« first day (1050 days earlier)      last day (3649 days later) » 

8:32 AM
早口言葉で「はしゅつしょ」って難しいんですけど
「派出所」
めっちゃむずい
@snailboat 「疲れた」ですって!は、「疲れた」だと!?とか「疲れた」だって!と同じ使い方ですよね
 
ssb
刃恤
why are there so few kanji that can be read しゅつ・・・
 
それ、読めないです
刃 やいば、とかかな
恤 けつ、かなとおもう
「派出所の手術室」
はしゅつしょのしゅじゅつしつ
「派出所に手術室出現」
はしゅつしょにしゅじゅつしつしゅつげん
 
9:08 AM
@Earthliŋ See here: search.yahoo.co.jp/…
68 million results. What do you call it if not "such a common expression"??
You fight or do betting for the right to do something. Is that such an uncommon phrase in your language??4
I don't care if you think you know more Japanese than I do, but you will never be able to prove it.
 
@TokyoNagoya I didn't get that from any of his posts... what are you going on about?
 
 
1 hour later…
10:31 AM
@TokyoNagoya Sorry, I just searched for 権利をかけ, 権利を懸け, 権利を掛け, 権利を賭け in BCCWJ (Japanese corpus), the only search, where I know I can trust the number of results. But all these give 0 results, so there was no obvious choice for me. I guess 懸ける would be the kanji of choice, although you seem to suggest to write this in kana.
@TokyoNagoya I'm not aware of an expression like "betting on/for the right to do something" in English or in German.
 
10:44 AM
@TokyoNagoya I actually don't think I know more Japanese than you. I've been learning Japanese for about 4 1/2 years (the first 3 of which I spent living in Japan) and am trying to learn more, but I think it would be quite easy to prove that you know much more Japanese than I do (about any part of Japanese). Most of your answers already contain information/observations I would never have guessed at...
 
10:59 AM
Does anyone know a website with up to date and short 常用漢字表 (just kanji, no readings or meaning) that I could print on a few pages? All I can find is too long.
 
@Szymon All 常用漢字 on a few pages in a random order? Why not just copy and paste into your favourite text editor?
 
I thought maybe someone had a link... That' ok, thanks.
 
 
2 hours later…
12:59 PM
@Szymon Sorry, I only have a text file with all 教育漢字
 
1:17 PM
That's ok. I took your advice and produced what I needed quite quickly :)
So thank you, @Earthliŋ!
 
1:36 PM
@virmaior 「してくれて、ありがとう(ございます)」 or 「していただいて、ありがとうございます」 or 「してくださって、ありがとうございます」, but not x「してもらって、ありがとう(ございます)」.
@snailboat I think 行く行かないを決めます is fine, but has a different nuance from the 行くか行かないか version. Like 「行く行かない」 feels like a single noun in the first one ("goingness"? lol), while the second one feels more like "whether we are going or not". So the former is a little more terse, in my possibly incorrect opinion.
 
 
2 hours later…
Anonymous
3:39 PM
Google only has 17 results for "権利をかける", it seems, if you click through to the second page of results
 
@snailboat But it says 68,600,000
about ;)
 
Anonymous
Yahoo! returns 16 results
 
Well, now we know: Don't trust Google counts, nor Yahoo counts
 
Anonymous
Hehe, yeah :-)
 
Anonymous
I'm not sure which engine Yahoo! Japan uses at the moment
 
Anonymous
3:45 PM
Ah, Yahoo! Japan uses Google now
 
Anonymous
That explains it
 
@TokyoNagoya It appears that Yahoo says "68,300,000 results", but in fact only finds 16. It might still be a common expression, because it is used in more complex sentences and not in the form "権利をかける".
@snailboat I guess a slightly outdated cache of Google results?
 
Anonymous
@Earthliŋ What makes you guess that?
 
Anonymous
I'm not sure how they get the results from Google.
 
3:48 PM
Google told me "68,800,000", Yahoo had "68,300,000"
And actual results 17 vs. 16
 
Anonymous
But there may be another explanation
 
Anonymous
There isn't enough information to guess that it's outdated or cached
 
OK, you're the programming whizz =)
 
Anonymous
It's a possible explanation, though
 
Anonymous
Hehe.
 
Anonymous
3:50 PM
Well, I haven't worked there for a few years now
 
Anonymous
So I don't know what they do anymore
 
Yahoo?
 
Anonymous
Yeah
 
I see
 
Anonymous
You can tell, because I'm one of the only people on the planet who bothers typing the exclamation point
 
3:51 PM
I actually considered typing it, but consciously decided against it =)
 
Anonymous
Hah
 
Anonymous
Yahoo! Japan is actually a separate company from Yahoo!
 
Anonymous
Unlike Google Japan, which is just Google
 
I was this close to typing it |-><-|
 
Anonymous
It was the first intl that Yahoo! set up. They made sure to own a controlling interest in all of the others where possible (I think China is a special case due to laws about Chinese companies being owned by foreign companies)
 
Anonymous
3:52 PM
But Yahoo! Japan is special! :-)
 
Anonymous
Also, happily, Yahoo! Japan is one of the few places where Yahoo! Auctions took off (it bombed almost everywhere else, though it did okay in a couple other intls like Singapore)
 
Anonymous
So I was part of the team that worked on that :-)
 
Why is there no Ebay in Japan?
 
Anonymous
Because Yahoo! Auctions got there first
 
Anonymous
Same reason there's no Yahoo! Auctions in the US
 
3:53 PM
I see...
 
Anonymous
Because eBay got there first
 
Anonymous
It's easy to corner that sort of market with a network effect
 
Did you work for Ebay, too? ;)
 
Anonymous
No, but I used to live with someone who did
 
Whence eBay, not Ebay...
 
Anonymous
3:54 PM
Haha.
 
I've got to go, see you!
 
Anonymous
See you later!
 
Anonymous
4:31 PM
is gone!
 
Anonymous
5:12 PM
@TokyoNagoya We were just making guesses because we didn't know. I don't think anyone is trying to say they know more Japanese than you
 
Anonymous
I'm just learning, and part of the process of learning is discussing the language :-)
 
Anonymous
7:40 PM
I searched for シュツ in KANJIDIC and then sorted them by frequency order using my composite list:
4 出
652 率
1062 卒
4733 恤
4805 蟀
5003 朮
5201 齣
6491 卆
 
Anonymous
Only the top three kanji make the cut in the ACA's list (which is mostly limited to the most frequent 3500 kanji)
 
Anonymous
And of those three, the second and third are almost always read with readings other than シュツ...
 
Anonymous
出 is the only one on the 常用漢字表 with シュツ listed
 
Anonymous
None of the remaining five have any words listed in EDICT with the シュツ reading. I don't see your 刃恤 word anywhere... What is it?
 
Anonymous
So it seems like practically speaking, 出 is the only kanji read シュツ, with very rare exceptions
 
Anonymous
7:45 PM
Hmm...
 
Anonymous
初 is also read chū in Mandarin, but that's ショ in Japanese
 
Anonymous
Baxter-Sagart's Middle Chinese transcriptions and Old Chinese reconstructions indicate that 初 had a different vowel back then
 
Anonymous
That's all I've got :-)
 
Anonymous
I don't really know why there aren't more kanji read シュツ
 
@snailboat What your "composite list"?
 
Anonymous
8:22 PM
@Earthliŋ There are lots of frequency lists. My first resort is to check this list‌​, but it only covers 3500 kanji
 
Anonymous
Some of the other lists have maybe less reliable data, but they cover more kanji
 
Anonymous
Or they just collected it in different ways
 
Anonymous
So I made a composite list to try to improve the coverage
 
Anonymous
It's not put together in a rigorous fashion or anything :-)
 
Anonymous
But if you want to use it for some reason, it's here: quarplet.com/composite.txt
 
8:41 PM
I was trying to search BCCWJ for frequency for my database, but it's quite tedious... I didn't find an automated way to search for a particular character
But I'm interested in frequency, not just "order by frequency"
@snailboat Thanks.
I figured I want a weighted list, not just by frequency, but also by frequency of characters containing the same phonetic component and by conceptual simplicity of the character (象形, 会意, ...)
Do you know of a list, which lists frequency?
 
 
1 hour later…
Anonymous
9:55 PM
@Earthliŋ I don't know of a list with those characteristics, but with certain caveats on the sources used for the data, you could assemble it yourself
 
Anonymous
@Earthliŋ The Wikipedia list has raw frequency: shang.kapsi.fi/kanji
 
10:11 PM
@snailboat Caveats being?
 
Anonymous
Well, Wikipedia isn't exactly a balanced corpus
 
Ah, ok. I thought there was a caveat for BCCWJ.
I'm two-thirds there with BCCWJ... It's taken me a few hours so far.
I don't want to rely on Wikipedia.
 
Anonymous
10:29 PM
Oh, nice! Did you set up a script to do it?
 
Anonymous
Did you notice you can use some RE syntax on BCCWJ?
 
Anonymous
You can search for 権利を, and then in the 後文脈 field type ^.け
 
Anonymous
Then you get all the results where the following context begins with any character and then け
 
Anonymous
And then you can click the 後文脈 header to sort by it
 
Oh, please tell me more.
@snailboat I couldn't figure out how to do it with a script.
My interface has a link to check for variant characters, but I couldn't even figure out how to link to the search results...
 
Anonymous
10:37 PM
@Earthliŋ To make the extra fields appear, click the こちら link
 
So, at the moment, I'm doing it by hand...
I'm no programmer, yet :(
Do you know how to link to the results for "未", e.g. ?
I would guess something like www.domain.com/search?q=未, but that's not how it looks...
 
Anonymous
It should work if you have a recent session cookie
 
Anonymous
Otherwise you'll probably get booted back to the intro page
 
Great thank you. How did you find this?
 
Anonymous
10:48 PM
1. Install LiveHttpHeaders
 
Anonymous
2. Perform a query
 
Anonymous
3. Look in the LiveHttpHeaders header output for the POSTed content. It'll be under a content-length line.
 
Oh, that sounds like a useful tip.
 
Anonymous
Because the form data isn't being put directly into the URL (via GET), it's natural to conclude that it's being submitted via POST
 
I see...
 
Anonymous
10:49 PM
Although you could verify this rather than inferring it by looking at the page source, or by looking through the DOM etc.
 
Anonymous
It looks like this for me: query_string=%E5%B0%86&lcontext_regex=&rcontext_regex=&media=%E6%9B%B8%E7%B1%8D&‌​media=%E9%9B%91%E8%AA%8C&media=%E6%96%B0%E8%81%9E&media=%E7%99%BD%E6%9B%B8&media=‌​%E6%95%99%E7%A7%91%E6%9B%B8&media=%E5%BA%83%E5%A0%B1%E7%B4%99&media=Yahoo%21%E7%9‌​F%A5%E6%81%B5%E8%A2%8B&media=Yahoo%21%E3%83%96%E3%83%AD%E3%82%B0&media=%E9%9F%BB%‌​E6%96%87&media=%E6%B3%95%E5%BE%8B&media=%E5%9B%BD%E4%BC%9A%E4%BC%9A%E8%AD%B0%E9%8‌​C%B2&entire_period=1
 
Anonymous
That's URI-escaped, of course. That's fine. I removed %E5%B0%86 (which was 将, the character I searched for) and replaced it with a URI-escaped version of 未
 
Anonymous
Then I changed that to GET by appending it to the URL after ?
 
Anonymous
It turns out, the server accepts the query via both GET and POST. (This is not a given. In this case it worked, but in another case this might not.)
 
Anonymous
This gave me the basic prototype URL. The first three fields are what you'd expect, query string and left and right REs for matching context. The remainder of the arguments specify which subcorpora to query--you can't leave these out. I didn't test whether entire_period was required or not, but it presumably does what it says
 
Anonymous
10:51 PM
(I haven't tried restricting queries in BCCWJ to specific years)
 
Anonymous
So, you could do this same thing yourself. But you'll notice that it's stateful--it only works with the session cookie it creates when you agree to the terms.
 
Fantastic, thank you.
My cookie session seems to last for quite a while
What do you do when the server isn't set up to accept GET queries?
(Just out of interest)
 
Anonymous
Well, then you can't give someone a link directly to it, because you can't put the data in the URL. But you can still grab the data yourself with whatever tool you want.
 
Anonymous
Like, curl for example.
 
I see...
Well, this works for now.
 
Anonymous
10:56 PM
If you were going to write a script to query for each kanji in a list, you could still do it if it required POST.
 
What should I look up to write such a script?
 
Anonymous
There are any number of tools. You could put a script together in perl or python, and you could use either a library (use libcurl from perl via WWW:Curl or python via pycurl) or just call out to an appropriate command-line tool (curl, wget, etc.)
 
and write the results to a database...?
What would you recommend to learn first: perl or python? (I have heard good things about python)
 
Anonymous
Sure. You can access MySQL (is that what you're using?) via perl's DBD::mysql or via python's MySQLdb
 
Anonymous
I've been using perl for most of my life so it's second-nature to me, but I think I'd recommend you start with python if you're starting from zero
 
Anonymous
11:02 PM
I tend to write small one-off scripts in perl still
 
Great, thank you.
That's a lot of homework for me now =)
 
Anonymous
Remember that if you automate access to someone's webserver that you're a guest. Don't hammer it--put in a generous delay between requests, like what you'd do as a human
 
Sure, I thought about that already.
I've seen "no systematic queries" in various places
I wouldn't mind it running for days or weeks, as long as it'd do all the work for me...
 
Anonymous
Yay
 
But it'll take me a fair amount of time before I learn how to do it...
(I'm a busy man) =)
 
Anonymous
11:07 PM
Hehe!
 
Although I've been spending a lot of time here lately...
 
Anonymous
You can do it!
 
Well, I can't complain
about not having time, I guess
Eventually =)
Thanks for all the help (and encouragement)
 

« first day (1050 days earlier)      last day (3649 days later) »