« first day (1485 days earlier)      last day (3440 days later) » 
00:00 - 22:0022:00 - 00:00

cfr
12:03 AM
@HarishKumar I missed the interview. Sounds surprisingly civilised. What does <3 mean? There is less gentleness on your side than in 3 PauloCeredas?
 
cfr
12:14 AM
To anybody: what should I do in the following situation? OP posts question A. Various answers. OP edits question A with follow-up which is not really a follow-up (suddenly solution needs to work with custom macro not previously mentioned). I post an answer to this follow-up which I found while answering questions B and C by the OP. I now find that the non-follow-up is also posted as question D. By now, my answer to question A has been up-voted and, also, it now answers the much-edited...
 
@cfr it's the heart ;) and you can still ask questions, usually the interview is "closed" only after a week or so
 
cfr
version of question A. @tohecz AHA! Thank you! Calon lân...
 
@cfr call the OP to come over and give him a spanking? :) There's always the (probably correct) possibility to dupe the questions of one user. I think it's the best way how to show them that this behaviour is not proper.
 
cfr
But if I post the same answer to question D it will be even more of a mess... @tohecz I'm just frustrated. The OP keeps changing the question and keeps posting more questions and...
 
Let's be specific, is it this guy? tex.stackexchange.com/users/18561/stefan-m%C3%BCller
 
12:18 AM
@cfr Rotate <3 by 90 degrees and what symbol it is? ;)
 
cfr
@HarishKumar Calon! (See @tohecz's enlightening comment above.) But thanks to you too.
@tohecz Yes. Specifically him.
 
@cfr Oh! Saw it just now. Thanks to @tohecz :-)
 
@cfr it's a messsss
 
cfr
'Calon lân...' is a cultural reference (song).
@tohecz Yes. I think so, too. And I'm partly responsible for it but I didn't quite realise all the mess...
 
@cfr I don't think you're responsible for someone else not being able to ask a question, unless you're their parent of primary school teacher :)
 
cfr
12:22 AM
@tohecz Not that I know of, no. What I mean is, answering bits of one in one place when there are more bits in other places...
Is there... an, er... site policy covering this kind of situation? (I'm assuming your earlier suggestion is not actually official policy.)
 
@cfr It happens when people don't know exactly what they need or reluctant to think/read/put some more effort from their side etc and seek every answer from somewhere assuming that others have crystal ball. :) Don't get frustrated. Just leave it at that. That is what I would do :)
And don't think that you are responsible for the mess. How do you know what the OP wants unless they say so :)
 
cfr
@HarishKumar But what should be done with tex.stackexchange.com/questions/207259/…? Should that be marked as a duplicate, as @tohecz suggested?
 
@cfr I'll make a CW answer to that one.
 
cfr
@tohecz Excellent! If you want my code, it is at tex.stackexchange.com/a/213604.
@HarishKumar, @tohecz Thank you both.
 
@cfr no, I'm not going to care too much. I'll solve the MWE he provides, and I'll leave a comment.
 
cfr
12:29 AM
@tohecz Sounds good.
 
@cfr I am not sure of it since it is about replacing the text with a command as the input, where exapnsions matter. It is a pandora's box which I wouldn't dare to open. Already wipet has commented on that question. I hope that clarifies things a bit.
Whoa, @egreg isn't sleeping yet or he left his computer on and connected and slept :-)
@egreg missed this one?
1
Q: How to create a newcommand with 2 different meanings for math mode and text mode?

kornarosI use the \usepackage{newunicodechar} to enter easily some unicode characters in math mode. For example I used unicode curled phi ( ϕ ) to insert phi in math mode. The problem is that any Unicode word in text mode starting with this phi is changed to math mode! So my question is: How could I u...

 
cfr
12:56 AM
@HarishKumar It seems to be a duplicate of the edited version of the question here.
 
@HarishKumar probably it's too hard for him
@cfr bang head on desk, and move on to next question:-)
 
cfr
@DavidCarlisle Trouble is, the next question keeps turning out to be the same code from the same OP ;).
I don't like the forest being left untidy...
 
@cfr it's possible to ignore that Op and answer something else:-)
@cfr forest fires can have a cleansing effect
good night all
 
1:24 AM
@DavidCarlisle Good night.
 
 
6 hours later…
7:18 AM
@JosephWright @ChristianHupfer Seems like they found 3 guys for the CTAN team.
@ChristianHupfer The two line chapter title question is bugging me.
 
 
1 hour later…
8:23 AM
@HarishKumar I left the easy ones to @DavidCarlisle
 
@egreg I noticed ;)
 
Do we have any hebrew LaTeX guys around? I think there has to be something done concerning hebrew.sty (of babel).
 
@HarishKumar Thanks, Harish. :) But I think this is a collaborative effort. We all work hard to make this place friendly. ;)
 
@Johannes_B In what way?
 
0
Q: How to use hebrew in latex - font or installation errors

sethI am trying to get latex working with hebrew and english using ubuntu 14.04 and TeX Live 2013/Debian. The following fails to run due to: ! I can't find file `jerus10'. The input file is: \documentclass{article} \usepackage[hebrew]{babel} \begin{document} hello or שלום \L{World}! \end{docu...

@JosephWright The fonts that the user has to install by hand.
Or more importantly, the package insisting on the one special font.
 
8:44 AM
@Johannes_B Well this is documented (texdoc -l babel and on my system option 22), although you do need to read a bit of stuff to find it!
 
@JosephWright Exactly, not very user friendly.
 
@Johannes_B Down not to the babel core but the people who look after the hebrew support: all that can be done is ask them about it
 
@JosephWright What is the name of aforementioned option 22?
 
22 C:\texlive\2014\texmf-dist\doc\generic\babel-hebrew\hebrew.pdf
   = Package documentation
 
@JosephWright Is “option 22” similar to “catch 22”?
 
9:04 AM
@JosephWright It seems that the hebrew letters aren't mapped in utf8.def
 
@Johannes_B The Hebrew support is all older, but to be honest I would not use pdfTeX or XeTeX for new RTL material
 
@JosephWright Me too, but since pdfTeX is still in widely use ... Or simple force them (the hebrew users) to switch?
 
@Johannes_B Well that would be the position of some members of the LaTeX team but not one I'd be so keen on
 
@JosephWright From my current compilation: Package polyglossia Warning: Hebrew is not supported with LuaTeX.
 
@Johannes_B There was a decision a while ago that individual languages in babel really have to be 'looked after' by separate 'teams': they can't all be done properly by the kernel team
@Johannes_B Also probably true: I was thinking more at a low level (i.e plain)
 
9:11 AM
@JosephWright I agree, but i guess one needs to know a language/script at least a little bit.
 
@Johannes_B I guess on the font situation the issue is likely to be that the font required has a long history of use but can't be included in a standard distribution for license reasons
 
@JosephWright Damn font license :-p But why require (throw an error if non existing) it?
 
@Johannes_B Like I say, I suspect 'history'. It's likely been the default for a long time, so existing documents are written expecting it to be loaded silently.
@Johannes_B Also, is there an alternative?
 
@JosephWright Alternative to what?
 
@Johannes_B The font required: remember it's got to be in the correct encoding (some 7/8-bit thing, but not a standard one apparently)
 
9:16 AM
@JosephWright Apperently there is culmus for Linux users. So, not exactly an alternative.
1
A: Installing hebrew (culmus) on Mac using TexLive

GuyYou should follow the instructions in: http://www.guyrutenberg.com/culmus-latex/ (I'm the author of culmus-latex)

 
@Johannes_B Not sure what encoding it uses
 
@JosephWright Me neither, and the most unfortunate thing: i am not experienced with fonts and font encodings.
 
@Johannes_B Not much experience here either but I do know that encodings matter :-)
 
@JosephWright I guess i'll write a mail to the author. Showing some problems, asking for some improvements.
 
9:37 AM
@egreg good morning:-)
@egreg know anything about Greek? tex.stackexchange.com/users/11905/kornaros
 
@DavidCarlisle I just saw bad kerning in the user's name
 
@egreg blame his parents?
 
@egreg ooh keming. :)
@DavidCarlisle LOL
 
I have to say, i am not sure i understand the question.
1
Q: Two lines chapters with Koma-Script

GastónI'm using Koma-Script (scrbook class). I want chapters with two lines: This is line number one which contains the title of the chapter This is line number two which contains the subtitle of the chapter Eeach one of them with diferent styles. How can I do this? Clarification: The behaviour I...

 
@Johannes_B one could probably use \dictum for the subtitles
 
9:52 AM
@cgnieder hi Clemens! You've got a new photo, haven't you? :)
 
@cgnieder True, but do you understand the comment of the OP below the answer?
 
@tohecz Hi :) You mean the avatar? Yes, it's new
@Johannes_B no
 
@cgnieder I am not alone :-)
 
@cgnieder yep, that one :)
 
Frank stole my tick:(
 
9:55 AM
@DavidCarlisle higher authority you know
 
@DavidCarlisle Das Tick ist gone!
 
@tohecz You mean the real authority is the one introducing the bug. OK :-)
@PauloCereda Eu desejo que eu era bom em línguas , como você.
 
@Johannes_B :)
 
@DavidCarlisle Eu queria ser bom em idiomas, assim como você. :) Close enough. :)
 
 
1 hour later…
11:14 AM
Hi all, does exist universal way to find coordinates of text block beginning (top-left)? Which works with various document classes, geometry package, etc)?
4
A: Training Tesseract with generated LaTeX files

michal.h21So I investigated option of using LuaTeX's node processing callbacks. Best suited is pre_output_filter which is called when page is ready for the output. I've created simple package, named boxes, which consists of two files: LaTeX package boxes.sty and Lua module boxes.lua. boxes.sty: \Provides...

 
@michal.h21 \pdfsavepos?
 
11:36 AM
@DavidCarlisle I'll try it, thanks
 
 
1 hour later…
1:06 PM
@egreg etoolbox v sed ...
 
@Johannes_B: The OP wants a split chapter title, a large main title and a smaller (fontsize) for the 'subtitle', as logical unit
@Johannes_B: Who are the other guys? You and Joseph? ;-)
 
@DavidCarlisle “You Shouldn't Be Writing Like This”.
 
@egreg That's Why You Should Fix The Source
 
1:40 PM
@ChristianHupfer The subtitle question is with the information given, unclear and not answerable. I provided a solution anyways, what i figured will give a basic construct that can be improved. If the OP wants both parts to be in one logical unit, that means adding an argument to chapter. But why is the OP asking for a new command (which i already defined). I knew this question would make me angry. All the questions i have asked for more clarity, simply ignored.
 
@Johannes_B: Regarding his style of English, it's quite unclear in that sense too. I have not looked until now, but I will do it
@Johannes_B: I think, the OP wants a single chapter command, that does this automatically, not an (very good idea by you, indeed!) extra command \chapsubtitle.
@Johannes_B: You got 10 rep more ;-)
 
@christian Thanks, but what troubles me is »I don't know if there's an easy way to create a command (e.g. \chapterwsub) that do that in Koma-Script.«
@ChristianHupfer Or thas that mean, he wants a wrapper like \newcommand\chapwsub[3]{\chapter[#1]{#2}\chapsubtitle{3}}?
 
@Johannes_B: I am not sure, but the wrapper one would be one of the easiest solutions... How about a second optional argument to chapter, for the subtitle, using xparse?
 
@ChristianHupfer Something like that, yeah.
 
@Johannes_B: I'll try something
 
1:52 PM
@ChristianHupfer But what about »I want that chapter subtitle to be part of the heading. «
@ChristianHupfer And what about addchap. He/she explicitely mentioned it.
@ChristianHupfer The wrapper would need to decide wheter to use a normal chapter, addchap, addchap* or chapter*.
 
@Johannes_B: I think, it's the page headers, i.e. something like from the scrpage2 (yes, I know, there is a new layer ;-))
 
@ChristianHupfer There are so many open questions.
@ChristianHupfer Does he want to have the subtitle added to the header, should it substitute the header ...?
 
Hey guys, how do we say happy birthday in Welsh?
 
@Johannes_B: In my point of view, the \addchap is misleading in this case
@PauloCereda: adsf23k2 in sdfkjl2 ? perhaps?
 
@ChristianHupfer No, that's called Dvorak keyboard. :P
 
1:55 PM
@ChristianHupfer He might use \addchap for all chapters :-)
 
Happy birthday, @BrentLongborough!
 
Happy Birthday @Brent
 
Happy birthday from me too, @Brent ;-)
 
@PauloCereda aha a Party! :D
 
@ChristianHupfer If there the subtitle should go to the header as well, an optional short form would be necessary as well.
 
2:00 PM
@tohecz :set party-mode on :)
We love cake!
 
@Johannes_B ... a fourth argument? ;-)
 
@PauloCereda pen-blwydd hapus
 
@egreg wow!
 
@PauloCereda @DavidCarlisle is not the only one who can use Google.
 
2:35 PM
@egreg I try to teach you some things
 
@DavidCarlisle Go and listen to some trombone!
 
@egreg I'll see if it can play happy birthday
 
@egreg :)
 
2:57 PM
@Johannes_B: Added another solution, using xparse and spending an optional 3rd argument to the chapter command, holding the subtitle, but I omitted any header feature. (And no comments on scrpage2 please ;-))
 
@ChristianHupfer You can simply substitute scrpage2 by scrlayer-scrpage.
 
@Johannes_B: Ok, the syntax of \cfoot etc. did not change?
@Johannes_B: You saw the new KOMA question already ;-)
 
3:20 PM
@ChristianHupfer It was implemented to be backwards compatible in the basic user interface. If you didn't do something fancy (defining new pagestyles), everything will be fine.
 
@Johannes_B: Now tell me: Who are the other two guys? :D
 
@ChristianHupfer And even if you did, a warning will be issued, that you are using obsolete commands.
@ChristianHupfer What two guys?
 
@Johannes_B: You wrote of the CTAN application... 3 guys applied
 
@ChristianHupfer Don't know. You will be notified by mail i guess. It came around on the DANTE ML
 
@Johannes_B: Ah, ok, since I unsubscribed ... damn :D
 
3:32 PM
 
@david @egreg One of you should have enough experience: tex.stackexchange.com/questions/213673/…
 
@Johannes_B the code is wrong:-)
 
3:48 PM
@DavidCarlisle Taken from `kpsewhich exam.cls` ;-)
 
@Johannes_B yes I know, but it's still wrong:-)
 
4:04 PM
@DavidCarlisle So, this is a bug in exam?
 
@Johannes_B well it could be better (but that's true of lots of code on ctan:-) no time now to really look, I just comment on the fragment in your comment on the question
 
@DavidCarlisle Thanks -> @egreg jumped in :-)
 
@Johannes_B A misfeature. Use environ and live happy. ;-)
 
@Johannes_B I leave the easy ones for him, he likes the points
 
@egreg Thanks
@DavidCarlisle Anybody wants to inform the author?
 
4:13 PM
@Johannes_B doesn't lyx have a thing to export the underlying latex file, I guess that's what he needs)
 
@DavidCarlisle You think the guy sent the .lyx to the editor?
 
@Johannes_B that would be my guess (I have never seen lyx and don't have it installed, so my understanding of it is somewhat vague:-)
 
@DavidCarlisle I\ ll try to get more information. Thanks for the hint.
 
I want this T-shirt. ^^
My teachers all spoke with an American accent.
:(
 
4:35 PM
@PauloCereda: My teachers spoke with a German accent, so you have been a lucky fellow... always this complaining :-P
 
@ChristianHupfer Like Frau Blücher? /horses neighing
By the way, it's forty years that Young Frankenstein was released!
 
@egreg: Wtf is Frau Blücher? ;-)
 
@egreg: Well more the way John Cleese is speaking English when playing a German officer in "The lethal joke" ;-)
@egreg: Well, that actress is not German... sounds like Swiss with some cold :D
 
@ChristianHupfer Of course she isn't and couldn't be! There's also inspector Kemp:
 
4:48 PM
@egreg: Oh my :D
 
@JosephWright: Another QWeRTy review in the Late Answers.
QWeRTy = my own meme
 
@egreg Yay!
 
@PauloCereda Actually it was released on 15 December 1974; on today's paper I read an interview to Mel Brooks for the forty years.
 
Hi, any experts on poster creation with LaTeX? I'm building my first one with baposter but the title is crap (line spacing) due to font size in tiKz and the magin on the sides are not symmetrical... I'm all ears open to any comment
 
@egreg Cool! :)
 
5:28 PM
 
@PauloCereda: Number 3 .. the larch :D
 
@JosephWright: When we arrive in this slide, I'll say it's and Brent will play Sousa's Liberty Bell. :)
@ChristianHupfer LOL
@Christian: number 19: the nose.
 
@PauloCereda: The nose?
 
@PauloCereda: Ah, throatwabbler mangrove :D
@PauloCereda: We are joking about MP and @JosephWright appears :D
 
5:44 PM
@ChristianHupfer :P
 
6:02 PM
@Werner Action taken
 
6:15 PM
@Johannes_B problem solved, it was enough to ask ;)
@tohecz Sorry. Forget the headings. — Gastón 5 mins ago
 
@tohecz I still don't understand the issue :-)
@ChristianHupfer Ping! See above.
 
@Johannes_B well, there's obviously no issue at all
 
@Johannes_B: What the f... eh .. heck? What's the matter?
 
@tohecz The whole subtitle thing. As you can see by my questions in the comments, i've been thinking about this subtitle matter.
@ChristianHupfer The subtitleguy commented on my answer.
 
@Johannes_B ah ok, this...
 
6:20 PM
@Johannes_B: I will look immediately...
@Johannes_B: Forget the headings... I told you the same :-P
 
Guys, does the verbatim environment have something along the lines of basewidth={0.5em,0.5em} from listings? I'm trying to typeset the arara logo with a custom typewriter font and I'd like it to look nice. :)
 
@ChristianHupfer Sooo many unanswered questions.
 
@Johannes_B: No, so many unanswerable questions since ill-posed (silly - posted ;-))
 
@ChristianHupfer I meant the Qs i asked in the comments to that subtitle question.
'ELEMENT OF WITH UNDERBAR' (U+22F8)
 
@Johannes_B: Ok, that's true, but my statement is not wrong, I suppose....
 
6:28 PM
@ChristianHupfer Sometimes, it's the language barrier (i think) latex-community.org/forum/viewtopic.php?f=5&t=25361
 
@Johannes_B: Maybe, but it's more often some kind of lazyness and 'do it for me' ... sorry, I am harsh ;-)
 
@ChristianHupfer Or just the missing knowledge how to ask a good question.
 
@Johannes_B: Kitchen time... Pasta con pesto .... this time with true green basil @egreg ;-)
See you later on...
 
@ChristianHupfer Lasst es euch schmecken.
 
Can anyone see my mistake on this one? I had to shift it to (-1,0) on purpose.
1
Q: Complex function plot using TikZ or PGFPlots

GeMirI need to plot some steps of this approximation http://mathoverflow.net/a/27127 but don't know how to start.

I even confused myself this time :)
 
6:32 PM
@Johannes_B: Ja, in einer halben Stunde... Ich hoffe, meine "vielen" Schülerfreunde bei FB haben Dich nicht verschreckt :D
 
@ChristianHupfer To be honest, i didn't look at your profile too closely. Just noticed a krisina?
@ChristianHupfer Don't know her, tough.
 
@Johannes_B: Something like that, yes :D ... Probably you know none of them .... till later on
 
@ChristianHupfer you and @Johannes_B are FB buddies? Are you part of the LaTeX Users Group over there (not that there is much going on, but anyway...)
 
@ChristianHupfer 25 people i may know :-D
@cgnieder Which UG over where?
 
@JosephWright Thanks Joseph.
 
6:35 PM
@cgnieder @ChristianHupfer tracked me down. I wonder how he did it.
 
@Johannes_B Did you “like” Dante's post you've posted here?
 
@cgnieder Don't know, did i?
 
@Werner sorry for the noise... I meant to answer @Johannes_B
 
@cgnieder nu gugge, Frank the Tank is a member as well.
 
@cgnieder Too bad, I joined the page. :-|
 
6:38 PM
@Johannes_B yes, looks like it :)
@Werner :) well, so did I
 
@cgnieder :)
 
@cgnieder Frank was giving a little talk on modifying biblatex styles last thursday at our regulars table.
 
@Johannes_B Is he the one who posted the blog article on texwelt?
 
@cgnieder Jep.
Guys, gotta go. See you later.
 
@Johannes_B there's also facebook.com/groups/tex.latex
 
6:44 PM
For the duckers...
 
7:39 PM
Does anyone have an idea about my printing problem? Surely I'm not the only one experiencing this. I would post a bounty but I'm worried the problem is too localized and not really about TeX. tex.stackexchange.com/questions/213201/…
 
8:02 PM
@AndrewCashner Could you try with another previewer? I think I once got stuck with some similar problem (I suspect it was with evince as well), and changing the previewer solved my problem.
 
@PauloCereda Normally I use mupdf for quick previews but it doesn't print. acroread prints but everything is light gray (some default print quality setting I imagine). if you have any suggestions for previewers that work under Gnome I welcome them. I tried installing 'okular' but with all the dependencies it frightened me.
@PauloCereda I'm pretty happy printing with lp for myself but I'm worried that other users (say on Mac or Windows) will have the same problems with the PDF.
 
@AndrewCashner apvlv :)
then :pr
 
@PauloCereda Ooh, it has "vim-like behaviour" according to apt!
 
@AndrewCashner @David's top choice. :)
 
@PauloCereda And apparently aptitude is British from the spelling
 
8:08 PM
@AndrewCashner vim like behaviour: incomprehensible and useless?
 
@AndrewCashner good! :) + APT
 
@DavidCarlisle Efficient, minimal, powerful?
 
@AndrewCashner no, that's sed :-)
 
@DavidCarlisle !
 
@PauloCereda have you finished faking the transcript of the interview yet?
 
8:11 PM
@PauloCereda So when I launch this previewer and hit all caps can I destroy my computer in just a few keystrokes like I can with vim?
 
@DavidCarlisle Close, I'm adding some dragons and fights. :)
@AndrewCashner Of course you can. :)
 
@PauloCereda Did you ever use cmus, the console music player based on Vim keystrokes? It's fantastically un-user-friendly but for some reason (probably the same reason I like vim) I like it.
 
@AndrewCashner ooh let me try it.
 
@DavidCarlisle I presume for all your real work you're using ed:)
@PauloCereda zxcv are the play controls or something like that. Numbers 1-4 are different panes with playlists, library, tracks. No menus, though.
 
@AndrewCashner There was a time that wasn't so far from the truth;-) but then I used sed then emacs so I never had need of the half baked vi interface:-) Also now I have no printing problems as I have the awesome stable printing system provided by MS Windows
 
8:22 PM
@DavidCarlisle I agree that printing on linux is rough. Did you ever use teletype terminals?
@PauloCereda <3 apvlv so far, but is :p the only print command? (No page selection, etc.?)
@PauloCereda Reread your comment: use apvlv, then lpr, right?
 
@AndrewCashner I think there aren't more options. :(
@AndrewCashner It might be worth a try. :)
 
@AndrewCashner I started on punched cards.
 
@DavidCarlisle Excellent. So are modern text terminal emulators reasonable approximations of output on a teletype? E.g., if you typed "echo hello" then it typed "hello" on the next line?
 
@AndrewCashner yes except you have line edit capabilities eg the backspace key deletes a character rather than just writing ^H after it
 
@DavidCarlisle So the line input had to be correct or else?
 
8:30 PM
@AndrewCashner no but the visual display didn't go back: yes^H^H^Hno would send no when you hit enter
 
@DavidCarlisle Oh, so the paper was for output only. The input was shown on a screen before you entered it? I thought you were actually typing like on a typewriter.
 
@AndrewCashner screen? there was no screen (multiple line screens with edit capabilities came in in my final undergraduate year I think)
 
@DavidCarlisle By "visual display" you meant ink on paper?
 
@AndrewCashner yes exactly but there was a one line buffer so you could correct on that line, but the actual printed text you see wasn't edited in place, you just saw a record of the control characters such as ^H = backspace
@AndrewCashner yes on a long roll
 
@DavidCarlisle Same roll for input and output? What about "the stderr device"?
 
8:35 PM
@ChristianHupfer That's what it should be!
 
@AndrewCashner normally (or you could send to a lineprinter but that was a "pick it up next day" service)
 
@DavidCarlisle And I think having to use lpr separately from my viewer is cumbersome!
 
@AndrewCashner :-) @egreg of course is even older than I am.
 
8:54 PM
Our future maintainer is included. :)
 
9:17 PM
@Johannes_B: Well, in case you should not know: It's possible to search people on FB ;-)
@cgnieder: I am not a member of that group
 
@percusse Hello, are you around, please?
 
9:35 PM
Good night everyone.
 
@AndrewCashner it's that a hello or a goodbye? :)
 
@tohecz At your service
 
@percusse hi. I have a sound question if you wouldn't mind
 
I wouldn't
 
I've got a 100W combo for my electronic piano (it's made directly by Yamaha for digital pianos and I use it through a mixer). I'm thinking about upgrading to a stereo solution. Someone has suggested that it's better to have a separate poweramp and then an unpowered speaker.
And not really being a sound guy myself, I'm looking for more opinions of experienced people
 
9:48 PM
@tohecz Combo meaning you have an speaker with a built-in preamplifier on it?
 
@percusse yep, you simply feed it unamplified sound directly from the piano or a mixer
 
@tohecz That someone suggests to buy a PA head and speaker separately
am I getting it right?
 
PA head = powered mixer or just an amplifier?
I got suggested to have: seperate mixer -> seperate stereo amp -> 2x seperate speakers
 
Power amp
 
so yes, you're getting it right
 
9:51 PM
@tohecz I have to invoke the usual and boring question. Where do you plan to use it mostly?
 
@percusse at home and at small performances
and I basically plan to run: 2 elec. pianos, a microphone, PC input. Hardly anything more. (the mixer I've got is capable of this).
 
There are two issues with any instrument. You can have a monitor for yourself and send the signal to the mixer and let the mixer handle. Or you basically have a smaller but more precise head+speaker and mic that one and send it to the mixer.
So you can send your main keyboard signal to the sound system, and send a split to your keyboard amp so you can hear yourself
That is the common I don't have money for an amp solution
 
@percusse and if I had money for a proper solution, what would you suggest?
 
Or if you are too picky you can set up your own environment with a separate head and a speaker lower in power but precise.
They call it a head because it usually sits on top of the speaker.
There is some urban legend associated with the combos
 
@percusse ah ok, got it. Well, mine would probably sit in a rack
@percusse well I know, most (guitar/bass) combos are exactly like that
 
9:56 PM
Many guitar players tend to believe that on-board preamps are one-size-fits-for most type of settings
so they tend to be sucky
I don't believe that much but yea it's your taste. You are free to complain about it.
 
well, what I got to know is that for guitar, you'd have: guitar -> combo (amp atop a speaker) -> microphone in front of the speaker -> mixer guy -> PA whatever
@percusse I don't play a guitar. For the piano, it's already purely electronic, so it doesn't make sense to make it complicated.
 
Anyway, the main advantage of separate head is finer control and much reduced noise and typically less detoriated signal from noise or electronics etc.
So you pump a more natural signal to the speaker.
 
@percusse well, the MSR100 has got a brilliant sound, if you mean this
 
Or if you skip the speaker you can send it to mixer directly.
Often you'll hear things like oh it totally kills the texture bla bla when they mention combos. Everything sounds like <insert your favorite guitar brand>....
 
@percusse well, that's what you do on a larger concert, but if you give a solo performance, then the setup would be: piano + microphone -> on-stage mixer -> powered speaker / PA+speaker, no?
 
9:59 PM
If the room has it's own speakers (main speakers that is), you'll probably plug in to a mixer.
 
00:00 - 22:0022:00 - 00:00

« first day (1485 days earlier)      last day (3440 days later) »