How was this no caught as OFF TOPIC, I don't understand. Can;t flag as such now that it's got a bounty. — Danny Schoemannyesterday
^ This seems to be correct: the question is about Jews and not Judaism. In addition, the question seems to be asking us to read into the mind of a particular speaker, without even saying who the speaker is, which is unanswerable without reference to the (correct revision of) the WP article, and thus should be closed for that reason also. Thoughts?
^ cc @IsaacMoses @DoubleAA @Daniel who are listed as present in the room or posted here very recently
@IsaacMoses Fair enough. And to my second objection?
(But I suppose my second objection can be obviated by anyone's editing (into the MY post) the info from the WP article revision as of the time of MY posting.)
@msh210 "I've heard Jews classifying their own Jewishness with this English term. What does it mean?" assumes that there is a shared meaning. That might be incorrect, but it's not obviously so a priori. The WP reference weakens the case here a little bit, since the WP article puts quotation marks around the term, indicating that it could be the subject's invention, but it wouldn't be hard to find examples of it being used un-self-consciously.
@msh210 That one's stronger, since, on the contrary, it's pretty obvious a priori that "Modern Orthodox" is meant to refer to a kind of Judaism, per se.