short story ~20 years ago in my school, where an executioner who executed convicts on an electric chair, never cared (or looked into) the convicts, comes across the fact the next convict is a young man of a cheerful nature (I don't remember...

 
2:16 PM
@Tsundoku Oh they are not? My bad. I almost got a sense of "anything goes"
Please help me move them to History SE then.
 
Even on Literature SE there are limits :-/
So you want me to migrate both questions to History SE?
 
And yet it has approximately zero close-votes.
 
Yes please, if History SE is the right destination
Hmmm, in that case the number of posts I contributed yesterday has just become zero. I have to post two today then,
 
It looks like they would be on topic under History SE's literature tag.
 
Sweet. Thank you
 
2:21 PM
@EddieKal If you are aiming for a Socratic badge, I recommend posting at most one question per day.
That's what Rand and I do.
 
@Tsundoku I will try. I just want to keep myself active here. So I made a pledge to myself here the other day that I'd ask a question or write an answer every day.
 
@NapoleonWilson I know. Perhaps very few people reviewed it. Or they are unaware of meta posts about questions about authors.
 
Hope Lit SE will be out of Beta soon
 
We haven't been in beta for seven years yet (which I think was the criterion for the last big batch of graduations).
 
And that was supposed to be a one-off event in any case.
 
2:24 PM
I will have to think of some other questions on Genji today. Kind of slow. Still on the third chapter.
 
I'm still waiting for my copy of Genji to arrive. I ordered it two months ago. Apparently, they're reprinting it.
 
@Tsundoku Washburn?
 
@EddieKal No, Royall Tyler's translation. That's the one I chose after reading what I found on Wikipedia about existing English translations.
There is a German translation at the local library but somebody else borrowed it.
 
I'm a little confused, were Gods immoral or immortal?
Gods mean Zeus, Poseidon etc.
 
@Knight In their case, I'd say both
 
2:30 PM
I second that.
 
In Greek Mythology they are always portrayed as immoral?
 
In the Iliad and the Odyssey, humans derive no morality from their religion. They just need to make regular sacrifices to placate the gods. In view of how those gods behaved, it is difficult to see what sort of morality they could provide.
 
okay.
 
It was pretty much the same in ancient Mesopotamia.
 
Was Leda a mortal or a lesser deity than Zeus and all?
 
2:35 PM
According to Wikipedia she was a mere mortal and one of the many women that Zeus abused.
 
Oh god, I was in Zeus house in my school.
 
@Tsundoku What is this twitter control room?
@Tsundoku Shades of ELU with the specter of OED. I was the first upvoter.
 
@EddieKal That's a chat room from which we used to send Twitter messages. But apparently that no longer works, either due to changes on the SE end or the Twitter API (or both, since you never know).
 
I see.
 
or dlvr.it
 
2:47 PM
@Mithical Did it rely on code on dlvr.it? If so, I have no idea whose account is associated with the Twitter control room.
 
Yep; you can see on Tweets posted via the control room (this, for instance)
 
I had never noticed "dlvr.it" below those tweets. I have just noticed there's a three-hour delay for tweets sent through a free dlvr.it account, so we need to wait a big longer to find out whether that mechanism still works.
 
0
Q: Book about people cut off from rest of the world that don't kill animals

Caleb MauerI read this book in elementary school (less than 10 years old) so I think it was a young adult or children's book. It's about inhabitants of a valley that were cut off from the outside world. The main characters were kids in school. It was like an agrarian society of some sort, like a small villa...

 
3:10 PM
@EddieKal Hmm. There may be some hidden context - I don't remember now since it's over 2 years ago, but the Hermione-Draco thing rings vague bells in my mind about a troll repeatedly posting about that topic using throwaway accounts. That might have soured the community on the whole idea even if the underlying question can be asked in a mature and reasonable way.
In fact, looking back at it now, there's a still extant comment on that question from such a troll:
Another thing to bear in mind about SFF is that they tend to put a lot of emphasis on authorial intent. I'd say it's reasonably certain that Rowling didn't intend to suggest rape of one major character by another, and the question of whether that interpretation could potentially be made from the text alone ... is, let's say, a question more likely to fit well on Lit than SFF :-)
OTOH, as you point out re bestiality, it's reasonably clear that she did intend to suggest that in the books. And the people DVing/VTCing the Sirius question because of ick-factor might be interested to read about the character of Poledra in another fantasy series :-)
@Tsundoku I didn't say the Maugham question is off-topic. In fact, IMO the Of Human Bondage connection was enough to make it fine. Same for @EddieKal's Murasaki Shikibu questions: if she wrote "autobiographical poetry", then asking about her real life in connection with that poetry seems on-topic. As for the Shakespeare question, it might be technically not about the author's works, but it relates to anti-Stratfordian theories which are surely of literary interest.
 
@Randal'Thor That's like the literal dumbest ship in the entire book
 
Ship or shit?
 
@NapoleonWilson Both
I don't understand what troll made that up
 
I only remember the big ship that the Romanians arrive in.
 
@NapoleonWilson Lol
 
3:24 PM
(I wonder if we might consider codifying "of literary interest" somehow, to include questions which aren't directly about literature itself but certainly fall within our site's ballpark of expertise. Similar to SFF's "fandom information" which allows the site to permit a lot of questions that aren't technically about scifi/fantasy works but are the kind of thing scifi/fantasy fans would know.)
 
@Randal'Thor What kind of "literary interest" would be considered that?
 
@NorthLæraðr Seems like you haven't seen much HP fanfic ;-)
Jan 22 '17 at 23:25, by DVK-in-Florida
@b_jonas I was once informed about a fanfic shipping a great squid and Dumbledore's chair. At that point, I realized people just treat HP fanfic as a homework in combinatorics.
@NapoleonWilson Scandinavians? Slavs? I don't remember any Romanians.
 
@Randal'Thor I tend to avoid fanfics in general, because I think they're stupid
 
Maybe you don't want to go as far as "did Tolkien have a driving license" or "What school subject does JKR fail at", though.
 
@Randal'Thor Viktor Krum?
Idk if he's Romanian
 
3:26 PM
@NorthLæraðr That was a follow-up to my previous message. E.g. this question which Tsundoku linked.
@NorthLæraðr Bulgarian.
 
@Randal'Thor I'm extremely sure Victor Krum wasn't a Norwegian.
 
@NapoleonWilson Durmstrang is in Scandinavia though.
 
Look at these NERDS debating HP lore
 
@Randal'Thor Well, the other Romania then.
 
3:27 PM
Jkjk
@Randal'Thor I see
 
@NapoleonWilson Oh sure. I think both of those got closed in the end even over there (albeit after some close-reopen wars).
 
The heck
 
@NapoleonWilson Romania isn't even a Slavic country.
I think all the Durmstrangers we know by name (although only Karkaroff and Krum are coming to mind at the moment) are Slavs. The Scandinavia thing is, as you say, odd. But canon, so whatchagonnado.
 
@Randal'Thor If you tell me JKR wrote him as a genuine member of Bulgarian culture, rather than a "cliché Russian", fine.
 
3:29 PM
"Did Tolkien have a driver's license" (smh)
 
He was on the Bulgarian national Quidditch team, so I'm assuming he was Bulgarian.
 
Why would someone even care about that?
 
@NorthLæraðr For the best reason to ask a question on SE: to make a point! What else? ;-)
 
@NapoleonWilson GeezLouize
 
@NorthLæraðr Link. And yes, as Napoleon says, it was posted in an attempt to make a point, in response to What is JK Rowling bad at?
 
3:31 PM
-8
Q: Was Tolkien a driver?

ValorumJ.R.R Tolkien is renowned (and occasionally mocked) for his Lord of the Ring novels in which his characters spend a very considerable time walking (and occasionally flying and riding horses) but never do we see them in a carriage, horseless or otherwise. In real life, did Tolkien drive an automo...

Ah, ninja'd.
 
@Mithical What the frick
 
Speaking of Durmstrang's location, I wonder if asking about textual rather than extratextual evidence (i.e. discounting random JKR interview quotes) would make a good Lit question, a sort of sequel to this.
 
@Mithical It still works, but apparently the feed posting into this room doesn't.
 
If the word wasn't remotely Scandinavian, I would have said Rowling simply failed at what Scandinavia is. But the remotely Germanic name suggests some degree of conciousness.
 
3:37 PM
Oh, good point; I hadn't thought of that.
@Tsundoku How about promoting that post on Twitter too? An apposite hashtag or two and we might pick up some people for our unanswered questions. (I won't post it in the Twitter Control Room since it's my question, hence just suggesting. By the way, I unfroze that room so that not only mods can post there.)
 
@Randal'Thor OK, I'll do that.
 
"Oh hey, a notification on the StackLiterature account!" "...oh, it's just @Tsundoku. And me."
 
@Mithical Lol
 
@Randal'Thor We might even get a response from Walt & Whitman Brewing :-P
 
3:48 PM
Funny, I hadn't see that one yet.
 
@Randal'Thor Lol I will let my questions tour History SE and if they are not lucky enough to get good answers I will probably request that they be moved back here. I shall name it "Murasaki's love life on a tour"
 
@EddieKal Apologies for migrating your questions too quickly.
 
@Tsundoku No no no that was my request
I should've read the meta discussion which, I wish to add, I did fish out and read later
 
0
Q: What does “An' hoo says hoo can tell when hoo's hurt” mean in this context?

Pasta AddictI would like to know what "An' hoo says hoo can tell when hoo's hurt" means in the following stanzas: VII. Eawr Marget declares had hoo cloo'as to put on, Hoo'd goo up to Lunnon an' talk to th' greet mon; An' if things were na awtered when there hoo had been, Hoo's fully resolved t' sew up meawt...

 
@Bookworm I thought I had a déjà vu but it is a different question containing "hoo".
 
4:00 PM
Urm @Tsundoku do we need a tag?
also who's sniping all these new tags (eyes suspiciously)
 
@NorthLæraðr Maybe not. But I haven't done anything about it yet. We still have other tags for broad themes and I don't think we've decided to remove them.
@NorthLæraðr Don't look at me. :-P
 
How pathetic was it that Daphne had to convert into a tree to escape from rape!
 
@Knight Pathetic???
How dare you!
You're pathetic
 
@Knight You underestimate trees ;-)
 
(dares to insult a tree grumble grumble)
 
4:02 PM
whoa passions run high
 
Hmm...
 
Fangorn will be coming for you!
 
tree s cannot move
humans can move
 
@Knight Bet
 
Don't step foot in Taurnalome...
 
4:03 PM
I'm a tree
 
Oh
Sorry North
 
@Knight Oh, you haven't see the last march of the Ents.
 
I just realized how badly photoshopped that looked
 
I really want to discuss the seriosity (if that's the right word) of Daphne's escape from rape and what Myths and Apollo called love.
It's today that I got to know that Apollo didn't want to love Daphne
 
4:05 PM
*Tauremornalómë, accidentally left out a few letters
 
He longed for her body.
 
I don't think anybody came out of that story looking particularly good.
 
I didn't get "looking particularly good" part of your sentence.
 
As in, that story doesn't portray any of the people involved (Apollo, Eros) in a positive way.
 
@Knight This is actually a valid research topic. I would lose the word "pathetic" though
 
4:11 PM
@Mithical Can you please describe that story to me? Or can you guide me where I can read what actually happened?
@EddieKal Again gender is not same as biology?
 
@Knight Forget biology for a moment. Biology is the least important factor in determining your role in society
 
okay
 
@Knight Apollo fought with Eros (god of love); Eros cursed Apollo to fall in love with Daphne and cursed Daphne to never fall in love with Apollo; Apollo chased Daphne and she turned into a tree to escape him.
 
@Mithical Did Eros had to say something after Daphne got converted into a tree? Was he sorry?
 
0
Q: Is there any connection between the reticence of Lady Anne and the cat-bird subplot?

Rand al'ThorWhile answering another question, I read Saki's short story The Reticence of Lady Anne" from his Reginald in Russia collection. Inasmuch as a story this short can be said to have "plotlines", there are two parts of this story (spoiler alert!): The main plot is Egbert trying to resolve an argumen...

 
4:41 PM
0
Q: What does Wednesday mean by "the flowers in your hair are optional"?

MithicalWhen Shadow is trying to tell Wednesday about his dream with the thunderbirds, Wednesday gets quite angry and then says they're heading to San Francisco: "I dreamed of thunderbirds...," said Shadow. "And a tower. Skulls..." It seemed to him very important to recount his dream. "I know what you w...

 
@Knight Till Birnam forest come to Dunsinane
3
 
4:59 PM
I found the Washburn Genji and Seidensticker Genji, but not the Tyler Genji. Anyone know where I can get my hands on it online?
 
5:36 PM
Wow, 6.1.
Lotta questions today.
 
 
2 hours later…
7:43 PM
@Randal'Thor Was it perhaps due to TomDot Com's massive number of questions?
 
 
2 hours later…
9:29 PM
@NorthLæraðr That definitely helped push up the average QPD.
 

« first day (3303 days earlier)      last day (1338 days later) »